| name | expert-medical-record-omissions |
| title | Expert Medical Record Omissions |
| description | Analyzes expert witness reports, depositions, and testimony to identify gaps in medical record review, map conflicts to the full record set, and produce impeachment and admissibility analysis with pinpoint citations. Use when reviewing expert reports for missing medical records, selective review patterns, Daubert/Frye challenges, cross-examination prep, motions to exclude or limit, or rebuttal expert focus in personal injury or medical malpractice litigation. |
| author | CaseMark |
| author_url | https://github.com/CaseMark/skills/tree/main/skills/legal/expert-medical-record-omissions |
| license | Apache-2.0 |
| version | 0.1.0 |
| execution_mode | open |
| jurisdiction | us |
| practice | personal-injury |
| language | en |
Expert Medical Record Omissions
Identify material omissions in expert medical record review and translate them into litigation-ready challenges with pinpoint citations.
Prerequisites
- Complete medical record set with Bates labels and index
- Expert materials: report(s), disclosure, materials-reviewed list, CV, deposition/testimony transcripts, exhibits
- Case theory summary (claims, defenses, causation or standard-of-care theory)
- Jurisdiction admissibility standard (Daubert, Frye, or hybrid)
- Medical chronology or timeline (if available)
Workflow
- Build record inventory and expert review map
- Detect omissions and contradictions
- Rate materiality and litigation impact
- Flag patterns suggesting selective review or bias
- Deliver structured report with pinpoint citations
Record Inventory
For each medical record, capture:
| Field | Entry |
|---|
| Record date | Encounter or service date |
| Provider/facility | Name and specialty |
| Record type | Note, imaging, lab, operative, billing, etc. |
| Bates range | Start–end |
| Key facts | Diagnosis, findings, causation cues |
| Causation relevance | Supports / Contradicts / Alternative / Neutral |
Expert Review Map
Extract from the expert's own materials:
| Item | Source | Citation |
|---|
| Materials-reviewed list | Report or disclosure | Page/paragraph |
| Records cited in opinions | Report | Page/paragraph |
| Deposition admissions about records | Transcript | Page/line |
| Stated limitations or exclusions | Report or deposition | Page/line |
Omission Matrix
One row per omitted record:
| Omitted record | Date | Provider | Bates | Expert statement that should have addressed it | Conflict or gap | Significance |
|---|
