deprecate-best-practice-skill

name	deprecate-best-practice-skill
description	Use when a grimoire skill has become outdated — the referenced tool no longer exists at scale, the source institution revised its position, a newer practice has achieved majority top-tier adoption that supersedes it, or the skill fails review-best-practice-skill criteria it once passed.
source	npm deprecation guidelines, IETF RFC obsolescence process (BCP 9), Semantic Versioning (semver.org)
tags	["skill-maintenance","staleness","deprecation","outdated-practice","maintainer","knowledge-freshness"]

Deprecate Best Practice Skill

Mark an outdated grimoire skill for removal and, where possible, point users to the practice that supersedes it.

Why This Is Best Practice

Adopted by: Explicit deprecation with replacement pointers is standard across all major knowledge systems — npm packages use deprecated metadata with migration notes, MDN Web Docs marks obsolete APIs with explicit "Use X instead" banners, and the Python Package Index surfaces deprecation notices prominently to prevent installation of abandoned packages. Impact: Without deprecation, outdated skills get served to users indefinitely. Research on documentation debt (Aghajani et al., 2019, MSR) found 50–60% of surveyed developers encountered bugs caused by stale documentation; explicit deprecation markers reduce this by surfacing decay at the point of use. Why best: Silent removal leaves users with broken install paths and no migration guidance. Deprecation-with-pointer gives users a safe off-ramp and maintains trust in the repo as a reliable source.

Sources: npm deprecation model, MDN Web Docs obsolescence guidelines, Aghajani et al. 2019 (MSR documentation debt), IETF RFC obsolescence process (BCP 9)

Steps

1. Confirm the skill meets staleness criteria

Before judging these criteria, search the internet to verify the source institution's current guidance, the newer practice's actual adoption level, and whether the referenced tool/API still exists at scale — don't rely solely on training-data recall, which may predate the change prompting this review. If no internet-access tool is available in this environment, say so explicitly and proceed on best available knowledge — flag the claim as unverified rather than silently skipping the check or asserting it was confirmed. After searching, state what was found (or that nothing conclusive turned up) before proceeding — don't just announce the check and discard the result.

A skill qualifies for deprecation if ANY of the following are true:

• The source institution has revised its position and the skill no longer reflects it
• A newer practice has achieved majority top-tier adoption that directly supersedes this one
• The tool or API referenced in the skill no longer exists at scale (abandoned, renamed, or replaced by something with 10× adoption)
• The skill now fails review-best-practice-skill criteria it once passed (e.g., the "Adopted by" claim is no longer accurate)

If none apply, the skill needs updating — not deprecating. Use write-best-practice-skill to revise it instead.

2. Identify the replacement (if one exists)

Situation	Action
A newer grimoire skill supersedes this one	Point to that skill
The practice is superseded but no grimoire skill covers the new approach yet	Note the superseding practice and flag for a new skill to be written
The practice was wrong / never qualified	No replacement — just remove

3. Add a deprecation notice to the skill file

Notice placement: The deprecation notice must appear in the YAML frontmatter as a deprecated: field AND as a banner at the top of the skill body (immediately after the H1 heading), before any other content:

deprecated: 'Replaced by [skill-name] — [brief reason]. Migrate by [date].'

> **Deprecated:** This skill is replaced by [skill-name]. See [skill-name] for the same functionality. Migration deadline: [date].

Placement in frontmatter ensures tooling can filter deprecated skills. Placement in body ensures users see it immediately.

If no replacement exists, omit the replacement reference and use:

deprecated: '[Brief reason]. No direct replacement — see [domain]/[subdomain] for related skills.'

> **Deprecated:** This skill is outdated. [Reason in one sentence.]
> No direct replacement — see [domain]/[subdomain] for related skills.

Do NOT delete the skill file in this step — deprecation precedes removal to give users time to migrate.

4. Update marketplace.json

Find the entry for this skill's domain/sub-domain and add a deprecated flag:

{
  "name": "grimoire-engineering-some-subdomain",
  "source": { ... },
  "description": "...",
  "deprecated": true,
  "deprecation_note": "Superseded by grimoire-meta-replacement-skill"
}

5. Open a PR

PR title: deprecate(<domain>/<skill-name>): <one-line reason>

PR description must include:

• What changed that made the skill stale (source revision, tool abandonment, etc.)
• Link to the superseding practice or skill
• Whether a new skill needs to be written to cover the replacement practice

6. Removal (maintainers only)

Cooling-off period: A deprecated skill must remain installed and functional for at least 30 days after the deprecation notice is added. Do not delete the skill file until:

1. The replacement skill is confirmed installed
2. 30 days have passed since the deprecation notice
3. The migration deadline (if specified) has passed

Premature deletion breaks any user with the old skill in their workflow.

Maintainers remove deprecated skills in the next release cycle after the PR merges. Removal steps:

1. Delete the skill directory
2. Remove from marketplace.json
3. Remove from the domain's .claude-plugin/plugin.json
4. Tag the release with a breaking-change note if the skill had significant install volume

Rules

• Never deprecate without a stated reason — "Deprecated" with no explanation is worse than nothing
• Always check if a replacement skill should be written before deprecating
• Deprecation PR and removal are two separate steps — never delete in the same PR as the deprecation notice
• If a skill is wrong but not stale (e.g., always had incorrect "Adopted by" claims), use review-best-practice-skill + a fix PR instead of deprecation
• Only maintainers perform step 6 (removal)

Common Mistakes

Removing instead of deprecating: deleting a skill file in one PR gives users no warning and breaks install paths. Always deprecate first, remove in the next cycle.

Deprecating because you disagree: deprecation is for staleness, not preference. If the practice is still majority top-tier adopted, open a revision PR instead.

No replacement pointer: "Deprecated" with no guidance forces users to start from scratch. Always name the superseding practice, even if no grimoire skill covers it yet.