메뉴
Malt, hop, and yeast substitution tables with flavor difference notes for when ingredients are unavailable
Codex 또는 Claude로 설치 이 Prompt를 복사해 Codex, Claude 또는 다른 어시스턴트에 붙여 넣으면 Skill 페이지를 검토하고 설치를 진행할 수 있습니다.
SOC 직업 분류 기준
BJCP style reference with OG/IBU/SRM/ABV ranges, water profiles, carbonation, serving temps, and key ingredient recommendations for 37 beer styles
Mash temperature vs fermentability, yeast pitching rates, dry hop timing and biotransformation, and off-flavour diagnostics
Hop flavor profiles, style pairing guide, dry hop rates, Cryo hops, biotransformation technique, and substitution ratio formula for 40+ varieties
Style-family water targets (Ca/SO4/Cl ppm), salt addition guide, mash pH targets, SO4:Cl ratio, and carbonation reference
Yeast strain reference with attenuation, temperature, flocculation, alcohol tolerance, pressure fermenting guidance, and quick selection guide for 22 strains
| name | ingredient-substitutions |
| description | Malt, hop, and yeast substitution tables with flavor difference notes for when ingredients are unavailable |
Use when a specified ingredient is unavailable or when adapting a recipe. Substitutions are ordered by similarity (best match first).
| Original | Substitutes | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 2-Row Pale (US) | Pilsner malt (reduce by 5%), Maris Otter | Pilsner gives slightly lighter, crisper result. Maris Otter adds biscuity character. |
| Pilsner malt | 2-Row Pale (add 5% more), Pale Ale malt | 2-Row slightly less fermentable. Pale Ale adds more body. |
| Maris Otter | 2-Row + 5% Biscuit malt, Golden Promise | Golden Promise is Scottish equivalent — similar character. |
| Vienna malt | Munich malt (use 80% of amount), 2-Row + 5% Crystal 20L | Munich is more intense; reduce amount. |
| Munich malt (Light) | Vienna malt (increase by 20%), 2-Row + 5% Aromatic malt | Vienna is subtler — increase quantity or add Aromatic. |
| Munich malt (Dark) | Munich Light + 5% Melanoidin, Aromatic malt | Melanoidin mimics deep Munich character. |
| Original | Substitutes | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Crystal 10L | Crystal 20L (reduce by 15%), Carapils + tiny Crystal 20L | Very similar; slightly more color from 20L. |
| Crystal 20L | Crystal 10L + 20%, Crystal 40L - 20% | Interchangeable at ±1 SRM. |
| Crystal 40L | Crystal 30L + 20%, Crystal 60L - 20% | Crystal 60L adds more caramel depth. |
| Crystal 60L | Crystal 40L + 50%, Special Roast malt | Special Roast (50L) is close match. |
| Crystal 80L | Crystal 60L + Crystal 120L (50/50), Cara-Munich II | Cara-Munich II (60-70°L) very similar. |
| Crystal 120L | Special B (70% amount) + Crystal 60L, Crystal 80L + 20% | Special B darker and more intense — reduce. |
| Carapils / Cara-Foam | Flaked wheat (same %) + Crystal 10L, Flaked barley | Adds body/head retention differently. |
| Special B | Crystal 120L + 20%, Dark Crystal + Chocolate malt (tiny) | Special B unique for raisin/plum. Approximate with very dark crystal. |
| Original | Substitutes | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Chocolate malt (350°L) | Carafa II (similar), Dark Chocolate malt (adjust %) | Carafa is dehusked — less harsh/astringent. |
| Roasted Barley | Black malt (reduce by 30%), Carafa III (reduce by 30%) | Roasted Barley uniquely dry/acrid — nothing identical. |
| Black Patent malt | Roasted Barley (increase by 30%), Carafa III | Black Patent harsher than Carafa; adjust carefully. |
| Carafa III (dehusked) | Black malt + reduce by 20%, Chocolate malt (increase by 50%) | Carafa gives smoother roast — preferred for Schwarzbier. |
| Original | Substitutes | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Flaked Oats | Flaked Barley (same %), Flaked Wheat | Barley slightly more body; wheat adds protein haze. |
| Flaked Barley | Flaked Oats, Flaked Wheat | All three contribute body and protein. |
| Flaked Wheat | Unmalted wheat, Wheat malt (60% of amount) | Wheat malt is malted so more fermentable. |
| Wheat Malt | Flaked Wheat + 20%, 2-Row + 10% | Flaked wheat less fermentable — increase amount. |
| Rye Malt | Flaked Rye (same %), Spelt malt | Rye malt more fermentable but similar spicy character. |
| Melanoidin malt | Aromatic malt (same %), Munich Dark + extra Crystal | Melanoidin adds unique depth — Aromatic is closest. |
| Biscuit malt | Victory malt (same %), Amber malt + 10% | Victory and Biscuit nearly identical. |
| Brown malt | Victory malt + Biscuit malt (50/50 blend), Amber malt | Brown malt unique — approximate with mix. |
| Original | Substitutes | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Clear Belgian Candi Sugar | Table sugar (sucrose) — 100% equivalent | Sucrose inverts during boil; identical fermentability. |
| Dark Belgian Candi Sugar D90 | Table sugar + Melanoidin malt (0.5% grist) | Add melanoidin for color; flavor will differ. |
| Dark Belgian Candi Sugar D180 | Table sugar + Special B (1% grist) | For Dubbel/Quad dark fruit notes. |
| Corn sugar (dextrose) | Table sugar — 95% equivalent by weight | Very close; sucrose slightly more fermentable. |
| Honey | Table sugar (use 75% of honey weight) | Honey adds floral aroma — no direct substitute. |
| Lactose | No fermentable substitute. For body: add Carapils or Oats. | Lactose is unfermentable — creates sweetness/body. |
| Original | Best Substitute | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Cascade | Centennial (use 60%), Amarillo | Centennial more intense — reduce rate. |
| Centennial | Cascade (use 130%), Columbus (bittering only) | Cascade lower AA — increase significantly. |
| Chinook | Columbus + Simcoe blend, Nugget (bittering) | For bittering: Columbus; for flavor: Simcoe. |
| Citra | Amarillo + Mosaic blend (50/50), Galaxy | Blend to approximate Citra's complexity. |
| Mosaic | Citra + Galaxy (50/50), El Dorado | Mosaic very unique — blending helps. |
| Amarillo | Citra (use 70%), Centennial | Citra brighter/more tropical; reduce rate. |
| Galaxy | Citra + Ekuanot, Mosaic | Australian hops hard to replicate exactly. |
| Simcoe | Chinook + Mosaic (50/50), Columbus | Pine/earthy from Chinook; tropical from Mosaic. |
| Saaz | Tettnang (same rate), Hallertau Mittelfrueh | All noble hops interchangeable at similar rates. |
| Hallertau Mittelfrueh | Tettnang, Saaz | Same noble character. |
| Tettnang | Saaz (same rate), Hallertau | Most interchangeable of noble hops. |
| Fuggle | East Kent Goldings (same rate), Willamette | EKG slightly more floral. Willamette = US Fuggle. |
| East Kent Goldings | Fuggle (same rate), Styrian Goldings | Styrian is Slovenian but very similar. |
| Nelson Sauvin | Hallertau Blanc (same rate) | Both have wine/white grape character. |
| Columbus (CTZ) | Chinook (same rate), Nugget | Similar high-AA bittering profile. |
| Magnum | Warrior, Apollo, Nugget | All are clean bittering hops — interchangeable. |
| Original | Best Substitute | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Wyeast 1056 | SafAle US-05, WLP001 | Identical character. US-05 is the dry equivalent. |
| WLP001 | Wyeast 1056, SafAle US-05 | Identical character. |
| SafAle US-05 | WLP001, Wyeast 1056 | Same strain available in liquid form. |
| Wyeast 1968 | SafAle S-04, WLP002 | S-04 is dry equivalent. Very high flocculation. |
| WLP002 | Wyeast 1968, SafAle S-04 | Classic English character. |
| Wyeast 3068 | WLP300 (Hefeweizen Ale) | Both produce banana/clove. WLP300 similar profile. |
| Wyeast 3787 | WLP530, Wyeast 1762 | 1762 for darker Belgians; WLP530 for Trappist ales. |
| Wyeast 1762 | Wyeast 3787 (different fruit), WLP540 | 3787 fruitier/spicier; less dark fruit than 1762. |
| Wyeast 3944 | WLP400 (Belgian Wit Ale) | Both designed for Witbier. |
| Wyeast 2565 (Kölsch) | WLP029 | Same Kölsch style yeast. |
| W-34/70 (dry) | WLP830, Wyeast 2124 | Liquid equivalents of the classic Weihenstephan lager strain. |
| Wyeast 2124 | WLP830, W-34/70 | All are Weihenstephan 34/70 equivalents. |
| WLP066 (London III) | Wyeast 1318 | Near-identical NEIPA yeast. Both from same heritage. |
| Wyeast 1318 | WLP066 | Same heritage strain. Essential for NEIPA biotransformation. |
| Kveik Voss | Kveik Hornindal, Kveik Stranda | Any Kveik strain at high temps. Different ester profiles. |
When specific water profile ingredients are unavailable:
| Target Profile | Key Minerals | Style Application |
|---|---|---|
| Burton (UK IPA) | High sulfate (500+ ppm) | Enhances hop bitterness perception |
| Dublin (Stout) | High bicarbonate, low calcium | Enhances roast character |
| Pilsen (Czech Pils) | Very soft water, near zero minerals | Clean malt + delicate hop |
| London (ESB) | Moderate bicarbonate + chloride | Rounds malt, softens bitterness |
| Generic Neutral | 50–100 ppm Ca, 50 ppm Cl, 100 ppm SO4 | Works for most styles |
Quick mineral guide:
When converting an all-grain recipe to extract (or vice versa):
| Grain format | → Dry Malt Extract (DME) | → Liquid Malt Extract (LME) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 kg base malt (75% brewhouse efficiency) | ~0.70–0.75 kg DME | ~0.85–0.90 kg LME |
| 1 kg base malt (70% efficiency) | ~0.65–0.70 kg DME | ~0.80–0.85 kg LME |
Colour guidance:
PPG reference:
Exceeding these limits causes lautering, attenuation, or flavour problems:
| Adjunct | Max % | Effect if exceeded |
|---|---|---|
| Flaked oats | 20–25% (30% for oat stout) | Stuck sparge, excessive starch haze, cloying body |
| Flaked wheat | 30% | Stuck sparge, protein haze issues |
| Flaked corn / maize | 30% | Astringency, poor head retention above 35% |
| Flaked rice | 25% | Thin body if over 30%, stuck sparge risk |
| Flaked barley | 20% | Excessive beta-glucan — very sticky lauter |
| Lactose | 3–8% | Cloyingly sweet above 8%; does not ferment |
| Table sugar / sucrose | 15–20% | Thin body, "cidery" character above 20% |
| Honey | 10–15% | Floral aroma washed out above 15%; thin body |
| Rye malt | 15–20% | Extremely sticky sparge above 20%; add rice hulls |
| Smoked malt (beechwood) | 30–50% | Overwhelming smoke above 60%; blend to taste |
| Acid malt (Sauermalz) | 3–5% | pH drops too fast above 5%; bitter/sharp |
General rule: Always add rice hulls (200–400 g per 20 L batch) when using >15% flaked/unmalted adjuncts to prevent a stuck sparge.
When adapting recipes for local ingredient markets:
