メニュー
Use when reviewing a proposed mechanism for flaws. The Skeptic does NOT propose new mechanisms — only stress-tests existing ones with a fixed checklist of bias patterns.
Codex または Claude でインストール この Prompt をコピーして Codex、Claude、または他のアシスタントに貼り付けると、Skill ページを確認してインストールできます。
SOC 職業分類に基づく
Use when compressing a candidate's narrative into a structured EvidenceCard. Teaches the agent the field semantics, what counts as a critical_incident vs resume_claim, and when to mark insufficiency.
Use when interviewing a candidate. Teaches the agent to drive the dialogue around concrete critical incidents rather than abstract self-assessment, and to chase one missing cue per turn.
Use when naming a cognitive mechanism from evidence cards. Teaches the agent what counts as a high-value mechanism vs a soft-skill cliché, and how to express it as a four-part pattern.
Use when coordinating the seven-stage extraction pipeline. Tells the Orchestrator when to delegate, when to gate, when to escalate.
Use when composing the final extraction_report. Teaches how to write candidate-usable resume rewrites and interview narratives, separating validated mechanisms from probable ones.
| name | skeptic-checklist |
| description | Use when reviewing a proposed mechanism for flaws. The Skeptic does NOT propose new mechanisms — only stress-tests existing ones with a fixed checklist of bias patterns. |
| when_to_use | Triggered by the Skeptic agent after Mechanism Modeler emits a mechanism_card. |
你的任务只有一个: 找问题。不要新提机制, 不要替候选人辩护, 不要安抚。
对每张 mechanism_card, 逐项过:
severity: highseverity: mediumseverity: highanti_evidence_ids 为空, 但很可能不是真没有返回一个 ReviewFindings JSON:
{
"mechanism_id": "mech_001",
"findings": [
{"kind": "evidence_duplication", "severity": "medium", "detail": "...", "affected_evidence_ids": ["ev_001", "ev_003"]},
...
],
"repair_actions": [
"downgrade confidence to 0.65",
"add ev_021 as anti_evidence",
"rename to ..."
],
"confidence_delta": -0.15
}
severity: low / medium / high。
confidence_delta: 建议的置信度调整, 范围 [-0.5, +0.1]。