agentic-browser-test

name

agentic-browser-test

description

Use when an Oxy dev or coding agent working in oxy-hq/oxygen-internal needs to create, update, maintain, or run/debug an agentic browser flow under web-app/tests/agentic/. Triggers include 'add a test for…', 'write a flow that…', 'this flow is failing', 'accept the healing recording', 'why did the agentic CI job fail?', 'regression test for the bug I just fixed'. Produces or repairs .flow.test.yml files and routes the dev through triage / healing / cache hygiene. Skip for unit tests (Vitest/cargo nextest), Oxy agent eval tests (.agent.test.yml / .aw.test.yml — the oxy-test-drafter skill handles those), or backend Rust integration tests.

Agentic Browser Test Skill

You are the expert covering all four reasons a developer or coding agent interacts with the agentic browser testing system in oxy-hq/oxygen-internal:

1. Creating a new flow for a new feature or regression. (/test-feature)
2. Updating an existing flow when the product surface changes. (/agentic-test-add-case)
3. Maintaining the suite — accepting healing recordings, fixing broken flows, managing cache hygiene, calibrating budgets. (/fix-agentic-test, /accept-agentic-healing)
4. Running / debugging a failing flow locally or in CI. (/run-agentic-tests, /fix-agentic-test)

The dev should never have to learn the YAML schema, what act: / wait_for: / expect: is, how the action cache works, what Tier-1 vs Tier-2 healing means, or which bucket their new flow lands in. You are the abstraction.

---

Step 0 — Always re-read source of truth (every invocation)

The runtime, schema, and authoring conventions evolve fast. Before writing or repairing any YAML, read these source-of-truth files (this skill is colocated in the same repo, so paths below are repo-relative). Do not cache them across invocations.

Canonical sources (PR #2275 shipped the suite; subsequent commits on main may have evolved the surface):

1. web-app/tests/agentic/README.md — runner mechanics, step kinds, wait_for: primitives, setup commands, action-cache contract, output format.
2. json-schemas/flow-test.json — schema for .flow.test.yml. Settings keys, enum values, defaults, validation rules.
3. web-app/tests/agentic/canonical-prompts.md — verbatim copy-pasteable step text for cross-flow cache_scope: shared reuse.
4. web-app/tests/agentic/flows/*.flow.test.yml — every existing flow. Canonical authoring examples.
5. web-app/tests/agentic/flows/_budgets.yml — per-flow cost ceilings. When generating a new flow, add an entry here.
6. web-app/tests/agentic/runner/ — runtime source. The authoritative answer to "is this tool / primitive / fixture available?" is in tool-registry.ts, fixtures/reset.ts (note: fixtures/ is a sibling of runner/), cli.ts, action-cache.ts, selectors.ts, healing.ts, lint.ts, secrets.ts.
7. .github/workflows/agentic-tests.yaml — reusable agentic-tests matrix (bucket layout, cache key formula, flow_bucket dispatch input). ci.yaml calls this via workflow_call and exposes the agentic_only fast-path.
8. internal-docs/agentic-browser-testing-spec.md — implementation deep-dive: runtime A/B verdict, post-A.x optimisations, v2 durability mechanism, cache invalidation taxonomy, steady-state cost model, incident retrospective, dated change log.
9. internal-docs/agentic-browser-testing-team-overview.md — team-facing CI mechanics + cost.

If anything in this SKILL conflicts with those files, the files win.

---

Step 1 — Identify the user's mode

The same dev request can map to any of the four modes. Map intent to skill route:

Phrase	Mode	Skill route
"add a test for…", "write a flow that…", "I just built X, test it"	Create	/test-feature
"add a case to chat-ask that covers…", "extend builder-edits-app to also…"	Update	/agentic-test-add-case
"this flow is failing in CI", "the trace shows…", "agentic/builder is red on my PR"	Run/debug	/run-agentic-tests for repro, then /fix-agentic-test for triage
"the runtime staged a healing recording — what do I do?", "PR comment says healing-staging.json is populated"	Maintain (Tier-2)	/accept-agentic-healing <flow>
"selector_drift_events went up but tests still passed"	Maintain (Tier-1)	No action needed — the cache silently re-ranked. Surface for awareness.
"bump CACHE_VERSION", "suite-wide cold rerun"	Maintain (cache hygiene)	/fix-agentic-test (cache health branch)

Ambiguous: ask via AskUserQuestion. Don't guess across modes — creating a new flow when the dev wanted a case-add is wasted work.

Trigger phrases that do NOT activate this skill (delegate)

• "write a unit test for …" → cargo nextest or Vitest.
• "write an oxy agent test" / "draft expecteds for my agent" → oxy-test-drafter skill handles *.agent.test.yml / *.aw.test.yml.
• "test the API endpoint …" → Rust integration tests.
• "test the workflow YAML" → likely oxy-test-drafter.

---

Runtime primitives — the current surface

The runtime is the bespoke runtime (@anthropic-ai/sdk + a custom tool registry driving vanilla Playwright). It exposes exactly the tools / wait primitives / setup commands below. Do not invent any others — the loader and judge throw on unknown values.

Tools (10) — authoritative: runner/tool-registry.ts:TOOLS

Tool	State-changing?	Notes
browser_snapshot	no	Compact a11y-tree text (≤12kB). Optional region: "main" or region: "<css>".
browser_click	yes	5s timeout.
browser_type	yes	Fills (or appends with append: true).
browser_press_key	yes	Single key or chord (Enter, Meta+s, Control+Enter).
browser_keyboard_type	yes	Raw keyboard into the focused element. Required for Monaco — browser_type's selector-based fill picks the hidden textarea wrong.
browser_file_upload	yes	Playwright setInputFiles. Selector points at <input type="file"> (often hidden behind a styled drop zone — the onboarding wizard's id is credential-<key>, so #credential-<key> works). Paths array is repo-relative; absolute paths and .. traversal refused by runner/files.ts:resolveRepoFile().
browser_navigate	yes	Absolute URL or relative path.
browser_screenshot	no	PNG base64. Expensive; the judge already screenshots.
browser_wait_for_selector	no	10s visibility wait.
browser_get_page_text	no	Truncated body.innerText fallback when snapshot is noisy.

Only the six state-changing tools persist into the action cache (tests/agentic/.cache/bespoke-actions.json). Snapshots and screenshots are observation-only.

wait_for: primitives (4) — authoritative: runWaitFor in tool-registry.ts

Primitive	What it waits for
streaming_complete	Chat stream finishes (loading state appears, then stop button hides). 20s appear-window, 240s disappear-window.
network_idle	Playwright networkidle (no requests for 500ms).
selector:<sel>[;timeout_ms=<n>]	Element matching <sel> becomes visible. Default 30s; override via the suffix for legitimately-long waits (build phases, agentic runs).
selector_hidden:<sel>[;timeout_ms=<n>]	Element matching <sel> disappears. Use when the act/wait sequence finishes faster than the UI it triggers — the classic case is warm-replay screenshots before a [data-testid=app-preview-loading] spinner clears.

Setup commands (3) — authoritative: fixtures/reset.ts:SetupCommand

Command	Mode	Notes
reset_test_file	local	Empties demo_project/test.sql. Refuses symlinks / paths escaping repo.
restore_demo_file:<rel>	local	Reverts demo_project/<rel> to git show HEAD:demo_project/<rel>. Used by flows that mutate a demo file (e.g. builder-edits-app editing insights.app.yml) so reruns start from the same canonical state. Refuses paths that escape the repo, contain .., or resolve through a symlink. Reads from HEAD without touching the index.
goto:<path>	both	Navigate to <OXY_BASE_URL><path> before the case starts.

Flow settings — authoritative: json-schemas/flow-test.json

settings:
  runs: 1                                  # int, min 1
  model: claude-sonnet-4-6                 # default; haiku is too flaky as a pickup model
  judge_model: claude-haiku-4-5-20251001
  trace: on-failure                        # on-failure | always | never
  cache_actions: true                      # disables the whole cache when false
  max_steps: 30                            # upper bound on LLM tool-pick iterations PER step
  backend_mode: local                      # local | cloud — picks which oxy boot the runner auto-spawns

• backend_mode: local → oxy start --local --enterprise from demo_project/, runner targets http://localhost:3000.
• backend_mode: cloud → oxy start --enterprise --clean from repo root, runner targets the auth-disabled internal port http://localhost:3001. --clean wipes the Postgres volume so create-org doesn't 409 on rerun. If a backend is already healthy at the resolved URL, the runner uses it as-is and does not respawn (no --clean side effect).
• All flows in a single invocation must agree on backend_mode. The runner errors loudly on mixed-mode loads.

Step cache_scope

steps:
  - act: |
      …canonical step text…
    cache_scope: shared      # 'shared' | 'flow' (default 'flow')

• cache_scope: flow (default): key = sha256(flowFile|caseName|stepIndex|stepText). Recording is private to this flow/case/step.
• cache_scope: shared: key = sha256("shared|" + stepText). Two flows with byte-identical step text share one recording. Used today for (see canonical-prompts.md for the verbatim text):
  • Cloud-mode onboarding prelude (welcome → create-org → skip-invite → blank workspace, plus the Anthropic-key step) in onboarding-blank-workspace.
  • Chat-prelude ("Submit … to the default agent…") shared by chat-ask and threads-list.
  • Builder dialog open (Cmd+I + auto-approve toggle + submit) shared by builder flows.
  • Sidebar navigation: sidebar-app-link-<app-name> and sidebar-thread-link-<thread-id> for flows that click into an app or thread from the sidebar.

Rule: when copying a step verbatim from canonical-prompts.md, opt into cache_scope: shared. When the step body has flow-specific variation, leave at default flow.

Expectations

• assert: <claim> — deterministic, $0. Supported forms (read runner/judge.ts):
  • selector <sel> is visible / is not visible
  • selector <sel> has attribute <attr>=<value>
  • text "<text>" is visible
  • <description> is enabled
  • save button is not visible (IDE-specific 5s waitFor helper)
• judge: <claim> — LLM-as-judge against current screenshot + DOM text. ~$0.002 per call with claude-haiku-4-5-20251001.

Reserve judge: for soft semantic claims. Never judge: something you can assert:.

---

Authoring rules — these matter for cost and reliability

Selectors: hierarchy + multi-strategy durability

Selector preference order (the runtime ranks fallbacks the same way in selectors.ts:materializeStrategies):

1. [data-testid=foo] — most stable. Survives copy edits, i18n, ARIA refactors.
2. role=button[name='Save'] — stable across CSS/Tailwind refactors.
3. text=Save — fragile against copy edits.
4. CSS class / structure (.foo button) — fragile against component refactors.

The runtime auto-records 2–3 fallback strategies per state-changing action. Even a suboptimal primary selector gets durability fallbacks materialized from the resolved DOM at record time. Tier-1 healing silently re-ranks when a fallback wins. So a text= primary isn't fatal — but a recording that never lands on a testid primary defeats the durability story.

Grep web-app/src/**/*.tsx for data-testid="…" before authoring. When a button you need lacks a testid, add one to the source component as a one-line follow-up — it's the most stable long-term option.

Prompt verbosity tradeoffs

Verbose act: prompts with explicit selectors converge faster on cold runs (1–2 LLM iterations vs 5–10), so per-step cost is lower despite more input tokens.

Concrete patterns that earn their tokens:

• Quote the testid verbatim: Click [data-testid=agent-selector-button].
• Number sub-steps for tightly-coupled actions.
• Disambiguate when the page has duplicates: "the file editor's Monaco surface — the TOP one, NOT the SQL results pane below".
• Tool hint when the right primitive is non-obvious: "Use browser_keyboard_type (NOT browser_type — Monaco's hidden textarea makes selector-based fill unreliable)".

Tokens that don't pay rent (the 2026-05-11 tightening pass dropped these):

• Rationale paragraphs explaining why a verb was chosen. If the testid is correct, the rationale is dead weight.
• "Edit @insights" verb prefixes (the Cmd+I dialog auto-prepends @insights).
• Over-cautious disambiguators ("not the Ask mode toggle") when the testid is already unambiguous.
• Radix DropdownMenu prose — the role=menuitem[name='…'] selector carries the same information.

Generate concise prompts. Rationale belongs in YAML comments above the step, not in the step body.

Atomic vs compound act: steps

• Default: atomic. One logical user action per act: step. Each step is its own cache entry — editing one doesn't invalidate the others.
• Compound only when actions are causally coupled. The classic case is the Cmd+I builder dialog: pressing Meta+i twice closes it, so the open + auto-approve-toggle + type + submit sequence has to be one act:. Cap compound steps at 5 actions max.
• Measured: atomic cold $0.34 vs compound cold $0.42 for ide-save; warm tied at ~$0.002. Atomic usually wins on cold cost too.

wait_for: placement

After every act: whose post-condition is non-trivial. Pair each user action with a wait that names the gate proving the action worked:

• chat submit → wait_for: streaming_complete
• navigation → wait_for: "selector:<thing-on-the-new-page>"
• loading spinner clear → wait_for: "selector_hidden:[data-testid=app-preview-loading]"
• network mutation → wait_for: network_idle

Without these gates, the next act: runs before the page is ready and either flakes or burns LLM iterations as the model figures out the page is mid-transition.

Secrets

${VAR} placeholders in act: text. Validated at YAML load time (missing var throws). Substituted only at egress (Anthropic API send + Playwright dispatch). The action cache and result artifact always store the placeholder, never the plaintext.

Current SECRET_ENV_VARS allowlist (in runner/secrets.ts):

• ANTHROPIC_API_KEY
• OPENAI_API_KEY
• GEMINI_API_KEY
• CLICKHOUSE_PASSWORD
• OXY_DATABASE_URL

Adding a new secret requires extending SECRET_ENV_VARS. redactArgs() is a defense-in-depth check — it throws if a plaintext value slips through. Values shorter than 8 chars (e.g. GEMINI_API_KEY=empty) are treated as test stubs and not substituted.

cache_actions: false is no longer required for secret correctness — egress-substitution covers it. Flip to false only for operational concerns like forcing every step cold for a benchmark.

Budgets

Per-flow cost ceilings live in web-app/tests/agentic/flows/_budgets.yml. The reporter compares observed cost against the ceiling and surfaces a ⚠️ in the markdown summary on overage (advisory, never fails CI). When generating a new flow, add a budget entry.

Reasonable defaults:

Shape	cold_usd	warm_usd
Simple (1–3 act steps, no builder / onboarding)	0.30	0.005
Builder / multi-step	0.50	0.01
Cloud-mode onboarding-class	1.00	0.01

--scaffold integration

When the dev has a component path in mind, prefer scaffolding from it:

pnpm test:agentic --scaffold <feature-name> --from <component-path>

runner/scaffold.ts extracts existing testids from the source and pre-populates an act: template with them. Less authoring work + better default selectors out of the gate.

---

Hard rules — red lines

These must show up in every authoring + run command. Encoded in web-app/tests/agentic/README.md's top-level policy section.

1. Read-only against external systems. Never seed/drop/mutate any database, warehouse, port-forward, or shared service from a fixture or flow. The setup-command surface in fixtures/reset.ts is intentionally limited to goto:, reset_test_file, and restore_demo_file: — none of which can make a network call. Cloud-mode flows drive onboarding through the UI wizard rather than API seeding. Any proposed setup command that wants to call out is rejected at code-review.
2. Never type secrets as plaintext. Use ${VAR} placeholders for any value in SECRET_ENV_VARS. Adding a new secret env var requires extending the allowlist.
3. Never auto-promote Tier-2 healing recordings. They stage to .cache/healing-staging.json, not bespoke-actions.json. Promotion requires --accept-healing <flow> so a developer reviews the new selectors before they become ground truth.

These three rules trace back to the 2026-05-06 ClickHouse incident retrospective in internal-docs/agentic-browser-testing-spec.md. Don't paper over them.

---

CI mechanics — what hits the matrix

The agentic-tests job is a reusable workflow at .github/workflows/agentic-tests.yaml (called from ci.yaml via workflow_call, also triggerable standalone via workflow_dispatch with optional flow_bucket and oxy_binary_run_id inputs). A small resolve-matrix setup job emits the bucket matrix as JSON. Flows are grouped into 6 domain buckets (not one job per flow):

Bucket	Flows	Mode	Port
builder	builder-edits-app, builder-rejected-suggestion	local	3000
semantic	semantic-builder-ask	local	3000
ask-agent	chat-ask, chat-panel-agent-switch	local	3000
threads	threads-list	local	3000
ide	ide-save	local	3000
onboarding	onboarding-blank-workspace	cloud	3001

Filename → bucket mapping for new flows:

• builder-* → builder
• semantic-* → semantic
• chat-* → ask-agent
• threads-* → threads
• ide-* → ide
• onboarding-* → onboarding

If a new flow doesn't match any prefix, surface to the dev: "This needs a new bucket entry in the resolve-matrix job's inline JSON in .github/workflows/agentic-tests.yaml. Buckets share backend_mode, so don't add a cloud-mode flow to a local-mode bucket — split the bucket by mode first. Also add the bucket name to the flow_bucket choice list in the workflow_dispatch trigger so dispatch UIs can target it."

ide-compile-error is in flows/ but NOT in any bucket — gated on Monaco SQL diagnostic service shipping. Don't reference it as a CI-live example.

Fast-iteration dispatch: agentic_only=true on workflow_dispatch cuts CI feedback from ~45 min to ~15 min by skipping typos / fmt-web / build-web / smoke / E2E / cargo clippy / cargo nextest:

gh workflow run "CI check" --repo oxy-hq/oxygen-internal \
  --ref <branch> --field agentic_only=true

Bucket cache key:

agentic-actions-${runner.os}-${matrix.flow.name}-${hashFiles(
  'web-app/tests/agentic/flows/*.flow.test.yml',
  'web-app/tests/agentic/runner/runtimes/bespoke.ts',
  'web-app/tests/agentic/runner/runtimes/replay.ts',
  'web-app/tests/agentic/runner/selectors.ts',
  'web-app/tests/agentic/runner/tool-registry.ts',
  'web-app/tests/agentic/runner/action-cache.ts'
)}

Bucket-prefix restore-keys fall back to the most recent cache file for the bucket; per-step entries still warm-replay even when a different flow's YAML moved.

continue-on-error: true is on while calibrating. Flip-off criterion: ≥3 consecutive green main-branch runs.

After each run, if .results/healing.json is non-empty (Tier-2 heal happened) the job posts a PR comment summarizing drift events with the --accept-healing command. /fix-agentic-test walks the dev through what to do with that comment.

---

Action cache + healing model

Cache file: web-app/tests/agentic/.cache/bespoke-actions.json. Schema version: CACHE_VERSION = 3 (defined in runner/action-cache.ts).

Three layers of invalidation

Layer	Trigger	Blast radius
A	CACHE_VERSION bump	Entire cache. Used for shape changes (e.g. multi-strategy selectors in v3).
B	act: / expect: text edited; flow rename; case rename; earlier step inserted/removed. (With cache_scope: shared, only step text matters.)	That step redrives and every subsequent step in the same case. Other cases / flows unaffected.
C1	A recorded fallback selector resolves (primary failed)	No invalidation. Strategies silently re-rank. $0.
C2	All recorded strategies for one action fail	That step redrives cold via intent-aware redrive. New recording staged to .cache/healing-staging.json (NOT main cache). Same downstream blast as B until --accept-healing promotes it.

What does NOT invalidate

• Single testid rename when other strategies resolve.
• Label / copy / i18n edits.
• Tailwind / CSS refactors.
• Wrapper <div> added/removed.
• Prop changes that don't surface in DOM.
• Backend / non-UI changes.
• New flow that doesn't share a cache_scope: shared key.

Tier-1 vs Tier-2

• Tier-1 silent heal (W1.3): a fallback resolved. The cache entry's strategies are re-ranked (winning strategy → rank 0). $0 LLM cost. Logged as selector_drift_events for telemetry. No developer action required — surface it for awareness only.
• Tier-2 staged heal: every recorded strategy failed. The runtime does an intent-aware redrive starting from the partially-replayed page state, stages the new recording to .cache/healing-staging.json, and writes a CI PR-comment summary. Promotion requires pnpm test:agentic --accept-healing <flow>.

The /fix-agentic-test command routes the dev through these tiers correctly. The /accept-agentic-healing command is the thin wrapper for Tier-2 promotion.

---

File shape — what you produce

# yaml-language-server: $schema=../../../../json-schemas/flow-test.json
#
# <one or two lines describing what this flow tests and why>

name: <human-readable summary>
target: <chat | ide | threads | onboarding | any>

settings:
  runs: 1
  trace: on-failure
  cache_actions: true
  max_steps: <pick an upper bound; default 30 is usually fine>
  backend_mode: <local | cloud>      # default 'local'; only set explicitly for cloud flows

setup:
  - <documented setup command>       # see the 3-item table above
  - "goto:/<path>"                    # land on the start page

cases:
  - name: <descriptive case name>
    tags: [<surface>, critical?, regression?]
    steps:
      - act: |
          <one logical user action, with explicit selectors>
        cache_scope: shared          # only if the step text is verbatim from canonical-prompts.md
      - wait_for: <documented primitive>
    expect:
      - assert: <deterministic claim>
      - judge:  <one sentence covering the success criterion>

Filename: web-app/tests/agentic/flows/<descriptive-kebab-name>.flow.test.yml. Lower-kebab. Bucket-prefix the stem (builder-…, chat-…, threads-…, ide-…, onboarding-…) so CI bucketing is unambiguous.

---

Self-check — before handoff

1. Parse-check via the runner's YAML loader

cd web-app
ANTHROPIC_API_KEY=fake-test-key \
  npx tsx -e "import('./tests/agentic/runner/yaml-loader.ts').then(m => m.loadFlow('tests/agentic/flows/<your-file>.flow.test.yml')).then(f => console.log('parsed:', f.name)).catch(e => { console.error(e); process.exit(1) })"

2. Schema-check against json-schemas/flow-test.json

npx --yes js-yaml web-app/tests/agentic/flows/<your-file>.flow.test.yml > /tmp/flow.json
npx --yes ajv-cli@latest validate -s json-schemas/flow-test.json -d /tmp/flow.json

3. --dry-run lint

Run the durability lint and surface findings to the dev:

cd web-app && pnpm test:agentic --dry-run <flow-stem>

The lint warns about text= only, bare CSS structure selectors, and steps with no selector hint at all. Two ignored warnings is fine for the current canonical flows (file-input id selector + oxymart text table-picker are the legitimate ones); more than two means the generated flow has room to improve — add testids / role+name selectors where the lint flagged.

4. Budget entry

When generating a new flow, append an entry to web-app/tests/agentic/flows/_budgets.yml using the defaults table above.

5. CI bucket assignment

Tell the dev which bucket the new flow lands in based on its filename prefix. If none matches, surface that they need to add a new bucket entry.

If any check fails, iterate. Don't hand off broken YAML.

---

Handoff message

After the file is written and self-checks pass:

1. Path to the new/updated file + the bucket it lands in.
2. First-run command:

   HEADED=1 pnpm test:agentic <flow-stem>
   

   Or /run-agentic-tests <flow-stem> for the wrapped version. The runner auto-spawns the right backend based on backend_mode.
3. Cost expectation vs the budget you wrote into _budgets.yml.
4. Where artefacts land:
   • Markdown report: web-app/tests/agentic/.results/<ts>.md
   • JSON: web-app/tests/agentic/.results/<ts>.json
   • Trace on failure: web-app/tests/agentic/.traces/<flow>-<case>.zip — pnpm exec playwright show-trace <path>
5. Slash commands the dev should know:
   • /test-feature <description> — create a new flow.
   • /agentic-test-add-case <flow> <description> — extend an existing flow.
   • /run-agentic-tests <pattern> — run with HEADED=1 DEBUG=1.
   • /fix-agentic-test <flow-or-bucket> — triage a failing flow.
   • /accept-agentic-healing <flow> — promote staged Tier-2 healings.

---

Future-proofing — design assumptions that may shift

The bespoke runtime is in active development. Re-read the README each invocation. Likely evolutions to watch:

• Bucket layout per (domain, mode) when cloud-mode coverage lands in builder / ask-agent / threads / ide. Today only onboarding is cloud-mode.
• cache_scope collapsing to shared: true boolean since only two values exist today.
• Structured shorthand DSL (click: / type: / press: step kinds that compile to Playwright tool calls without an LLM round-trip) — discussed for ~40–50× cold cost reduction per pure-mechanical step. Not committed.

When the dev asks for something the current README doesn't support, say so explicitly and offer a workaround using what's documented.

---

Guardrails

• Never invent setup commands, wait_for: primitives, assert: forms, or CLI flags the README / source doesn't document. The loader and judge throw on unknowns or silently ignore them — either way the flow breaks.
• Never put real secrets in the YAML. Use ${VAR} placeholders; ensure the var is in SECRET_ENV_VARS.
• Never edit a flow whose name suggests it's actively in use (chat-ask, ide-save, onboarding-blank-workspace, etc.) when the dev is asking for a new flow. Create a new file. Use /agentic-test-add-case only when the dev explicitly says so.
• Never use cache_actions: false as a "make it work" hack. Flaky warm-replay is a runtime bug — file it against the runner.
• Never hand off YAML that hasn't passed parse + schema + dry-run lint.
• Never auto-promote Tier-2 healing recordings; route the dev to /accept-agentic-healing instead.

---

Last verified against oxy-hq/oxygen-internal main after PR #2275 merged at 80023e576 (2026-05-19).