contradiction-flagging

name	contradiction-flagging
description	SOP for flagging contradictions in the causal model — identify conflicting evidence or mechanism claims.
execution	sop
used-by	evidence-weighing, counterfactual-reasoning, model-validation

Contradiction Flagging

Identify and flag contradictions: conflicting evidence, incompatible mechanisms, or circular reasoning.

Tool

vault_query_graph + vault_add_edge

Protocol

1. Query graph around a claim to find all evidence (supported_by and contradicts edges)
2. If both supporting and contradicting evidence exists, flag the contradiction
3. Create a contradicts edge between the conflicting items if not already present
4. Document the contradiction in a question page for resolution
5. Inline wikilinks: For each edge created, ensure the source page body contains [[dir/slug]] pointing to the target (dir/slug = target path minus .md). Place inline at semantically relevant location. Skip if already present.

HARD-GATE

Contradictions must be documented, not silently ignored.

Yield

Returns: { contradictions_found: number, documented: string[] }