flowfile-ai-subsystem

name

flowfile-ai-subsystem

description

Architecture and safe-extension guide for flowfile_core's /ai/* subsystem — the assist/copilot/planner surface map, the FEATURE_FLAG_AI router gate, the litellm lazy-import contract and its enforcing tests, BYOK provider resolution, per-process rate limiting, the prompt-log debugging runbook, the local llama.cpp model, and two maintainer-validated doctrines (prompt edits must be additive not subtractive; wrong-but-recoverable LLM payload shapes get normalized at the executor seam, not the schema or the prompt) — use when adding or debugging an AI route/agent/provider, when an agent tool call is being rejected or looping, when asked to "make the prompt more direct" or tighten AI/system prompts, when the LLM keeps emitting a wrong JSON shape for a tool call, or when investigating what a Flowfile LLM call actually saw/said.

Flowfile AI subsystem

Everything under flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/ — the /ai/* HTTP surface, the three agent tiers (assist / copilot / planner), the litellm provider seam, BYOK credentials, rate limiting, the prompt log, and the local model manager. Read this before touching any file under flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/ or flowfile_core/tests/ai/.

When NOT to use this skill

• The full FEATURE_FLAG_AI / FLOWFILE_AI_LOG_PROMPTS* / rate-limit env-var table with exact settings.py line numbers → flowfile-config-and-flags (this skill states only what's needed to reason about AI behavior).
• Step-by-step "an agent is misbehaving, what do I check first" triage → flowfile-debugging-playbook (this skill explains why the prompt log works the way it does; the playbook is the symptom-first runbook).
• Adding a brand-new node type (Pydantic settings, add_<type> on FlowGraph, frontend node UI) → flowfile-node-development. The AI tool catalog auto-derives from those same settings classes — get the node right first, the AI surfaces it for free.
• Core/worker/kernel dataflow contract (why core never .collect()s) → flowfile-architecture-contract.
• Frontend chat/copilot UI components (AiAssistant.vue, ghost-node suggestions, Cmd+K palette rendering) → flowfile-frontend-conventions.
• Test markers and how to run flowfile_core/tests/ai/ → flowfile-testing-and-validation.

---

1. Surface map — three agent tiers, one prompt stack

All AI code lives under flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/. The package docstring (ai/__init__.py) is the map: providers/ (litellm seam + BYOK key load), tools/ (tool catalog + executor), context/ (subgraph/schema serialization), agents/ (surface implementations), prompts/ (layered system prompts), plus streaming, scheduler, sessions, diff, safety, metrics. 17 *_routes.py route modules (as of 2026-07-03; re-count with ls flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/*_routes.py) are mounted onto one router, which is the package's only public export.

Tier	Entry point	Where the logic actually lives	Behavior
Assist	POST via chat_routes.py (chat drawer, inline ✨ menu, Fix-with-AI)	Route modules directly — agents/assist.py is a 9-line docstring-only stub ("Stub.")	Single-turn, read-only. No tool calls, no graph mutation.
Copilot	autocomplete_routes.py, command_palette_routes.py, edge ghost-node suggestions	Route modules directly — agents/copilot.py is a 10-line docstring-only stub	Suggestive, in-flow. One tool call per surface; applied immediately, undoable.
Planner	POST /ai/agent/start (agent_routes.py)	agents/planner/ — a real package (_internal.py, catalog.py, coercions.py, insertion.py, llm_replies.py, loop.py, messages.py, rationale.py, recovery.py, staged_schemas.py)	Multi-turn, tool-calling, diff-staged.

Do not look for assist/copilot implementation inside agents/assist.py or agents/copilot.py — they only point you at the real route modules and at prompts/base.md + prompts/assist.md / prompts/copilot.md. All three tiers share prompts/base.md as a common layer.

Planner surfaces (verify before quoting elsewhere — this drifted once already)

AgentStartRequest.surface (agent_routes.py) is a Literal["agent_complex", "agent_staged", "agent_live"], default "agent_staged" — not a bare "agent". agents/planner/_internal.py defines _STAGED_STATE_MACHINE_SURFACES = frozenset({"agent_staged", "agent_live"}):

• agent_staged (default) — the two-stage state machine: classify → pick_type → pick_upstream → fill_settings. Every tool call dispatches with mode="stage"; nothing touches the live graph until the user accepts.
• agent_live — same state machine, but applies each step immediately (lives in flow.nodes right away) instead of staging, and includes an observation step. Every agent_staged gate in the planner code must also include agent_live (see the comment at _internal.py:65-69).
• agent_complex — single-shot, full tool catalog (including codegen helpers hidden from the staged surfaces). Requires a provider with supports_tools=True, or the route returns 422.

Planner contract, verified against agents/planner/__init__.py's module docstring:

• Session opens via POST /ai/agent/start; every LLM tool call dispatches through execute_tool_call with mode="stage" — the live graph is never mutated mid-run (staged surfaces) or mutated one step at a time with full auditing (agent_live).
• The graph is snapshotted before every dispatch. If the user edits the canvas mid-run, the planner yields drift_detected + paused and exits cleanly; the session waits for POST /ai/agent/{session_id}/resume ({"action": "continue"} re-snapshots and resumes; {"action": "discard"} frees the staged diff).
• A rejected step retries up to max_retries_per_step times by feeding the executor's refusal_detail back to the LLM as a role="tool" message.
• On completion, per-step results bundle into one flowfile_core.ai.diff.GraphDiff via bundle_staged_results, reviewed and accepted atomically in the UI (AiDiffPreview).
• The planner generator never raises — every failure becomes a PlannerEvent ("error" / "tool_call_rejected" / "drift_detected" / "abort"). SSE id: headers are f"{session_id}.{step_count}" so Last-Event-ID reconnect works against the replay buffer.
• Sessions are namespaced by user_id; cross-user access on {session_id}/* returns 404 (not 403) to avoid leaking session existence.

---

2. Router gating — FEATURE_FLAG_AI

The entire /ai/* router is behind one dependency: ai/feature_flag.py::require_ai_enabled(), wired as APIRouter(dependencies=[Depends(require_ai_enabled)]) in ai/routes.py. Off → every AI endpoint returns 503 with detail "AI features are disabled. Set FEATURE_FLAG_AI=true to enable." (DISABLED_DETAIL, feature_flag.py:36).

• Backing store: settings.FEATURE_FLAG_AI, a MutableBool (configs/settings.py:25-27), default on (os.environ.get("FEATURE_FLAG_AI", "1"), truthy strings true/1/yes/on, case/whitespace-insensitive).
• is_ai_enabled() reads the live MutableBool value on every call — no restart, no reload needed to see a flip.
• Live flip: POST /system/feature_flags/ai (ai/admin_routes.py, admin-only via get_current_admin_user) — mounted under /system, deliberately outside the gated /ai router (so you can turn AI back on while it's reporting 503). It sets both settings.FEATURE_FLAG_AI.set(enabled) and os.environ["FEATURE_FLAG_AI"], but the response always carries persisted: false — surviving a process restart is the operator's .env file, not this endpoint's job.
• Full env-var table (defaults, truthy-parse rule, every other FLOWFILE_AI_* flag) → flowfile-config-and-flags.

---

3. The litellm lazy-import contract

Rule: no module under ai/ imports litellm at module (top) level, so the package can be imported — including by cheap classification/dry-run/ scheduling code paths that never need a real LLM call — without paying litellm's import cost or triggering its network calls.

Verified (grep for import litellm / from litellm import under flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/) — there are exactly two real imports, both function-local:

1. ai/providers/_litellm_base.py, inside _lazy_litellm() — import litellm then litellm.suppress_debug_info = True (idempotent; silences litellm's stdout banners on every call).
2. ai/scheduler.py, inside a function — from litellm import exceptions as lle # lazy, guarded by try/except so a missing/broken litellm install degrades to bare TimeoutError/ConnectionError retry matching instead of crashing.

ai/__init__.py also does os.environ.setdefault("LITELLM_LOCAL_MODEL_COST_MAP", "True") before importing routes — a write, not an import — guaranteeing litellm's eventual first import uses the bundled cost map instead of fetching one from raw.githubusercontent.com.

Correction to a common paraphrase of the root CLAUDE.md line ("keep the package litellm-import-free except ai/byok.py"): read literally that's wrong — byok.py contains no litellm import at all (verified). What byok.py's own docstring actually describes is that it keeps ai/credentials.py (the DB CRUD layer) provider-class-import-free, so import flowfile_core.ai.credentials never pulls in any providers/* module. The real litellm rule is simpler and package-wide: no module under ai/ imports litellm at load time; the two lazy sites above are it.

Enforcing tests (flowfile_core/tests/ai/) — re-adding an eager import litellm anywhere under ai/ breaks these:

• test_classification.py::test_classify_lazy_litellm — asserts no litellm/litellm.* module is in sys.modules after importing the classification module.
• test_dry_run.py::test_dry_run_lazy_litellm_contract — same assertion for the dry-run module.
• ai/scheduler.py's own docstring states the same invariant for flowfile_core.ai.scheduler, but no dedicated test for it was found beyond the two above — don't assume a third exists.

LiteLLMProvider.chat() / .stream() (ai/providers/_litellm_base.py) are the single dispatch seam every vendor subclass shares: translate Pydantic Message/ToolSpec to litellm's dict shapes, aggregate streamed tool-call fragments in _PartialToolCall buffers (a tool call surfaces only once it has an id + name and its arguments parse as JSON), and in finally blocks run two never-crash hooks — _record_call_telemetry (always-on flowfile_ai_provider_call_total counter) and _record_chat_log/ _record_stream_log (prompt log, only when FLOWFILE_AI_LOG_PROMPTS is on). Both import their dependencies function-locally and swallow + log failures — a logging bug must never take down an LLM call.

---

4. Providers, BYOK, and model resolution

ai/providers/registry.py::PROVIDERS maps six litellm-backed vendors — anthropic, openai, google, groq, openrouter, ollama — each a config-only subclass of LiteLLMProvider (name, default_model, model_prefix, capability flags, surface_models, default_api_base).

The local llama.cpp pseudo-provider (providers/local.py, LOCAL_PROVIDER_ID = "local") is deliberately not in PROVIDERS — it never appears in BYOK credential CRUD. is_resolvable_provider(name) = PROVIDERS ∪ {"local"}, used by read-only routes; the tool-calling agent route (agent_routes.py) rejects provider == LOCAL_PROVIDER_ID explicitly — a local model has no reliable tool-calling support to build a planner run on.

BYOK (ai/byok.py + ai/credentials.py): API keys are Secret rows via the normal secret_manager (encrypt_secret/decrypt_secret), name convention ai:{provider}:api_key:{user_id}:{credential_id}. Rotation mutates Secret.encrypted_value in place (id stable).

byok.get_configured_provider(db, user_id, provider, *, surface, model) — model resolution order (its own docstring, byok.py:1-31): (1) explicit model= argument → (2) credential row's default_model → (3) provider class surface_models[surface] if it's in the user's curated models list → (4) first entry of the user's curated models list → (5) provider class surface_models[surface] (plain fallback) → (6) provider class default_model (terminal fallback).

Env-var fallback when no credential row exists — _PROVIDER_ENV_VARS (byok.py): anthropic→ANTHROPIC_API_KEY, openai→OPENAI_API_KEY, google→GEMINI_API_KEY/GOOGLE_API_KEY, groq→GROQ_API_KEY, openrouter→OPENROUTER_API_KEY, ollama→none (never needs a key — unconfigured until a row exists, configured only once one is saved). get_configured_provider raises ProviderNotConfiguredError only when all of: no credential row, no env var, no class default_api_base, and provider != "ollama".

Rate limiting (ai/scheduler.py) — opt-in, not automatic. Per-provider sliding-window RPM/RPD from FLOWFILE_AI_<PROVIDER>_RPM / _RPD (unset ⇒ unenforced; ollama is always in _UNLIMITED_PROVIDERS, never limited). Honors Retry-After on 429; exponential backoff 2s, 4s, 8s, 16s, max 4 retries, ±25% jitter — server Retry-After always wins when longer. byok.get_configured_provider is NOT auto-wrapped; callers opt in via with_provider_retry(provider, ...).

Load-bearing caveat: state is per-process, in-memory (plain deques, no persistence, nothing shared across workers). Under gunicorn -w N (or any multi-worker deploy), the effective aggregate budget is ≈ N × the configured RPM/RPD — each worker enforces its own window independently. For a hard global ceiling, pin to a single worker or divide the configured limit by the worker count. No audit writes happen on retries ("failure is free" — retries are invisible to user-facing quota counters).

---

5. Prompt-log debugging runbook

The prompt log is the "what did the model actually see and say" hatch — prefer it over guessing from output when an agent loops, hallucinates a tool name, references a nonexistent column, or otherwise misbehaves.

1. Set FLOWFILE_AI_LOG_PROMPTS=true in the environment (accepts true/1/yes/on) and re-run the failing flow/chat/agent session.
2. Tail the latest entries: python -m flowfile_core.ai.prompt_log tail 20.
3. Or search: python -m flowfile_core.ai.prompt_log grep PATTERN [SURFACE] — regex over the serialized JSON line, optionally scoped to one AI surface (e.g. agent_staged).
4. Or open the file directly: {storage.base_directory}/ai_prompts/YYYY-MM-DD.jsonl — ~/.flowfile/ai_prompts/... locally, $FLOWFILE_STORAGE_DIR/ai_prompts/... when set, or /app/internal_storage/ai_prompts/... in Docker. One jq-parseable JSON line per LLM round-trip.

Gotcha — tail/grep only read today's file. Both tail(n, date=None) and grep(pattern, surface=None, date=None) default date to datetime.now(timezone.utc).date().isoformat() — UTC, not local time — and the CLI (_cli_main in prompt_log.py) never exposes a date flag. To inspect a prior day, either run just after UTC midnight rollover expecting "yesterday", or drop into Python and call tail(20, date="2026-07-02") / grep(pattern, date="2026-07-02") directly.

Truncation (keeps every line jq-parseable regardless of agent-loop depth): entries over MAX_MESSAGES_BYTES = 256 * 1024 (256 KiB) get their older message bodies replaced with [...truncated, len=N chars] and truncated: true set, while the system prompt plus the most-recent KEEP_RECENT_TURNS = 5 messages are kept verbatim.

Sharing transcripts externally: set FLOWFILE_AI_LOG_PROMPTS_SCRUB=true first. Scrub masks user and tool message bodies only through the regex PII scrubber in ai/safety.py — system and assistant content stay verbatim, because that's the half you actually need to debug compliance against the prompt. Both flags default off; production stays silent unless an operator opts in.

Failure isolation: a prompt-log write failure (disk full, serialization bug) never crashes the LLM call — the wrapper in _litellm_base.py swallows and warns.

---

6. Local model (ai/local_model/manager.py)

On-demand llama-server (llama.cpp) + a GGUF model, downloaded only when the user opts in via /ai/local-model/* routes — the download directory (storage.local_model_directory, ~/.flowfile/local_model) is deliberately excluded from shared.storage_config's _ensure_directories() so it's never created for users who never touch the feature.

• Pinned llama.cpp build: LLAMACPP_BUILD = "b9305" from ggml-org/llama.cpp releases (platform-specific archive per OS/arch). Default model: Qwen2.5-Coder-3B-Instruct GGUF (~2 GB); a curated list also offers a 1.5B (lighter) and a 7B (heavier, non-coder) option.
• Module-level singleton — at most one server runs at a time; _lock guards it. LocalProvider resolves the live port lazily on the first .stream() call so constructing it stays synchronous/non-blocking.
• Shut down from core's FastAPI lifespan (main.py's _shutdown_local_model) so a killed core process doesn't orphan the llama-server subprocess.
• Kept out of providers.PROVIDERS (see §4) — never appears in BYOK CRUD, and the tool-calling agent route rejects it outright.

---

7. How to extend safely

• New vendor provider: add a config-only subclass under ai/providers/ (mirror anthropic.py/groq.py — name, default_model, model_prefix, surface_models, default_api_base), register it in registry.PROVIDERS, and add its API-key env var(s) to byok._PROVIDER_ENV_VARS. Never import litellm at module scope — the vendor subclass inherits the lazy _lazy_litellm() call from LiteLLMProvider.
• New AI route: put it under the /ai router (ai/routes.py) so it inherits require_ai_enabled for free — don't hand-roll the 503 check. Add auth per-route (Depends(get_current_active_user), or get_current_admin_user for admin-only) — the feature flag and auth are orthogonal gates, both required.
• New agent tool: the tool catalog auto-derives from the same Pydantic node-settings classes used by the visual graph (see flowfile-node-development) — get the node's settings schema right first and most of the catalog wiring falls out for free. Route it through execute_tool_call in ai/tools/executor/; don't bypass the dispatch seam.
• New prompt content: see the doctrine in §8 before editing anything under ai/prompts/.
• A tool call keeps arriving in a wrong-but-fixable shape: see the doctrine in §9 before touching the prompt or the Pydantic schema.

---

8. PROMPT DOCTRINE (maintainer-validated — do not relitigate without re-reading this)

Flowfile's AI prompts (ai/prompts/base.md, planner.md, assist.md, copilot.md, and the stage_*.md files) are written for cheap, small-model-class agents, not just top-tier models. That constraint shapes what "improving" a prompt actually means:

• Worked examples and repeated imperatives are load-bearing scaffolding, not padding. A concrete "customers per city → look for a node with customer and city columns"-style example teaches pattern-matching that a terser rule statement doesn't reliably transfer to a smaller model, even when the rule text is technically equivalent.
• A ~40-50% "more direct" rewrite of the planner prompt caused an immediate, cascading regression in production dogfooding and was reverted within minutes (2026-05). The rewrite led with the rule, cut hedges and worked examples, and shortened rationale paragraphs — and the very next live session produced cascading retry failures across add_group_by / connect / delete_node / read_node_schema tool calls plus an unrequested node staged. The fix was reverting, not iterating on the shorter version.
• Prefer additive clarity over subtractive trimming. If a prompt section feels verbose, the safe move is adding one more worked example or imperative restatement — not deleting the ones already there. Treat any PR that removes worked examples or repeated imperatives from base.md/planner.md/assist.md/copilot.md as a regression risk requiring dogfood verification, not a routine cleanup.
• Tone-level polish is fine and welcome: fixing typos, sharpening a verb, stripping a genuinely dead conversational hedge, or improving formatting — as long as no rule, imperative, or worked example is removed in the same edit.
• If asked to "make the prompt more direct" or "tighten" it: do not interpret that as "shorten." Rewrite for clarity and force per line without deleting content. If real compression is wanted, that's a planned, test/dogfood-gated editorial pass — not a quick edit.

---

9. EXECUTOR-SEAM DOCTRINE (maintainer-validated — do not relitigate without re-reading this)

When the LLM consistently emits a wrong-but-structurally-recoverable payload shape for a tool call, the fix goes in the executor, not the prompt and not the Pydantic schema.

Where: flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/tools/executor/ — a package (it used to be a single executor.py; the public API is re-exported verbatim from executor/__init__.py so from flowfile_core.ai.tools.executor import ... still works). Coercers live in executor/coercions.py and executor/manual_input.py; the dispatcher that calls them is executor/dispatch.py and executor/handlers/add.py.

Two live examples to copy the shape of:

• coercions.py::_coerce_connection_id_to_flat — the LLM occasionally emits {"connection_id": "1→2"} (or "1->2" / "1:2") for a delete-connection call instead of the structured {from_node_id, to_node_id} shape. Called first thing inside the connection-delete handler (executor/handlers/connections.py), before validation.
• manual_input.py::_normalize_manual_input_args (+ _normalize_manual_input_columns / _normalize_manual_input_data) — the manual_input node's RawData schema (schemas/input_schema.py) demands strictly columnar data (data[i] = all values for columns[i]), but LLMs consistently emit row-oriented data and columns as a {name: dtype} dict. Root cause noted in the module docstring: Pydantic's JSON-Schema rendering of data: list[list] produces unconstrained items: {} at the inner level, so the schema itself can't teach the columnar invariant — prompt examples alone weren't enough. Gated on node_type == "manual_input" inside _handle_add_node (executor/handlers/add.py), called before settings_cls.model_validate.

The pattern to follow:

1. Place the normalizer alongside the existing coercers (coercions.py for general shape fixes, or a dedicated module like manual_input.py for a node-type-specific one).
2. Gate the call on the specific node_type or tool name it applies to — never apply a coercion globally to every payload.
3. Write it identity-preserving on no-op: if the input is already canonical or doesn't match the recognized bad shape, return the original object unchanged (not a copy) so callers can detect "did anything change" via is.
4. When the shape is structurally ambiguous — e.g. a square manual_input matrix where len(data) == len(columns) and every inner list also has that length, so both orientations are valid list[list] — leave it untouched. The schema is canonical in the ambiguous case; guessing wrong silently corrupts data, which is worse than a refusal.
5. Add a unit test per shape variant (see flowfile_core/tests/ai/test_executor.py's test_normalize_columns_* / test_normalize_data_* / test_normalize_manual_input_args_* / test_executor_accepts_*_for_manual_input cluster) plus an integration-style test asserting the previously-rejected payload now applies successfully.

What NOT to do:

• Do not keep tightening the prompt for a shape error once it's shown up more than once — in-prompt examples were already tried for the manual_input case and the LLM still fell back to row-oriented thinking, because the JSON-Schema the LLM actually sees doesn't encode the constraint the prose does.
• Do not add a schema-level @model_validator(mode="before") to make the Pydantic class itself accept the sloppy shape. Node settings classes like RawData have non-AI consumers — the UI's manual-input dialog, the programmatic flowfile_frame API — that must not pay the LLM-tolerance cost of a permissive schema. The schema stays the strict, canonical contract; leniency is the executor's job, scoped to the AI path only.

---

Provenance and maintenance

Facts below are dated 2026-07-03 (v0.12.7); the AI package moves fast (new route modules, occasional file-to-package splits like executor.py → executor/) — re-run these before trusting a specific line number or file path.

# Surface map / stub confirmation + planner surface literal (watch for drift off
# agent_staged/agent_live/agent_complex)
sed -n '1,20p' flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/agents/assist.py flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/agents/copilot.py
ls flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/agents/planner/
grep -n 'surface: Literal' flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/agent_routes.py

# FEATURE_FLAG_AI gate + admin flip endpoint
grep -n 'FEATURE_FLAG_AI' flowfile_core/flowfile_core/configs/settings.py
sed -n '1,95p' flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/admin_routes.py
grep -n 'ai_admin_router\|prefix="/system"' flowfile_core/flowfile_core/main.py

# Lazy-litellm contract + its tests. Expect exactly two code hits, both
# function-local: providers/_litellm_base.py (import litellm) and
# scheduler.py (from litellm import exceptions). A bare `grep 'import litellm'`
# also matches comments/log strings and misses the `from litellm import` form.
grep -rnE '^\s*(import litellm|from litellm import)' flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/
poetry run pytest flowfile_core/tests/ai/test_classification.py::test_classify_lazy_litellm \
  flowfile_core/tests/ai/test_dry_run.py::test_dry_run_lazy_litellm_contract -q

# Provider registry + BYOK env-var fallback map + rate-limit per-process caveat
sed -n '1,45p' flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/providers/registry.py
grep -n '_PROVIDER_ENV_VARS' -A 9 flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/byok.py
grep -n 'per-process\|_UNLIMITED_PROVIDERS\|gunicorn' flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/scheduler.py

# Prompt log constants + CLI (today-only date default) + local model manager pin/singleton
grep -n 'MAX_MESSAGES_BYTES\|KEEP_RECENT_TURNS\|LOG_SUBDIR\|def tail\|def grep\|def _cli_main' \
  flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/prompt_log.py
grep -n 'LLAMACPP_BUILD\|local_model_directory\|_ensure_directories' \
  flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/local_model/manager.py shared/storage_config.py

# Executor-seam doctrine: coercers, their gating call sites, and no before-validator on RawData
grep -n 'def _coerce_connection_id_to_flat\|def _normalize_manual_input_args' \
  flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/tools/executor/coercions.py \
  flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/tools/executor/manual_input.py
grep -n  flowfile_core/flowfile_core/ai/tools/executor/handlers/add.py
grep -n  -A 20 flowfile_core/flowfile_core/schemas/input_schema.py | grep -i model_validator

The prompt doctrine (§8) and executor-seam doctrine (§9) are process knowledge from lived incidents, not something you can grep back out of the current tree (the reverted prompt diff and the original bug report aren't preserved as commits to inspect). Treat them as standing policy unless a maintainer explicitly revisits them — don't rediscover them the hard way.