devtools-setting-migration

name	devtools-setting-migration
description	Workflow for splitting an existing SettingRegistration into a SettingDescriptor (placed in the lowest layer where used: core/, models/, or ui/settings/) and SettingUIDescriptor (registered in a higher-level -meta.ts file, outside of core/ and models/).

DevTools Setting Migration Guide

This skill guide describes how to migrate an existing legacy SettingRegistration in DevTools by splitting it into a SettingDescriptor (non-UI descriptor) and a SettingUIDescriptor (UI descriptor).

---

Key Principles & Layer Boundaries

1. SettingDescriptor Location ("Lowest Layer")

• Lowest Layer Rule: A SettingDescriptor MUST be placed in the lowest architectural layer where the setting is used.
  • Core / Model Settings: If a setting is used by core/sdk (or models/), its SettingDescriptor should be located in core/sdk (or models/).
  • Panel / UI Settings: If a setting is only used by UI components or a specific panel (e.g. panels/console/), its SettingDescriptor MUST GO INTO ui/settings/FooSettings.ts (e.g. ui/settings/ConsoleSettings.ts where Foo is the panel name).
• CRITICAL RULE — PANEL DESCRIPTORS MUST NOT BE PLACED IN panels/:
  • A SettingDescriptor MUST NOT be placed inside a panels/ directory (e.g. panels/console/ConsoleSettings.ts).
  • Reason: Panel -meta.ts files (e.g. panels/console/console-meta.ts) need to import the SettingDescriptor to call SettingsUI.SettingUIRegistration.register(descriptor, uiDescriptor). -meta.ts files are loaded early and MUST NOT import from panels/ (which would break lazy-loading of panel bundles). Since ui/settings/ is in the ui/ layer below panels/, -meta.ts files can safely import from ui/settings/.
• CRITICAL RULE — MUST NOT BE IN A -meta.ts FILE:
  • A SettingDescriptor MUST NOT be placed in a -meta.ts file.
  • Reason: Actual runtime code (e.g. models, panels, SDKs) needs to import the descriptor directly to call Settings.instance().resolve(descriptor). Preload -meta.ts files are meant for lazy-loaded extension registrations and must not be imported by runtime code to avoid circular dependencies and module boundary violations.

2. SettingUIDescriptor Location (Higher-Level -meta.ts File)

• A SettingUIDescriptor defines UI-specific properties (category, title, tags, options, reload requirement, etc.).
• Higher-Level Meta File Rule: UI registrations MUST BE PLACED IN A -meta.ts FILE ON A HIGHER LEVEL (e.g., entrypoints/main/main-meta.ts, entrypoints/inspector_main/inspector_main-meta.ts, panels/settings/settings-meta.ts, or the specific panel's -meta.ts file).
• CRITICAL RULE — MUST NOT REMAIN IN core/ OR models/:
  • UI descriptors MUST NOT remain in or be added to -meta.ts files under core/ or models/ (such as core/sdk/sdk-meta.ts or models/*/*-meta.ts).
  • Goal: A major goal of this migration is to completely eliminate -meta.ts files in core/ and models/.

3. Resolving Settings vs moduleSetting(name)

• Legacy code retrieves settings using string identifiers: Settings.instance().moduleSetting('setting-name').
• Refactored code should replace moduleSetting('setting-name') with Settings.instance().resolve(settingDescriptor).

---

Step-by-Step Migration Workflow

Given a setting name (e.g., 'preserve-console-log' or 'network-messages'):

Step 1: Locate Existing Registration & Analyze Use-Sites

1. Search for the setting name in -meta.ts files to find its Common.Settings.registerSettingExtension block.
2. Search for all occurrences of 'setting-name' or moduleSetting('setting-name') across the codebase to identify all use-sites.
3. Determine the lowest layer among all use-sites:
   • If used in core/sdk -> Target directory is core/sdk/.
   • If used in models/ -> Target directory is models/<module>/.
   • If used in a panel (panels/foo) or UI -> Target directory is ui/settings/ (file: ui/settings/FooSettings.ts). NEVER place descriptors in panels/.

---

Step 2: Extract & Define SettingDescriptor in the Lowest Layer

Decision Strategy: Create vs. Update File

When placing a SettingDescriptor in the target directory, decide whether to create or update a file using these rules:

1. For Panel / UI Settings (Target is ui/settings/):

   • UPDATE: Check if ui/settings/FooSettings.ts already exists (e.g., ui/settings/ConsoleSettings.ts). If so, add and export the SettingDescriptor there.
   • CREATE: If ui/settings/FooSettings.ts does not exist:
     • Create ui/settings/FooSettings.ts.
     • Add FooSettings.ts to sources in ui/settings/BUILD.gn.
     • Export FooSettings.ts from ui/settings/settings.ts.

2. For Core / Model Settings (Target is core/ or models/):

   • UPDATE: Check if a module-wide settings file exists in that directory (e.g. core/sdk/SDKSettings.ts, models/workspace/WorkspaceSettings.ts). If so, add and export the SettingDescriptor there.
   • UPDATE: If no module settings file exists and the setting is strictly used inside a single file (e.g., ResourceTreeModel.ts), update that .ts file by exporting the SettingDescriptor at the top.
   • CREATE: Otherwise, create <Module>Settings.ts (e.g., core/sdk/SDKSettings.ts), add it to sources in BUILD.gn, and export it from the module's entrypoint (sdk.ts).

Code Definition Example:

Define and export the SettingDescriptor in the target file:

import type * as Common from '../core/common/common.js';

export const preserveConsoleLogSettingDescriptor: Common.Settings.SettingDescriptor<boolean> = {
  name: 'preserve-console-log',
  type: Common.Settings.SettingType.BOOLEAN,
  defaultValue: false,
  storageType: Common.Settings.SettingStorageType.SYNCED,
};

Note: For conditional settings (dependent on hostConfig), use Common.Settings.ConditionalSettingDescriptor<ValueT, ReasonT> with an isAvailable function.

---

Step 3: Move UI Registration to a Higher-Level -meta.ts File

If the original registration was in a core/ or models/ -meta.ts file (e.g., core/sdk/sdk-meta.ts), MOVE the UI registration to a higher-level -meta.ts file (e.g., entrypoints/main/main-meta.ts or panels/console/console-meta.ts).

In the higher-level -meta.ts file:

1. Import SettingsUI from ui/settings/settings.js (e.g., import * as SettingsUI from '../../ui/settings/settings.js';).
2. Import the SettingDescriptor (from core/sdk/, models/, or ui/settings/).
3. Register using SettingsUI.SettingUIRegistration.register(...):

import * as SettingsUI from '../../ui/settings/settings.js';
import * as SDK from '../../core/sdk/sdk.js';

SettingsUI.SettingUIRegistration.register(SDK.SDKSettings.preserveConsoleLogSettingDescriptor, {
  category: Common.Settings.SettingCategory.CONSOLE,
  title: i18nLazyString(UIStrings.preserveLogUponNavigation),
  options: [
    {
      value: true,
      title: i18nLazyString(UIStrings.preserveLogUponNavigation),
    },
    {
      value: false,
      title: i18nLazyString(UIStrings.doNotPreserveLogUponNavigation),
    },
  ],
});

4. Delete the old Common.Settings.registerSettingExtension call from the core/ or models/ -meta.ts file. (If the -meta.ts file becomes empty, delete the file and clean up its build references).

---

Step 4: Update Call Sites (moduleSetting to resolve)

Find all call sites referencing the setting via moduleSetting:

// BEFORE:
const setting = Common.Settings.Settings.instance().moduleSetting('preserve-console-log');

// AFTER:
import { preserveConsoleLogSettingDescriptor } from './SDKSettings.js';
...
const setting = Common.Settings.Settings.instance().resolve(preserveConsoleLogSettingDescriptor);

For conditional settings, use Common.Settings.Settings.instance().maybeResolve(descriptor) instead of resolve(descriptor).

---

Step 5: Update BUILD.gn Files and Module Entrypoints

1. If a new .ts file was created (e.g., SDKSettings.ts or ui/settings/ConsoleSettings.ts):
   • Add the file to sources in its module's BUILD.gn.
   • Export the file from the module's entrypoint (sdk.ts, settings.ts, etc.).
2. If a core/ or models/ -meta.ts file was deleted, remove it from BUILD.gn and devtools_grd_files.gni.
3. Verify module imports strictly follow DevTools import rules (refer to devtools-imports skill).

---

Step 6: Verify Changes

1. Run autoninja -C out/Default to check GN build.
2. Run npm run lint to check style and formatting rules.
3. Run relevant unit tests for the modified module.

---

Concrete Examples

Example 1: Core/SDK Setting Migration (preserve-console-log)

Before Migration

Setting registered in front_end/core/sdk/sdk-meta.ts (Legacy core meta file):

Common.Settings.registerSettingExtension({
  category: Common.Settings.SettingCategory.CONSOLE,
  storageType: Common.Settings.SettingStorageType.SYNCED,
  title: i18nLazyString(UIStrings.preserveLogUponNavigation),
  settingName: 'preserve-console-log',
  settingType: Common.Settings.SettingType.BOOLEAN,
  defaultValue: false,
  options: [...],
});

Setting used in front_end/core/sdk/ResourceTreeModel.ts:

const setting = Common.Settings.Settings.instance().moduleSetting('preserve-console-log');

---

After Migration

1. front_end/core/sdk/SDKSettings.ts (Lowest Layer in Core — NOT a -meta.ts file):

import type * as Common from '../common/common.js';

export const preserveConsoleLogSettingDescriptor: Common.Settings.SettingDescriptor<boolean> = {
  name: 'preserve-console-log',
  type: Common.Settings.SettingType.BOOLEAN,
  defaultValue: false,
  storageType: Common.Settings.SettingStorageType.SYNCED,
};

2. front_end/entrypoints/main/main-meta.ts (Higher-Level Meta File — NOT in core/ or models/):

import * as SDK from '../../core/sdk/sdk.js';
import * as SettingsUI from '../../ui/settings/settings.js';

SettingsUI.SettingUIRegistration.register(SDK.SDKSettings.preserveConsoleLogSettingDescriptor, {
  category: Common.Settings.SettingCategory.CONSOLE,
  title: i18nLazyString(UIStrings.preserveLogUponNavigation),
  options: [...],
});

3. front_end/core/sdk/ResourceTreeModel.ts (Call Site in core/sdk):

import { preserveConsoleLogSettingDescriptor } from './SDKSettings.js';

const setting = Common.Settings.Settings.instance().resolve(preserveConsoleLogSettingDescriptor);

4. front_end/core/sdk/sdk-meta.ts: Registration for 'preserve-console-log' removed.

---

Example 2: Panel UI Setting Migration (network-messages)

Before Migration

Setting registered in front_end/panels/console/console-meta.ts:

Common.Settings.registerSettingExtension({
  category: Common.Settings.SettingCategory.CONSOLE,
  storageType: Common.Settings.SettingStorageType.SYNCED,
  title: i18nLazyString(UIStrings.networkMessages),
  settingName: 'network-messages',
  settingType: Common.Settings.SettingType.BOOLEAN,
  defaultValue: true,
  options: [...],
});

Setting used in front_end/panels/console/ConsoleView.ts:

const setting = Common.Settings.Settings.instance().moduleSetting('network-messages');

---

After Migration

1. front_end/ui/settings/ConsoleSettings.ts (Lowest Layer for UI/Panel Descriptor — NOT in panels/console/!):

import type * as Common from '../../core/common/common.js';

export const networkMessagesSettingDescriptor: Common.Settings.SettingDescriptor<boolean> = {
  name: 'network-messages',
  type: Common.Settings.SettingType.BOOLEAN,
  defaultValue: true,
  storageType: Common.Settings.SettingStorageType.SYNCED,
};

2. front_end/panels/console/console-meta.ts (Panel Meta File — Imports Descriptor from ui/settings/):

import * as SettingsUI from '../../ui/settings/settings.js';

SettingsUI.SettingUIRegistration.register(SettingsUI.ConsoleSettings.networkMessagesSettingDescriptor, {
  category: Common.Settings.SettingCategory.CONSOLE,
  title: i18nLazyString(UIStrings.networkMessages),
  options: [...],
});

3. front_end/panels/console/ConsoleView.ts (Call Site in panels/console):

import * as SettingsUI from '../../ui/settings/settings.js';

const setting = Common.Settings.Settings.instance().resolve(SettingsUI.ConsoleSettings.networkMessagesSettingDescriptor);

---

Interface Reference Summary

SettingDescriptor<T>

Defined in core/common/Settings.ts:

• name: string: Unique setting name (kebab-case).
• type: SettingType: BOOLEAN, ENUM, ARRAY, or REGEX.
• defaultValue: ValueT | ((hostConfig: HostConfig) => ValueT): Default setting value.
• storageType?: SettingStorageType: SYNCED, LOCAL, GLOBAL, or SESSION.

SettingUIDescriptor

Defined in ui/settings/SettingUIRegistration.ts:

• category?: SettingCategory: Category under which setting is listed in Settings UI.
• order?: number: Sorting order.
• title?: () => LocalizedString: Title string displayed in Settings UI.
• tags?: Array<() => LocalizedString>: Search tags for Command Menu.
• options?: SettingExtensionOption[]: Enum / boolean option descriptions.
• reloadRequired?: boolean: Whether setting change requires DevTools reload.
• deprecationNotice?: { disabled: boolean, warning: () => LocalizedString, experiment?: string }: Deprecation notice.
• learnMore?: LearnMore: Help link or tooltip info.