cswin32-com

name	cswin32-com
description	Guides struct-based COM interop in MSBuild using CsWin32 patterns. Consult when working with ComScope<T>, ComClassFactory, IComIID, IID.Get<T>(), delegate* unmanaged vtables, CoCreateInstance, or manually defining COM interfaces not in Win32 metadata (e.g. WMI IWbemLocator, IWbemServices).
argument-hint	Describe the COM interface or activation pattern you are working with.

CsWin32 COM Interop Guide

Struct-based COM interop using CsWin32 patterns — AOT-compatible, no [ComImport] or built-in marshalling.

Paired skill: cswin32-interop covers general P/Invoke and the blittable signature rules that apply to both [DllImport] and COM vtables. This file covers only the COM-specific layer.

Workflow

1. Interface in Win32 metadata? Add the name to src/Framework/NativeMethods.txt → CsWin32 generates it. Not in metadata (WMI, Fusion, Setup Configuration) → define a manual struct under its own folder, excluded from source builds via <Compile Remove>.
2. Lifetime: using ComScope<T> scope = new(); for every transient COM pointer (CoCreateInstance, QueryInterface, IEnumXxx::Next, factory output, app-local STDAPI Get*, etc.). Never write T* local; try { ... } finally { local->Release(); } — that's the pre-ComScope shape that leaks on every early return. Same for BSTR out-params: using BSTR x = default;.
3. Activate via ComClassFactory.TryCreate(CLSID, ...) (AOT-compatible) or PInvoke.CoCreateInstance with IID.Get<T>() — not &localGuid.
4. Call via scope.Pointer->Method(...). Pass ComScope<T> directly where the API expects T** / void** — the implicit operator does the address-of.
5. Match the caller's error contract. If the top-level consumer swallows COM failure ("no result" == "absent"), helpers return default / false instead of throwing a COMException that's immediately discarded. ThrowOnFailure only when the exception will actually propagate or assert a should-never-happen.
6. Guard with #if FEATURE_WINDOWSINTEROP — add && NET only when the struct uses the static-abstract IComIID form exclusively (no net472 dual-target).

Manual COM Structs (Not in Metadata)

Define each interface in its own file under e.g. src/Tasks/AssemblyDependency/Fusion/, src/Framework/Shared/VisualStudio/, src/Framework/Utilities/Wmi/. Exclude from source builds. Pattern (dual-target — works on net472 + .NET):

internal unsafe struct IAssemblyCache : IComIID
{
    public static readonly Guid IID_IAssemblyCache = new(0xE707DCDE, ...);

#if NET
    static ref readonly Guid IComIID.Guid
    {
        [MethodImpl(MethodImplOptions.AggressiveInlining)]
        get => ref Unsafe.AsRef(in IID_IAssemblyCache);
    }
#else
    readonly ref readonly Guid IComIID.Guid
    {
        [MethodImpl(MethodImplOptions.AggressiveInlining)]
        get => ref Unsafe.AsRef(in IID_IAssemblyCache);
    }
#endif

    private readonly void** _lpVtbl;

    // IUnknown at indices 0-2, then interface methods at 3+
    public HRESULT QueryInterface(Guid* riid, void** ppvObject)
    {
        fixed (IAssemblyCache* pThis = &this)
            return ((delegate* unmanaged[Stdcall]<IAssemblyCache*, Guid*, void**, HRESULT>)_lpVtbl[0])(pThis, riid, ppvObject);
    }
    // AddRef @1, Release @2, then interface methods at correct slot indices.
}

Rules:

• delegate* unmanaged[Stdcall] for the function-pointer cast — IDL STDMETHODCALLTYPE ⇒ __stdcall on Win32. Picking the wrong convention silently corrupts the stack.
• IComIID has two shapes: static-abstract (static ref readonly Guid IComIID.Guid) on .NET 7+, instance (readonly ref readonly Guid IComIID.Guid) on net472 / netstandard2.0. CsWin32 picks the right one for its generated structs automatically (see IComIID across TFMs); a manual struct must spell out both arms itself. For .NET-only structs (WMI), drop the #else branch and gate the whole file #if NET. For dual-target structs (Fusion), keep both as shown — see src/Tasks/AssemblyDependency/Fusion/ for the canonical example.
• Use CsWin32-generated PCWSTR / PWSTR for wide strings (add to NativeMethods.txt); raw char* only when no typed equivalent exists.
• Vtable slots are exact: index 0 = QueryInterface, 1 = AddRef, 2 = Release, 3+ = interface methods in IDL order. When inheriting, add the parent interface's method count before counting your own (e.g. ISetupConfiguration2.EnumAllInstances is at slot 6 = 3 IUnknown + 3 v1 + 0).
• CS0592 prevents [SupportedOSPlatform] on structs — put it on individual methods.

Lifetime & Access

A raw T* (COM struct) is forbidden as a field on a non-ref type. Allowed locations: locals in unsafe methods, parameters, fields of a ref struct. Anywhere else (instance fields of class / non-ref struct) → use AgileComPointer<T> — a raw pointer field is an apartment-agility hazard and leaks on finalize-without-Dispose.

ComScope<T> — transient pointers

ref struct, using'd, calls Release on dispose. The default for everything that doesn't survive the current method. Implicitly converts to T** and void**, so out-params write into the scope directly:

using ComScope<ISomeInterface> scope = new();
Guid clsid = SomeStruct.CLSID;
Guid iid = IID.Get<ISomeInterface>();
PInvoke.CoCreateInstance(&clsid, null, CLSCTX.CLSCTX_INPROC_SERVER, &iid, scope).ThrowOnFailure();
scope.Pointer->DoThing(...);

using ComScope<IOther> other = new();
Guid otherIid = IOther.IID_IOther;
scope.Pointer->QueryInterface(&otherIid, other).ThrowOnFailure();

• Access methods via scope.Pointer->Method(...). Null-check with scope.IsNull.
• Applies to every COM out-param: CoCreateInstance, QueryInterface, IEnumXxx::Next, factory methods, app-local STDAPI Get* (declare the [DllImport] with T** pp, not out T*, so the implicit operator binds).

Ownership transfer out of a helper. A helper that acquires a COM pointer can return ComScope<T> directly; intermediate pointers stay in their own using scopes and Release on the helper's return. default ComScope<T> is null and its Dispose is a no-op, so callers don't need an extra null guard:

private static ComScope<ISetupConfiguration2> AcquireSetupConfig()
{
    Guid clsid = SetupConfiguration.CLSID_SetupConfiguration;
    Guid iid = ISetupConfiguration2.IID_ISetupConfiguration2;

    ComScope<ISetupConfiguration2> config = new();
    HRESULT hr = PInvoke.CoCreateInstance(&clsid, null, CLSCTX.CLSCTX_INPROC_SERVER, &iid, config);
    if (hr.Succeeded) return config;                 // ownership flows to caller
    if (hr != HRESULT.REGDB_E_CLASSNOTREG) return default;

    using ComScope<ISetupConfiguration> v1 = new();  // intermediate, Released on return
    if (SetupConfiguration.GetSetupConfiguration(v1, IntPtr.Zero) < 0 || v1.IsNull) return default;
    return v1.Pointer->QueryInterface(&iid, config).Succeeded ? config : default;
}

// caller:
using ComScope<ISetupConfiguration2> config = AcquireSetupConfig();
if (!config.IsNull) { /* use config.Pointer */ }

BSTR — COM strings

CsWin32-generated; extended in Windows/Win32/Foundation/BSTR.cs with IDisposable. Dispose calls SysFreeString and zeroes the field in place. Scope every COM BSTR out-param with using BSTR x = default; — no manual try/finally + SysFreeString:

using BSTR versionBstr = default;
if (instance->GetInstallationVersion(&versionBstr).Failed) return false;
string version = versionBstr.ToString();
// SysFreeString runs at scope exit.

In-place-only: BSTR.Dispose writes through Unsafe.AsRef(in this), so using must be on the storage location, not on a method-returned copy. Same rule as ComScope<T>.

AgileComPointer<T> — fields outliving a method

Finalizable managed class. Use whenever a COM pointer is stored in a class field (the only legal way — raw T* fields are forbidden, see top of section).

• Registers in the Global Interface Table (thread-agile); finalizer releases if Dispose is missed.
• Access via using ComScope<T> scope = agile.GetInterface(); then scope.Pointer->Method(...). GetInterface() round-trips through the GIT — hoist a single scope to the top of a method when several calls share it.
• Constructor takeOwnership: pass false when the raw pointer is also held by a ComScope<T> that will Release (GIT AddRefs independently); pass true only when no other code path will Release.
• Dispose via the owner's Dispose / DisposeManagedResources (AgileComPointer is managed, not unmanaged — its finalizer is the safety net, not the primary cleanup).

Activation

// AOT-compatible
if (ComClassFactory.TryCreate(IWbemLocator.CLSID, out var factory, out HRESULT hr))
    using ComScope<IWbemLocator> instance = factory.TryCreateInstance<IWbemLocator>(out hr);

// CoCreateInstance — IID.Get<T>(), not &localGuid
Guid clsid = IWbemLocator.CLSID;
using ComScope<IWbemLocator> locator = new();
hr = PInvoke.CoCreateInstance(&clsid, null, CLSCTX.CLSCTX_INPROC_SERVER, IID.Get<IWbemLocator>(), locator);

Error-Handling Parity When Migrating

Struct-based COM returns raw HRESULT; [ComImport] and built-in activation threw automatically. Preserve the old throw-vs-return at each call site:

Old shape	Threw via	Migrated shape
new SomeCoClass()	built-in activation	PInvoke.CoCreateInstance(...).ThrowOnFailure()
(IFoo)rcw cast	InvalidCastException on QI	QueryInterface(&iid, scope).ThrowOnFailure()
[ComImport] method, default PreserveSig=false	marshaller throws on FAILED(hr)	.ThrowOnFailure() at the call site
[ComImport] method with [PreserveSig]	caller inspects return	mirror the existing hr branch — don't start throwing

Factory-method exception: when the old contract was "return null for invalid input" (e.g. Create(path)), keep null-return only for the legitimate-rejection path; activation / QI failures still throw. See MetadataReader.cs (throws on activation/QI, returns null on OpenScope).

Don't throw when the caller swallows it. If the top-level consumer wraps the whole chain in catch (COMException) { }, inner helpers must return default / false / empty instead of constructing a COMException only to have it discarded. Throwing here allocates the exception, walks the stack, and hides the HRESULT for no benefit. See VisualStudioLocationHelper.AcquireSetupConfiguration2.

Mocking Struct-Based COM in Tests

Struct-based COM calls go through raw vtable pointers, so a managed mock can't be passed where a T* is expected. Bridge with the built-in COM marshaller: the mock implements the managed interface (BCL System.Runtime.InteropServices.ComTypes.* when ABI-compatible — true for ITypeLib / ITypeInfo — else CsWin32's nested [ComImport] internal interface Interface), and the test passes a CCW (COM-callable wrapper) pointer to the code under test:

// MockTypeLib : ComTypes.ITypeLib   (a normal managed class)
IntPtr ccw = Marshal.GetComInterfaceForObject(mock, typeof(ComTypes.ITypeLib));
try { walker.AnalyzeTypeLibrary((ITypeLib*)ccw); }   // struct API; real QueryInterface works
finally { Marshal.Release(ccw); }

The CCW exposes a real vtable, so no hand-rolled native vtable is needed and the managed mock framework stays intact. But the mock must now behave like real COM, not a managed object:

• All [out] params are written, even ones the caller ignores. Passing null for a trailing out-param (GetDocumentation(-1, &name, null, null, null)) faults the marshaller — supply a real pointer for each.
• Exception identity is lost. An HRESULT-returning method resurfaces a thrown exception as a new COMException (HRESULT preserved, instance not); a uint/void method with no HRESULT channel (GetTypeInfoCount, the Release* methods) swallows it silently and returns garbage. Assert on type/count, not the injected instance, and don't rely on void/uint methods to propagate.
• Throw COMException on bad input, don't Assert. An Assert throws an XunitException that escapes the SUT's catch (COMException); a COMException becomes a failing HRESULT the SUT handles normally. (Matters because a swallowed GetTypeInfoCount failure can feed an out-of-range index to the next call.)

See MockTypeLib.cs / MockTypeInfo.cs and the CCW bridge in ComReferenceWalker_Tests.cs.

Strongly-typed handle / token wrappers

When the native side typedefs a primitive into a family of "same shape, different meaning" aliases (corhdr.h's typedef ULONG32 mdToken; typedef mdToken mdAssembly; ...), mirror that hierarchy with distinct readonly struct wrappers holding the single underlying primitive — same pattern as CsWin32's HANDLE / HWND / HMODULE. Stays blittable; delegate* casts and arrays marshal at zero cost.

Conversions follow the typedef hierarchy: implicit widening to the base (MdAssembly → MdToken, always safe), explicit narrowing ((MdAssembly)token, opt-in because the C side can't enforce the kind at the cast site).

Check the native header for the canonical validation primitives before defining IsNil / IsValid. Encoding details often hide in macros that don't grep cleanly. For mdToken the encoding is (TableType << 24) | Rid:

C macro	Meaning
TypeFromToken(tk) = tk & 0xff000000	Table-type tag (high byte) → CorTokenType
RidFromToken(tk) = tk & 0x00ffffff	Row id (low 24 bits)
IsNilToken(tk) = RidFromToken(tk) == 0	Nil check — rid half, not the whole value
mdAssemblyNil = mdtAssembly = 0x20000000	Per-type nil is the table-type tag, not 0

A naive IsNil => Value == 0 would misclassify the 0x20000000 "no assembly in this scope" return from GetAssemblyFromScope. Mirror the macro: IsNil => Rid == 0. Reference: Tokens.cs, CorTokenType.cs.

IComIID across TFMs

CsWin32 (since 0.3.287) emits IComIID and attaches it to every generated COM struct on all target frameworks — static-abstract static ref readonly Guid Guid { get; } on .NET 7+, instance ref readonly Guid Guid { get; } on net472 / netstandard2.0. No hand-authored polyfill is needed; the old src/Framework/Polyfills/IComIID.cs + IComIIDPolyfills.cs files (one partial per generated struct) are gone.

When you add a new CsWin32-generated COM type to NativeMethods.txt, it carries IComIID automatically through ComScope<T> — nothing extra to do.

Only manual structs (WMI, Fusion, Setup Configuration, CLR metadata) implement IComIID by hand, matching the per-TFM shape — see Manual COM Structs. IID.Get<T>() (IID.cs) reads it via T.Guid on .NET and default(T).Guid on net472.

File Organization

Location	Contents
src/Framework/Windows/Win32/System/Com/	ComScope, ComClassFactory, AgileComPointer, GlobalInterfaceTable
src/Framework/Windows/Win32/IID.cs	Generic IID lookup
src/Framework/Utilities/Wmi/, src/Framework/Shared/VisualStudio/, src/Tasks/AssemblyDependency/Fusion/, src/Tasks/AssemblyDependency/Metadata/, src/Tasks/TypeLib/	Manual COM struct interfaces — own folder per API surface

CS3016 CLS Compliance

CsWin32 (since 0.3.287) auto-emits [CLSCompliant(false)] on every generated COM struct wrapper that carries CCW thunks (the [UnmanagedCallersOnly(CallConvs = new[] { ... })] array argument is what trips CS3016), and adds CS3019 / CS3021 to its own generated-file #pragma warning disable list. So a CLS-compliant assembly ([assembly: CLSCompliant(true)]) builds clean with no consumer action — the hand-authored GeneratedInteropClsCompliance.cs partial and the .editorconfig CS3019 suppression for {**/Windows/**/*.cs} are gone.

The attribute is only emitted on .NET 5+ TFMs (net472 / netstandard2.0 have no CCW thunks, so no CS3016) and only for internal wrappers (the generator default). Don't re-add per-type [CLSCompliant(false)] partials or blanket NoWarn. See https://github.com/dotnet/roslyn/issues/68526 for the underlying Roslyn limitation that motivated the generator-side fix.