migrate-mdc-to-comark

name	migrate-mdc-to-comark
description	Port a legacy MDC-based PR onto the new comark-based `main`. Use when a contributor's PR was opened against the old `@nuxtjs/mdc` API (any commit before `feat(mdc): comark migration #355`) and now needs to be rebased / merged with the current Nuxt Studio main branch, which uses `comark` everywhere.

Migrating a Legacy MDC PR to Comark

Since commit 5464103e feat(mdc): comark migration (#355) (merged 2026-05-13), Nuxt Studio's main branch no longer uses @nuxtjs/mdc. The entire conversion layer, document utilities, and TipTap bridges were rewritten on top of comark.

Any PR opened against main before this commit will conflict on merge. Do not simply resolve the conflicts mechanically — most legacy API calls have semantic equivalents in comark that must be re-implemented.

This skill is the reverse of the previous "merge-main-on-comark" skill: the comark branch is now main, and legacy PRs need to be ported forward.

1. Identify whether the PR is legacy

Run these checks at the root of the PR branch:

# Legacy imports — any match means the PR predates the comark migration
grep -rE "from '@nuxtjs/mdc'|from 'remark-mdc'|from 'unist-util-visit'|from '@nuxt/content/runtime'" src/

# Legacy function names
grep -rE "generateDocumentFromContent|generateDocumentFromMarkdownContent|generateDocumentFromYAMLContent|generateDocumentFromJSONContent|generateContentFromDocument|generateContentFromMarkdownDocument|generateContentFromYAMLDocument|generateContentFromJSONDocument|mdcToTiptap|tiptapToMDC|compressTree|decompressTree|parseMarkdown|stringifyMarkdown|parseFrontMatter|stringifyFrontMatter|remarkEmojiPlugin" src/

# Legacy file references (these files were deleted on main)
ls src/app/src/utils/tiptap/mdcToTiptap.ts src/app/src/utils/tiptap/tiptapToMdc.ts 2>/dev/null

If anything matches, the PR is legacy.

2. Conceptual Mapping: Legacy MDC → Comark

Types

Legacy (pre-#355)	Comark (current main)
MDCRoot, MarkdownRoot from @nuxt/content	MarkdownDocument from comark
MDCNode, MDCElement, MDCText, MDCComment from @nuxtjs/mdc	MarkdownNode, ElementNode, CommentNode from comark
MDC element: { type: 'element', tag: 'note', props: {…}, children: [...] }	Tuple: ['note', attrs, ...children]
MDC text: { type: 'text', value: 'hello' }	Plain string: 'hello'
MDC comment: { type: 'comment', value: 'txt' }	Tuple: [null, {}, 'txt']

Functions (document utilities)

Located in src/module/src/runtime/utils/document/generate.ts:

Legacy	Comark
generateDocumentFromContent(id, content, opts)	documentFromContent(id, content, opts)
generateDocumentFromMarkdownContent(...)	documentFromMarkdownContent(...)
generateDocumentFromYAMLContent(...)	documentFromYAMLContent(...)
generateDocumentFromJSONContent(...)	documentFromJSONContent(...)
generateContentFromDocument(doc)	contentFromDocument(doc)
generateContentFromMarkdownDocument(doc)	contentFromMarkdownDocument(doc)
generateContentFromYAMLDocument(doc)	contentFromYAMLDocument(doc)
generateContentFromJSONDocument(doc)	contentFromJSONDocument(doc)

The shape generate-X-from-Y was reversed to Y-from-X for symmetry.

TipTap bridges

Located in src/app/src/utils/tiptap/:

Legacy file (deleted on main)	Comark replacement
mdcToTiptap.ts	comarkToTiptap.ts
tiptapToMdc.ts	tiptapToComark.ts
mdcToTiptap(body, frontmatterData, opts)	comarkToTiptap(tree, opts) — options collapsed to a single object; frontmatter is part of the tree
tiptapToMDC(json, opts) → { body, data }	tiptapToComark(json, opts) → MarkdownDocument — returns one tree with frontmatter embedded

Parser / stringifier

Legacy	Comark
import { parseMarkdown } from '@nuxtjs/mdc/runtime/parser/index'	import { parseMarkdown } from 'comark'
import { stringifyMarkdown } from '@nuxtjs/mdc/runtime'	import { renderMarkdown } from 'comark/render'
parseFrontMatter / stringifyFrontMatter from remark-mdc	js-yaml (yaml.load / yaml.dump) for pure YAML/JSON files; for Markdown, frontmatter is now embedded in MarkdownDocument.frontmatter
compressTree / decompressTree from @nuxt/content/runtime	No longer used in app code — see §4 "Legacy bridge"
visit from unist-util-visit	Walk the tuple tree manually using the helpers from src/app/src/utils/comark.ts

Plugin / option shape

// Legacy
parseMarkdown(content, {
  contentHeading: …,
  highlight: { theme },
  remark: {
    plugins: {
      'emoji': { instance: remarkEmojiPlugin },
      'remark-mdc': { options: { autoUnwrap: true } },
    },
  },
})

// Comark
import { parseMarkdown } from 'comark'
import comarkEmoji from 'comark/plugins/emoji'
import shiki from 'comark/plugins/shiki'
import tocPlugin from 'comark/plugins/toc'

parseMarkdown(content, {
  autoClose: false,
  autoUnwrap: true,
  plugins: [
    comarkEmoji(),
    shiki({ themes: { default, dark, light } }),
    tocPlugin({ depth: 2, searchDepth: 2, title: '', links: [] }),
  ],
})

For rendering back to markdown:

// Legacy
const markdown = await stringifyMarkdown(body, data, {
  frontMatter: { options: { lineWidth: 0 } },
  plugins: { remarkMDC: { options: { autoUnwrap: true } } },
})

// Comark
const markdown = await renderMarkdown(tree, {
  blockAttributesStyle: 'frontmatter',
  components: { br: () => ':br' },
})

Dependencies (package.json)

Removed from runtime deps: @nuxtjs/mdc, remark-mdc (moved to devDeps), unist-util-visit.

Added: comark (pulled from pkg.pr.new while it stabilises). js-yaml is now used directly for YAML.

minimark is also a devDep only — do not import it in runtime code.

If the PR adds any of the removed runtime deps, drop them; if it uses one, swap to the comark equivalent.

3. Comark AST helpers

When walking or building a MarkdownDocument, use the helpers in src/app/src/utils/comark.ts:

import { isElement, isComment, getTag, getAttrs, getChildren } from '../../utils/comark'

// Element check
if (isElement(node)) {
  const tag = getTag(node)         // 'note', 'a', 'paragraph', …
  const attrs = getAttrs(node)     // Record<string, unknown>
  const children = getChildren(node)
}

// Comment check
if (isComment(node)) {
  // node === [null, {}, 'comment text']
}

// Text is just a string — no helper needed
if (typeof node === 'string') { … }

Do not reimplement these checks with raw array indexing in PR code; reuse the helpers.

Common visit-style replacement:

// Legacy
visit(document.body, (node) => node.type === 'element' && node.tag === 'a', (node) => {
  Reflect.deleteProperty(node.props, 'rel')
})

// Comark — manual recursion
function walk(node: MarkdownNode) {
  if (isElement(node)) {
    if (getTag(node) === 'a') delete (node[1] as Record<string, unknown>).rel
    for (const child of getChildren(node)) walk(child)
  }
}
tree.nodes.forEach(walk)

4. Legacy bridge — when MDC types still appear

The DB layer in @nuxt/content still stores MarkdownRoot (compressed minimark). Studio bridges this at the DB boundaries with two helpers in src/module/src/runtime/utils/document/legacy.ts:

• comarkTreeFromLegacyDocument(document) — used in host.ts at db.get, db.list, db.create to upgrade legacy bodies on read.
• markdownRootFromComarkTree(tree) — used in host.ts at db.upsert to downgrade back for storage.

If the PR touches host.ts or DB-adjacent code, the body type at that boundary may still be MarkdownRoot. Use isComarkTree(body) (exported from document/index.ts) to branch:

const body = document.body
const stored = isComarkTree(body)
  ? markdownRootFromComarkTree(body)
  : body  // already MarkdownRoot

This bridge is temporary. The header comment of legacy.ts lists the cleanup steps for when @nuxt/content ships native MarkdownDocument storage — do not extend it.

5. Editor component pattern

ContentEditorTipTap.vue now flows through a single tree. Compare:

// Legacy: two separate values (body + data) and manual compression / toc
const frontmatterJson = cleanDataKeys(document.value!)
const newTiptapJSON = mdcToTiptap(
  document.value?.body as unknown as MDCRoot,
  frontmatterJson,
  { hasNuxtUI: hasNuxtUI.value },
)

const { body, data } = await tiptapToMDC(cleanedTiptap, { highlightTheme })
const compressedBody = compressTree(body)
const toc = generateToc(body, { searchDepth: 2, depth: 2 } as Toc)
const updatedDocument = {
  ...document.value!,
  ...data,
  body: { ...compressedBody, toc },
}

// Comark: one tree carries frontmatter + nodes + toc
const comarkTree = document.value!.body
if (!comarkTree) return
const newTiptapJSON = comarkToTiptap(comarkTree, { hasNuxtUI: hasNuxtUI.value })

const comarkTree = await tiptapToComark(cleanedTiptap, { highlightTheme })
const updatedDocument = {
  ...document.value!,
  ...comarkTree.frontmatter,
  body: comarkTree,
}

Key points:

• Frontmatter is inside the MarkdownDocument. There is no separate data return value.
• No manual compressTree, no manual generateToc — the tree carries everything.
• host.document.utils.areEqual and host.document.generate.contentFromDocument are now async (the comark renderer is async).

6. Git Conflict Resolution

DU conflicts (Deleted by Us, Updated by Them)

Files deleted on main but modified in the PR. The most common are:

• src/app/src/utils/tiptap/mdcToTiptap.ts
• src/app/src/utils/tiptap/tiptapToMdc.ts
• src/app/test/unit/utils/tiptap/mdcToTiptap.test.ts

Resolution: accept the deletion (git rm <file>). Port the PR's intent into the comark equivalents (comarkToTiptap.ts, tiptapToComark.ts, comarkToTiptap.test.ts).

UU conflicts (Both Modified)

Common files: ContentEditorTipTap.vue, ContentEditorTipTapDebug.vue, useStudio.ts, useDraftBase.ts, useDraftDocuments.ts, host.ts, compare.ts, generate.ts, index.ts (document utils), actions.test.ts, tiptap.test.ts.

Resolution: keep HEAD (main / comark) as the base. Cherry-pick the semantic intent of incoming changes — translate any legacy MDC API calls to comark equivalents using the mapping in §2.

7. References

• porting-guide.md — Code patterns inside comarkToTiptap.ts / tiptapToComark.ts (option threading, adding new node types, helper extraction, JSDoc style).
• test-migration.md — How to rewrite tests that used the MDC API.

8. Related Skills

• [[mdc-to-comark]] — Project-wide migration from @nuxtjs/mdc to comark in arbitrary Nuxt projects (this skill is the Studio-specific PR-port flavour).
• [[comark]] — Reference for the comark syntax, AST and renderers.
• [[nuxt-content-comark]] — Migrating an entire Nuxt Content project's storage to MarkdownDocument.

9. Checklist for Each Legacy PR Port

• Detect legacy imports / functions with the greps in §1
• Map every legacy function call to its comark equivalent (§2)
• DU conflicts: git rm the deleted files; reimplement intent in comarkToTiptap.ts / tiptapToComark.ts
• UU conflicts: keep HEAD as base, translate incoming MDC calls to comark
• Replace parseMarkdown / stringifyMarkdown (from @nuxtjs/mdc) with parseMarkdown / renderMarkdown (from comark) and update the plugin shape
• Replace visit(...) walks with manual tuple walks using isElement / getChildren / getAttrs
• Drop manual compressTree / generateToc / decompressTree calls in app code — MarkdownDocument carries this natively
• Move frontmatter merging to ...comarkTree.frontmatter
• Treat areEqual and contentFromDocument as async at every call site
• Remove @nuxtjs/mdc, remark-mdc (runtime), unist-util-visit, minimark (runtime) from added deps
• If touching DB boundaries: use isComarkTree + comarkTreeFromLegacyDocument / markdownRootFromComarkTree
• Rewrite tests using comark helpers and tuple-based expected values (see test-migration.md)
• Run to verify