synthesis-report

name	synthesis-report
description	SOP for producing argument synthesis reports — aggregate evidence, resolve contradictions, identify surviving claims, write structured summary.
execution	sop
used-by	argument-synthesis

Synthesis Report

Produce a synthesis report that identifies which claims survive scrutiny.

Tool

vault_query_graph + vault_graph_stats + CC file write

Protocol

1. Query graph for all claims and evidence in the target domain
2. Classify claims by survival status:
   • Survived: strength ≥ 7, no undefeated contradictions
   • Contested: strength 4-6, active contradictions with comparable evidence
   • Undermined: strength ≤ 3, or defeated by stronger contradicting evidence
3. For each contested claim, summarize the state of the debate
4. Write wiki/topics/<topic-slug>-synthesis.md with sections:
   • Surviving claims (high confidence)
   • Contested claims (ongoing debate)
   • Undermined claims (low confidence / refuted)
   • Remaining gaps (claims lacking sufficient evidence either way)
5. Add addresses edges from synthesis page to relevant question pages

HARD-GATE

Must categorize ALL claims for the topic — no claim left unclassified. Synthesis is comprehensive or it is not synthesis.

Yield

Returns: { topic: string, survived: number, contested: number, undermined: number, gaps: number }