validate-plan-file

name	validate-plan-file
description	Validate that orchestrator plan files conform to expected JSON schema. Use before workers read plan files or after orchestrators create them to ensure proper structure and required fields.
allowed-tools	Read

Validate Plan File

Validate orchestrator plan files to ensure they conform to the expected schema before workers process them.

When to Use

• Before workers read plan files
• After orchestrators create plan files
• When debugging plan file issues
• In quality gates validation

Instructions

Step 1: Read Plan File

Use Read tool to load the plan file.

Expected Input:

• file_path: Path to plan file (e.g., .bug-detection-plan.json, .security-scan-plan.json)

Tools Used: Read

Step 2: Determine Schema

Map file name pattern to appropriate JSON schema.

Schema Mapping:

• .bug-*-plan.json → .claude/schemas/bug-plan.schema.json
• .security-*-plan.json → .claude/schemas/security-plan.schema.json
• .dead-code-*-plan.json → .claude/schemas/dead-code-plan.schema.json
• .dependency-*-plan.json → .claude/schemas/dependency-plan.schema.json
• .version-*-plan.json → base schema (version update workflow)

New Naming Convention (standardized):

• Bug workflow: .bug-detection-plan.json, .bug-fixing-plan.json, .bug-verification-plan.json
• Security workflow: .security-scan-plan.json, .security-remediation-plan.json, .security-verification-plan.json
• Dead code workflow: .dead-code-detection-plan.json, .dead-code-cleanup-plan.json, .dead-code-verification-plan.json
• Dependency workflow: .dependency-audit-plan.json, .dependency-update-plan.json, .dependency-verification-plan.json

Step 3: Load and Parse JSON Schema

Use Read tool to load the appropriate schema file from .claude/schemas/.

Tools Used: Read

Step 4: Validate JSON Against Schema

Validate the plan file content against the loaded JSON schema.

Base Schema Validation (all plan files):

• workflow: String (required, e.g., "bug-management", "security-audit")
• phase: String (required, e.g., "detection", "fixing", "verification")
• phaseNumber: Integer (optional, for sequencing)
• config: Object (required, domain-specific configuration)
• validation: Object (required, with required array of validation criteria)
• nextAgent: String (optional, agent to invoke next)
• timestamp: String (optional, ISO-8601 format)
• metadata: Object (optional, with createdBy, iteration, maxIterations)

Domain-Specific Validation:

Bug Plans:

• config.priority: "critical"|"high"|"medium"|"low"|"all" (required)
• config.categories: Array of bug types (optional)
• config.maxBugsPerRun: Integer (optional, default 50)
• config.verifyOnly: Boolean (optional, default false)

Security Plans:

• config.severity: "critical"|"high"|"medium"|"low"|"all" (required)
• config.categories: Array of vulnerability types (optional)
• config.maxVulnsPerRun: Integer (optional, default 25)
• config.skipSupabaseRLS: Boolean (optional, default false)

Dead Code Plans:

• config.type: "critical"|"high"|"medium"|"low"|"all" (required)
• config.categories: Array of dead code types (optional)
• config.maxItemsPerRun: Integer (optional, default 100)
• config.safeMode: Boolean (optional, default true)

Dependency Plans:

• config.category: "security"|"unused"|"outdated"|"all" (required)
• config.severity: "critical"|"high"|"medium"|"low"|"all" (optional)
• config.maxUpdatesPerRun: Integer (optional, default 10)
• config.updateStrategy: "one-at-a-time"|"batch-compatible"|"all" (optional)

Step 5: Return Validation Result

Return detailed validation result with errors/warnings.

Expected Output:

{
  "valid": true,
  "file": ".bug-detection-plan.json",
  "errors": [],
  "warnings": [],
  "schema": "bug-plan",
  "schemaPath": ".claude/schemas/bug-plan.schema.json"
}

Error Handling

• File Not Found: Return error with file path
• Invalid JSON: Return parsing error with line number if possible
• Schema File Not Found: Return error if schema file missing
• Missing Required Fields: List all missing fields from JSON schema validation
• Invalid Field Types: Describe type mismatches (e.g., expected string, got number)
• Invalid Enum Values: Report when value not in allowed enum list
• Schema Mismatch: Warn if file doesn't match expected schema pattern
• Validation Array Errors: Report missing or invalid validation criteria

Examples

Example 1: Valid Bug Detection Plan

Input:

file_path: .bug-detection-plan.json

Content:

{
  "workflow": "bug-management",
  "phase": "detection",
  "phaseNumber": 1,
  "config": {
    "priority": "all",
    "categories": ["type-errors", "runtime-errors"],
    "maxBugsPerRun": 50
  },
  "validation": {
    "required": ["report-exists", "type-check"],
    "optional": ["tests"]
  },
  "nextAgent": "bug-hunter",
  "timestamp": "2025-10-18T14:00:00Z",
  "metadata": {
    "createdBy": "bug-orchestrator",
    "iteration": 1,
    "maxIterations": 3
  }
}

Output:

{
  "valid": true,
  "file": ".bug-detection-plan.json",
  "errors": [],
  "warnings": [],
  "schema": "bug-plan",
  "schemaPath": ".claude/schemas/bug-plan.schema.json"
}

Example 2: Missing Required Field

Input:

file_path: .security-scan-plan.json

Content:

{
  "workflow": "security-audit",
  "phase": "scan",
  "config": {
    "categories": ["sql-injection"]
  },
  "validation": {
    "required": ["report-exists"]
  }
}

Output:

{
  "valid": false,
  "file": ".security-scan-plan.json",
  "errors": [
    "Missing required property: config.severity",
    "Schema validation failed at /config/severity: required property missing"
  ],
  "warnings": [],
  "schema": "security-plan",
  "schemaPath": ".claude/schemas/security-plan.schema.json"
}

Example 3: Invalid Enum Value

Input:

file_path: .dependency-audit-plan.json

Content:

{
  "workflow": "dependency-management",
  "phase": "audit",
  "config": {
    "category": "deprecated",
    "severity": "critical"
  },
  "validation": {
    "required": ["report-exists", "lockfile-valid"]
  },
  "nextAgent": "dependency-auditor"
}

Output:

{
  "valid": false,
  "file": ".dependency-audit-plan.json",
  "errors": [
    "Invalid enum value at /config/category: 'deprecated' not in allowed values ['security', 'unused', 'outdated', 'all']"
  ],
  "warnings": [],
  "schema": "dependency-plan",
  "schemaPath": ".claude/schemas/dependency-plan.schema.json"
}

Example 4: Workflow/Phase Mismatch

Input:

file_path: .bug-fixing-plan.json

Content:

{
  "workflow": "security-audit",
  "phase": "fixing",
  "config": {
    "priority": "critical"
  },
  "validation": {
    "required": ["type-check"]
  }
}

Output:

{
  "valid": false,
  "file": ".bug-fixing-plan.json",
  "errors": [
    "Schema mismatch: file pattern suggests 'bug-plan' schema but workflow field is 'security-audit'",
    "Invalid enum value at /phase: 'fixing' not in allowed values ['detection', 'fixing', 'verification'] for bug-plan"
  ],
  "warnings": [
    "Consider renaming file to match workflow: .security-remediation-plan.json"
  ],
  "schema": "bug-plan",
  "schemaPath": ".claude/schemas/bug-plan.schema.json"
}

Validation

• Validates all required fields present
• Checks field types correctly (string, number, boolean, array, object)
• Validates enum values against allowed lists
• Identifies schema based on file name pattern
• Returns clear error messages with JSON paths
• Handles malformed JSON gracefully
• Validates domain-specific fields (priority, severity, category)
• Checks workflow/phase consistency
• Validates validation criteria arrays (required/optional)
• Handles schema file loading errors

Supporting Files

Located in .claude/schemas/:

• base-plan.schema.json: Base schema for all plan files
• bug-plan.schema.json: Bug management workflow schema
• security-plan.schema.json: Security audit workflow schema
• dead-code-plan.schema.json: Dead code cleanup workflow schema
• dependency-plan.schema.json: Dependency management workflow schema

Integration with Orchestrators

All orchestrators should use this Skill after creating plan files:

## Step 3: Create Plan File

1. Write plan to `.{domain}-{phase}-plan.json`
2. Use validate-plan-file Skill to verify:
   - Input: file_path = ".{domain}-{phase}-plan.json"
   - Check result.valid === true
   - If errors exist, fix plan file and retry
3. Only signal readiness after validation passes

Notes

JSON Schema Validation: This Skill performs full JSON Schema Draft-07 validation including:

• Type checking (string, number, boolean, array, object)
• Required properties
• Enum constraints
• Pattern matching
• Nested object validation (allOf, $ref)
• Array item validation

File Naming Convention: Plan files must follow pattern .{domain}-{phase}-plan.json where:

• {domain}: bug|security|dead-code|dependency
• {phase}: detection|fixing|verification (bugs), scan|remediation|verification (security), etc.

Schema References: Uses JSON Schema $ref for base schema inheritance. All domain schemas extend base-plan.schema.json.