proofloop-herdr-sol-luna-fable-planr

name

proofloop-herdr-sol-luna-fable-planr

description

Coordinate Planr-backed or project-configured Herdr workflows in which Sol owns intake, architecture, design-sensitive implementation, integration, and the final decision; Luna Max serves only as an explicitly selected read-only silent sentinel, fresh bounded verifier, or interactive operator; and Fable supplies at most one independent semantic challenge or final review. Use for bounded Sol-Luna-Fable implementation runs with Planr task sources, explicit ownership, evidence, budgets, or pane lifecycle safety; do not use for trivial edits, hidden background processes, or overlapping writers.

Proofloop Herdr: Sol, Luna, Fable, and Planr

Keep Sol responsible for the task, architecture, sole-writer implementation, integration, and final decision. Add another agent only when its distinct role materially improves the run.

Start from project policy

1. Discover the repository root with its version-control or project tooling; otherwise use the explicit working directory.

2. Read the applicable AGENTS.md files and locate the project profile they name. If none exists, adapt assets/project-profile.template.json and the AGENTS.md template inside the project before orchestrating.

3. Create one run contract from assets/run-contract.template.json. Keep allowed paths project-relative and choose one literal validation command.

4. Validate both documents:

   python3 scripts/validate_config.py path/to/project-profile.json path/to/run-contract.json
   

Stop if policy, scope, ownership, or the source task is ambiguous. Never inspect credential contents or copy credentials into prompts, logs, contracts, or evidence.

Select the smallest useful topology

• Use Sol only for ordinary implementation and deterministic validation.
• Add one Luna Max silent sentinel only when the run contract explicitly selects it for a long-running Sol implementation. luna_mode: null creates no Luna pane or process. Start it only with scripts/silent_sentinel.py; the script refuses an unselected mode and exits at settlement, owner loss, mandatory stop, or its deadline.
• Add one fresh Luna Max bounded verifier only when project policy selects it and independent verification is worth a separate session.
• Add one fresh Luna Max interactive operator only for sustained UI or manual interaction that cannot be represented by the validation command.
• Ask Fable once per hypothesis, either before implementation to challenge it or afterward for final semantic review. Do not use both by default.

Do not overlap writers. Luna never edits product source, tests, task state, or documentation. Fable challenges or reviews but does not write. Human owners decide subjective or manual acceptance. Sol resolves all findings and makes the final decision.

Run the loop

1. Read policy and validate the profile and run contract.
2. Run python3 scripts/test_distillation_gate.py snapshot before the first edit.
3. Start the optional silent sentinel only when selected.
4. Execute the declared BUILD or HARDEN phase; do not add tracked tests while implementation changes.
5. Run the exact focused validation command, then test_distillation_gate.py settle.
6. Use optional independent review once. Sol integrates the decision.
7. Stop workflow-owned processes, clean panes, and return one evidence-backed handoff.

When a sentinel stops, its bundled runtime atomically archives the final state and records the archive path in the process record. Sol and the parent workflow must never delete or manually rename the sentinel state. Resolve cleanup.sentinel_process_record to an absolute path before prompting Luna; require Luna to repeat that exact path verbatim after exit or report MISSING at that path. Never let an agent infer an evidence filename from a naming convention.

The lifecycle is BUILD -> ACCEPT -> HARDEN -> DISTILL -> PROMOTE OR DROP. New HARDEN work requires a new contract and baseline. Temporary probes stay in the ephemeral directory and are removed before settlement. Production code is not subordinate to speculative tests: classify failures as BUG, BAD_ORACLE, or LOW_VALUE. See references/testing.md.

Read references/orchestration.md when operating Herdr panes, defining evidence, handling stop conditions, or migrating an existing workflow. Use the Planr example when the task source is a Planr item.

Preserve pane ownership

Reuse a pane only when its target, working directory, purpose, and current state are known and it contains no active user work. Record whether each pane pre-existed and whether the workflow created it. Close only exact pane IDs marked created_by_workflow: true. Stop workflow-started sessions in reused panes but leave those panes open. A sentinel remains silent while healthy, sends only deduplicated event notices, exits at its deadline or settlement, and is never detached as a daemon. Never leave completed sentinel or verifier panes behind.

Return one handoff

Report the task and source, sole writer, topology used, files changed, validation command and semantic result, evidence paths, independent findings and Sol's decision, manual acceptance still required, stop conditions encountered, and pane cleanup status. Do not claim manual quality without its human owner's acceptance.