mcp-tool-selection

name	mcp-tool-selection
description	Decision rules for when to use MCP Qdrant-Indexer semantic search vs grep/literal file tools. Use this skill when starting exploration, debugging, or answering "where/why" questions about code.

MCP Tool Selection Rules

Core principle: MCP Qdrant-Indexer tools are primary for exploring code and history. Start with MCP for exploration, debugging, or "where/why" questions; use literal search/file-open only for narrow exact-literal lookups.

STOP — Do NOT Use Read File or Grep for Exploration

DO NOT use Read File, grep, ripgrep, cat, find, or any filesystem search tool for code exploration. You have MCP tools that are faster, smarter, and return ranked, contextual results.

• About to Read a file to understand it? → use search or repo_search or context_answer
• About to grep for a symbol? → use search or symbol_graph or search_callers_for
• About to grep -r for a concept? → use search with natural language
• About to find/ls for project structure? → use qdrant_status (with list_all=true)

TIP: Use search as your DEFAULT tool — it auto-detects intent and routes to the best specialized tool.

The ONLY acceptable use of grep/Read: confirming exact literal strings (e.g., REDIS_HOST), or reading a file you already located via MCP for editing.

Use MCP Qdrant-Indexer When

• Exploring or don't know exact strings/symbols
• Need semantic or cross-file understanding (relationships, patterns, architecture)
• Want ranked results with surrounding context, not just line hits
• Asking conceptual/architectural or "where/why" behavior questions
• Need rich context/snippets around matches
• Finding callers, definitions, or importers of any symbol

Use Literal Search/File-Open Only When

• Know exact string/function/variable or error message
• Only need to confirm existence or file/line quickly (not to understand behavior)

Grep Anti-Patterns (DON'T)

grep -r "auth" .        # → Use MCP: "authentication mechanisms"
grep -r "cache" .       # → Use MCP: "caching strategies"  
grep -r "error" .       # → Use MCP: "error handling patterns"
grep -r "database" .    # → Use MCP: "database operations"
# Also DON'T:
Read File to understand a module  # → Use repo_search or context_answer
Read File to find callers         # → Use symbol_graph
find/ls for project structure     # → Use qdrant_status (list_all=true)

Literal Search Patterns (DO)

grep -rn "UserAlreadyExists" .      # Specific error class
grep -rn "def authenticate_user" .  # Exact function name
grep -rn "REDIS_HOST" .             # Exact environment variable

Quick Decision Heuristic

Question Type	Tool
UNSURE / GENERAL QUERY	MCP search — RECOMMENDED DEFAULT, auto-routes to best tool
"Where is X implemented?"	MCP search or repo_search
"Search across multiple repos"	MCP cross_repo_search — PRIMARY for multi-repo, prefer over manual chains
"Trace frontend→backend flow"	MCP cross_repo_search(trace_boundary=true) — auto-extracts boundary keys
"Who calls this and show code?"	MCP symbol_graph — DEFAULT for all graph queries, always available
"What does this call?"	MCP symbol_graph (query_type="callees")
"Where is X defined?"	MCP symbol_graph (query_type="definition")
"What imports X?"	MCP symbol_graph (query_type="importers")
"Callers of callers? Multi-hop?"	MCP symbol_graph (depth=2+) or graph_query
"What breaks if I change X?"	MCP graph_query (impact analysis, transitive callers)
"Circular dependencies?"	MCP graph_query (query_type="cycles")
"N independent searches at once?"	batch_search (~75% token savings)
"N symbol queries at once?"	batch_symbol_graph (~75% token savings)
"N graph queries at once?"	batch_graph_query (~75% token savings)
"How does authentication work?"	MCP context_answer
"High-level module overview?"	MCP info_request (with explanations)
"Does REDIS_HOST exist?"	Literal grep
"Why did behavior change?"	search_commits_for + change_history_for_path

symbol_graph is ALWAYS available (Qdrant-backed). graph_query is available to all SaaS users (Memgraph-backed) for advanced traversals: impact analysis, circular dependencies, transitive callers/callees. In self-hosted, requires NEO4J_GRAPH=1 or MEMGRAPH_GRAPH=1. If graph_query is not in your tool list, use symbol_graph for everything.

Batch tools (batch_search, batch_symbol_graph, batch_graph_query) run N independent queries in one MCP invocation with ~75% token savings. Max 10 queries per batch. Use when you have 2+ independent queries of the same type.

cross_repo_search discovery modes: "auto" (default), "always" (force discovery), "never" (skip). Use trace_boundary=true to extract API routes, event names, types.

If in doubt → start with search (unified MCP tool that auto-routes to the best specialized tool)