stage1-arr-breakdown

name

stage1-arr-breakdown

description

Break down full ARR (ACL Rolling Review) reviewer responses into structured rebuttal units. Use when input contains ARR reviewer fields (Paper Summary, Strengths, Weaknesses, Comments/Suggestions) and numeric scores (Confidence, Soundness, Excitement, Overall Assessment, Reproducibility). Splits weaknesses and comments/suggestions into granular response items while preserving original wording for quoted issues.

Stage 1 · ARR Breakdown Skill (Template Extension)

Apply the shared template first:

• skills/stage1/template/SKILL.md

Then apply only the ARR-specific overrides below.

ARR overrides

Score mapping (required keys)

Extract exactly these five keys (numbers only, decimals allowed):

• confidence <- ARR Confidence
• soundness <- ARR Soundness
• excitement <- ARR Excitement
• assessment <- ARR Overall Assessment (number before = sign)
• reproducibility <- ARR Reproducibility (number before = sign)

Preserved section mapping

• summary <- Paper Summary
• strength <- Summary Of Strengths

Atomic issue source mapping

• weakness-type source <- Summary Of Weaknesses
• question-type source <- Comments Suggestions And Typos (label as suggestion)

Output header and score block

• Header must be exactly: # Stage1 ARR Breakdown
• ## Scores must contain exactly the five keys above.

ARR notes

• ARR scores may include decimals (e.g. 2.5, 3.5). Extract only the numeric part before any = or description text.
• The Ethical Concerns, Datasets, Software, Knowledge Of Paper, and certification fields are irrelevant — ignore them.
• Map Comments Suggestions And Typos to the suggestion section and split it into atomic issues just as weaknesses are split.