ap2-cryptographic-signing

name	ap2-cryptographic-signing
description	Implement AP2 cryptographic signing — hardware-backed user signatures, merchant entity signatures, VDC integrity, key management, and attestation flows. Use when building the signing, verification, and key management components of AP2 mandates.

AP2 Cryptographic Signing

Before writing code

Fetch live docs:

1. Fetch https://ap2-protocol.org/specification/ for cryptographic signing requirements
2. Fetch https://ap2-protocol.org/topics/privacy-and-security/ for security architecture
3. Web-search site:github.com google-agentic-commerce AP2 signature mandate for signing implementations
4. Web-search ap2 protocol VDC signing cryptographic hardware-backed for community guides

Conceptual Architecture

Why Cryptographic Signing Matters

AP2's core innovation is verifiable intent — cryptographic proof that:

• The user authorized a specific transaction
• The merchant committed to specific terms
• Neither party can deny what they agreed to (non-repudiation)
• No intermediary tampered with the mandate (integrity)

VDC Credential Format

AP2 VDCs use the SD-JWT with Key Binding (+kb) format, enabling selective disclosure and cryptographic holder binding.

Supported Signing Algorithms

AP2 supports ECDSA with the following algorithm/curve combinations:

• ES256 — ECDSA with P-256 curve
• ES384 — ECDSA with P-384 curve
• ES512 — ECDSA with P-521 curve

JSON Canonicalization (JCS)

Before signing, JSON payloads are canonicalized using JCS (RFC 8785) to produce a deterministic byte representation. This ensures that logically equivalent JSON objects produce the same signature regardless of key ordering or whitespace.

Detached JWS for Merchant Authorization

The merchant_authorization field on Cart Mandates uses Detached JWS format:

<base64url-header>..<base64url-signature>

Note the double dots — the payload is omitted from the JWS because it is the JCS-canonicalized CartContents, which the verifier already possesses.

JWT Header and Payload Requirements

JWT header MUST include:

• alg — The signing algorithm (ES256, ES384, or ES512)
• kid — Key identifier for the signing key

JWT payload for merchant_authorization includes:

• iss — Issuer (merchant identifier)
• aud — Audience
• iat — Issued-at timestamp
• exp — Expiration timestamp
• jti — Unique JWT identifier
• cart_hash — Hash of the canonicalized cart contents

Two Types of Signatures

User Signatures

• Hardware-backed device keys — Generated and stored in secure hardware (TPM, Secure Enclave)
• In-session authentication — User must authenticate (biometric, PIN) at signing time
• Attestation — Device provides cryptographic proof of the signing context
• Purpose — Proves the user explicitly authorized the transaction

Merchant Signatures

• Entity-level — Signed by the merchant organization, not by the AI agent
• Fulfillment guarantee — Commits the merchant to the stated terms
• Key management — Organizational-level key infrastructure
• Purpose — Proves the merchant committed to specific products/prices

What Gets Signed

VDC	Signed By	What's Covered
Cart Mandate	Merchant + User	Exact items, prices, totals, payment methods
Intent Mandate	User	Shopping constraints, categories, intent, TTL
Payment Mandate	User	Payment method selection, transaction amount

Trusted Device Surface

The user signing step (especially for Cart and Payment Mandates) involves:

1. Shopping Agent triggers redirect to trusted device surface
2. User's device displays the transaction summary
3. User authenticates (biometric, PIN, passkey)
4. Device generates signature using hardware-backed key
5. Attestation object created proving the signing context
6. Signature + attestation returned to Shopping Agent

This is a load-bearing security step — the agent cannot bypass it.

Signature Verification

Verifiers check:

1. Signature validity — Cryptographic verification against the signer's public key
2. Signer identity — Public key belongs to the claimed entity
3. Content integrity — Signed content matches the mandate contents
4. Temporal validity — Signature was created within acceptable timeframe
5. Attestation validity — Device attestation is genuine (for user signatures)

Non-Repudiation

Signed mandates provide non-repudiation for disputes:

• User can't deny they authorized a purchase (their device signed it)
• Merchant can't deny their offer terms (their entity signed it)
• The cryptographic evidence is deterministic, not inferred

Key Management Considerations

• User keys: Managed by the user's device secure hardware
• Merchant keys: Managed at the organization level (HSM or key vault)
• Key rotation: Support for rotating keys without breaking verification
• Key revocation: Ability to revoke compromised keys
• Certificate chain: Trust chain from key to identity

Man-in-the-Middle Prevention

VDC signatures prevent MITM attacks:

• An attacker cannot modify mandate contents without invalidating signatures
• End-to-end integrity from creation to verification
• Digital signatures cover the complete mandate payload

Best Practices

• Always use hardware-backed keys for user signatures when available
• Never store private signing keys in agent code or config
• Implement proper key rotation procedures
• Verify all signatures before trusting mandate contents
• Store signed mandates with signatures for dispute resolution
• Use standard cryptographic libraries — don't implement crypto primitives
• Test with both valid and invalid signatures
• Handle signature verification failures gracefully with clear errors
• Log all signing and verification events for audit

Fetch the specification for exact signature formats, supported algorithms, attestation requirements, and verification procedures before implementing.