cd-anti-pattern-page

name	cd-anti-pattern-page
description	Generate anti-pattern pages for the CD migration guide following the standard template
user_invocable	true

CD Anti-Pattern Page Generator

Role: implementation. This skill generates new content files following the anti-pattern page template.

Generate a new anti-pattern page for the "Quality and Delivery Anti-Patterns" section of the CD migration guide.

Constraints

1. Follow the template exactly. Do not invent new sections or skip required ones.
2. Be concise. Generate the page and report validation results. No preambles.
3. Validate before finishing. Run all validation checks in the instructions before considering the work complete.

Instructions

1. Read the canonical example at content/en/docs/problems/push-based-work-assignment.md to calibrate tone, depth, and structure.
2. Read common-issues.md at the repo root to find the issue description if the user references an issue number or name.
3. Ask the user which anti-pattern to write if not already specified.
4. Generate the page following the template below.
5. Validate before finishing:
   • Run /grammar-check on the generated file to catch and fix any prohibited punctuation.
   • Verify all internal links point to existing pages.
   • Confirm the "Why This Is a Problem" section has all three required subsections plus the CD impact closing subsection.

Template

---
title: "[Anti-Pattern Name]"
linkTitle: "[Anti-Pattern Name]"
weight: [number matching common-issues.md issue number]
description: >
  [One-sentence description of the anti-pattern]
---

{{% pageinfo %}}
**Category:** [Category Name] | {{% risk-indicator level="[critical|high|medium|low]" %}}
{{% /pageinfo %}}

## What This Looks Like

[2-3 paragraphs describing observable symptoms. Be specific and concrete - describe what a team
member would actually see, hear, or experience. Use present tense.]

Common variations:

- **[Variation name].** [Description]
- **[Variation name].** [Description]

[Telltale sign paragraph: "The telltale sign: ..."]

## Why This Is a Problem

[1-2 sentence framing paragraph that sets up the subsections below.]

### It reduces quality

[How this anti-pattern degrades quality. Be specific about the mechanism. Contrast with the
healthier alternative in the final paragraph of this subsection.]

### It increases rework

[How this anti-pattern causes wasted or duplicated effort. Contrast with the healthier
alternative.]

### It makes delivery timelines unpredictable

[How this anti-pattern disrupts flow and predictability. Contrast with the healthier alternative.]

### [Optional: context-specific impact subsection]

[Additional impacts that don't fit the three required dimensions above. Use when the anti-pattern
has a distinctive effect worth calling out separately. Skip if the three required subsections
already cover the key impacts.]

### Impact on continuous delivery

[How this specifically blocks CD adoption or practices. This is always the final subsection.
Connect back to the core CD requirements: steady flow of small changes, fast feedback, predictable
delivery.]

## How to Fix It

### Step 1: [Action verb]

[Concrete first step. Include specific actions the team should take.]

### Step 2: [Action verb]

[Continue with weekly steps. Each step should build on the previous one.]

[Include an objection-handling table if the anti-pattern has common pushback:]

| Objection | Response |
|-----------|----------|
| "[Common pushback]" | [Concrete response that addresses the concern] |

[Include a role transition table if applicable:]

| Before | After |
|--------|-------|
| [Old behavior] | [New behavior] |

## Measuring Progress

| Metric | What to look for |
|--------|-----------------|
| [Metric name] | [What improvement looks like] |

## Related Content

- [Links to relevant guide pages in the site]

Content Guidelines

Tone

• Direct, specific, and assertive but not preachy
• Write as a practitioner advising a peer, not a consultant lecturing a client
• State what happens and why it matters - let the reader draw conclusions
• Use "you" and "the team" naturally

Depth per section

• What This Looks Like: 2-3 paragraphs plus variations. Enough detail that a reader says "that's us."
• Why This Is a Problem subsections: 2-4 paragraphs each. Each subsection should have a clear mechanism (how the anti-pattern causes this effect) and a contrast with the healthier alternative.
• How to Fix It steps: 3-6 steps, each with a week number. Concrete enough to start Monday morning.
• Measuring Progress: 4-6 metrics. Link to reference metric pages where one exists.
• Related Content: 3-5 links to existing guide pages.

Style rules

• Use sentence-style capitalization in headings (only capitalize the first word and proper nouns).
• Keep paragraphs to 3-4 sentences maximum.
• Use active voice.
• Run /grammar-check before finishing to catch prohibited punctuation (endashes, emdashes, hyphens used as dashes).

Subsection conventions

• "Why This Is a Problem" always has three required subsections: "It reduces quality", "It increases rework", "It makes delivery timelines unpredictable"
• Optional extra subsections go between "delivery timelines" and "Impact on continuous delivery"
• "Impact on continuous delivery" is always the final subsection
• Each subsection contrasts the anti-pattern with the healthier alternative
• "How to Fix It" uses time-boxed weekly steps

Quality Impact Levels

Each anti-pattern gets a risk indicator badge. Choose the level based on how directly the anti-pattern blocks continuous delivery:

Level	When to use
Critical	Foundational blocker - CD is impossible without fixing this (e.g., no CI, no pipeline)
High	Significant drag on delivery flow, feedback loops, or quality (e.g., PR bottlenecks, too much WIP)
Medium	Impedes delivery but less directly tied to core CD gates (e.g., no vertical slicing)
Low	Minor friction - worth fixing but not a delivery blocker

Categories

These match the categories in common-issues.md:

1. Delivery Speed & Frequency (issues 1-8)
2. Branching & Integration (issues 9-15)
3. Testing & Quality (issues 16-27)
4. Work Decomposition & Planning (issues 28-35)
5. Pipeline & Infrastructure (issues 36-48)
6. Monitoring & Observability (issues 49-54)
7. Organizational & Cultural (issues 55-69)
8. Compliance & Security (issues 70-75)
9. Architecture (issues 76-83)
10. Developer Experience (issues 84-90)
11. Legacy & Migration-Specific (issues 91-97)
12. Missing Practices (issues 98-105)

Available Metrics Pages (for linking)

Use relative links from the problems directory: ../../reference/metrics/[page]/

• build-duration - Build Duration
• change-fail-rate - Change Fail Rate
• development-cycle-time - Development Cycle Time
• integration-frequency - Integration Frequency
• lead-time - Lead Time
• mean-time-to-repair - Mean Time to Repair
• release-frequency - Release Frequency
• work-in-progress - Work in Progress

Available Guide Pages (for Related Content links)

Use relative links from the problems directory: ../../[section]/[page]/

Assess:

• assess/baseline-metrics - Baseline Metrics
• assess/current-state-checklist - Current State Checklist
• assess/identify-constraints - Identify Constraints
• assess/value-stream-mapping - Value Stream Mapping

Foundations:

• foundations/build-automation - Build Automation
• foundations/code-review - Code Review
• foundations/everything-as-code - Everything as Code
• foundations/testing-fundamentals - Testing Fundamentals
• foundations/trunk-based-development - Trunk-Based Development
• foundations/work-decomposition - Work Decomposition
• foundations/working-agreements - Working Agreements

Pipeline:

• pipeline/application-config - Application Config
• pipeline/deployable-definition - Deployable Definition
• pipeline/deterministic-pipeline - Deterministic Pipeline
• pipeline/immutable-artifacts - Immutable Artifacts
• pipeline/pipeline-architecture - Pipeline Architecture
• pipeline/production-like-environments - Production-Like Environments
• pipeline/rollback - Rollback
• pipeline/single-path-to-production - Single Path to Production

Optimize:

• optimize/architecture-decoupling - Architecture Decoupling
• optimize/feature-flags - Feature Flags
• optimize/limiting-wip - Limiting WIP
• optimize/metrics-driven-improvement - Metrics-Driven Improvement
• optimize/retrospectives - Retrospectives
• optimize/small-batches - Small Batches

Continuous Deployment:

• continuous-deployment/agentic-cd - Agentic CD
• continuous-deployment/deploy-on-demand - Deploy on Demand
• continuous-deployment/experience-reports - Experience Reports
• continuous-deployment/progressive-rollout - Progressive Rollout

Reference:

• reference/cd-dependency-tree - CD Dependency Tree
• reference/common-blockers - Common Blockers
• reference/dora-capabilities - DORA Capabilities
• reference/glossary - Glossary
• reference/resources - Resources

Output

Write the generated page to content/en/docs/problems/[slug].md where [slug] is the anti-pattern name in kebab-case.