speckle-impl-federation

name	speckle-impl-federation
description	Use when exchanging data between multiple design tools via Speckle, planning federated model workflows, or resolving cross-tool data conflicts. Prevents applicationId instability across round-trips, geometry fidelity loss from baking, and broken proxy references in federated views. Covers cross-tool data exchange patterns, federated views, proxy-based relationships, applicationId stability, geometry baking for interoperability, asymmetric fidelity, common workflows (Revit to GH to Revit), conflict resolution, and versioning strategies. Keywords: speckle federation, cross-tool, data exchange, interoperability, applicationId, geometry baking, federated model, round-trip, combine models, Revit to Rhino, exchange between tools.
license	MIT
compatibility	Designed for Claude Code. Requires Speckle Server 2.x/3.x, multiple Speckle Connectors.
metadata	{"author":"OpenAEC-Foundation","version":"1.0"}

speckle-impl-federation

Quick Reference

Federation Architecture

Concept	Description	Key Constraint
Federated View	Multiple models from different tools loaded into one Speckle project	Each model retains its source hierarchy
applicationId	Stable cross-version identifier from the source application	NEVER use content-based id for tracking — it changes on every data update
displayValue	Interoperable geometry primitives (Mesh, Line, Point)	ALWAYS the universal fallback — Brep only for Rhino-capable receivers
Proxy	Relationship container linking objects to shared resources	Proxies reference objects by applicationId, NEVER by id
Asymmetric Fidelity	Publishing preserves MORE data than loading can reconstruct	ALWAYS plan for information loss on the receiving side
Collections	Hierarchical containers preserving source application structure	Each connector writes its own hierarchy pattern

Fidelity Loss Matrix

This matrix defines EXACTLY what happens when data moves between tool pairs. Every cell describes the receiving outcome.

Source \ Target	Revit	Rhino	Grasshopper	Blender	AutoCAD	Archicad	SketchUp	Power BI
Revit	Direct Shapes	Geometry + user strings	Data Objects	Mesh + materials	Geometry + layers	GDL Objects	Components	Tabular + 3D
Rhino	Direct Shapes	Native geometry	Geometry Objects	Mesh + curves	Geometry + layers	GDL Objects	Components	Tabular + 3D
Grasshopper	Direct Shapes	Geometry	Geometry Objects	Mesh + curves	Geometry + layers	GDL Objects	Components	Tabular + 3D
Blender	Direct Shapes	Mesh + curves	Data Objects	Native mesh	Geometry + layers	GDL Objects	Components	Tabular + 3D
AutoCAD	Direct Shapes	Geometry	Geometry Objects	Mesh (no solids)	Geometry + layers	GDL Objects	Components	Tabular + 3D
Tekla	Direct Shapes	Geometry	Data Objects	Mesh	Geometry + layers	GDL Objects	Components	Tabular + 3D
Archicad	Direct Shapes	Geometry + user strings	Data Objects	Mesh + materials	Geometry + layers	GDL Objects	Components	Tabular + 3D

Reading this matrix: Find the source tool in rows, target tool in columns. The cell describes what the target tool produces when loading from that source.

Critical Warnings

NEVER assume native element recreation on load. Revit ALWAYS creates Direct Shapes. Archicad ALWAYS creates GDL Objects. There is NO native wall, door, or floor reconstruction in ANY connector.

NEVER rely on content-based id for cross-version tracking. The id is a hash of the object's content — it changes every time the object is modified. ALWAYS use applicationId for stable tracking.

NEVER assume bidirectional capability. Tekla is publish-only. Power BI is load-only (read-only visualization). ALWAYS verify connector direction before planning a workflow.

NEVER expect custom properties to survive a full round-trip. Revit, Blender, and Archicad do NOT load custom properties onto received objects. Properties are preserved in Speckle's data model and visible in the web viewer, but the host application may silently drop them.

NEVER expect textures to transfer. Speckle does NOT support textures across ANY connector. Only material properties (color, opacity, metallic, roughness) transfer via RenderMaterial proxies.

---

Federated View Patterns

Pattern 1: Multi-Discipline Coordination

Multiple teams publish to the same Speckle project from different tools. The federated view shows all models together in the web viewer or Power BI.

Architect (Revit)     ──publish──> Speckle Project / architecture
Structural (Tekla)    ──publish──> Speckle Project / structure
MEP (Revit)           ──publish──> Speckle Project / mep
Landscape (Rhino)     ──publish──> Speckle Project / landscape
                                        │
                                        ▼
                              Federated View (Viewer / Power BI)

Each model retains its source hierarchy in Collections:

• Architecture: File > Level > Category > Type (Revit pattern)
• Structure: File > Type (Tekla pattern)
• Landscape: File > Layer > Sublayer (Rhino pattern)

Pattern 2: Design Iteration (Revit to Grasshopper to Revit)

The most common cross-tool workflow in AEC:

Step 1: Publish from Revit
        Revit wall (ElementId=12345) → RevitObject with applicationId="12345"
        Properties: type, family, category, level, material quantities
        Geometry: displayValue = [Mesh]

Step 2: Load in Grasshopper
        RevitObject → Data Object (castable to geometry if single displayValue)
        Properties accessible via Deconstruct component
        applicationId preserved: "12345"

Step 3: Modify in Grasshopper
        Use Passthrough nodes to mutate the loaded object
        ALWAYS preserve applicationId — NEVER create new objects from scratch
        Publish back to Speckle

Step 4: Load in Revit
        Modified object → Direct Shape (NOT a native wall)
        Original wall parameters are LOST as native Revit properties
        Properties visible only as Speckle metadata

Key rule: On return to Revit, objects ALWAYS become Direct Shapes. The native Revit "wall-ness" is permanently lost after a round-trip through any other tool.

Pattern 3: Design Option Comparison

Publish multiple versions from different tools or iterations. Compare in the web viewer using version history.

Option A (Revit v1)   ──publish──> Model / design-options  (version 1)
Option B (Revit v2)   ──publish──> Model / design-options  (version 2)
Option C (Rhino)      ──publish──> Model / design-options  (version 3)

The viewer displays version history with diff capabilities. Each version is immutable — previous versions are NEVER overwritten.

---

applicationId Stability Rules

The applicationId is the ONLY stable identifier across versions. These rules are non-negotiable:

Source Application Mapping

Connector	applicationId Source	Format	Stability
Revit	ElementId	Integer string (e.g., "12345")	Stable within project file; changes on copy/paste to new project
Rhino	Object GUID	UUID (e.g., "a1b2c3d4-...")	Stable within file
AutoCAD	Handle	Hex string (e.g., "1A2B")	Stable within file
Civil 3D	Handle	Hex string	Stable within file
Archicad	Element GUID	UUID	Stable within project
Tekla	GUID	UUID	Stable within model
Blender	Object name	String	Stable only if user does not rename
SketchUp	Persistent ID	Integer	Stable within file

Grasshopper applicationId Problem

Grasshopper parameters generate NEW GUIDs on every Grasshopper solve cycle. This breaks change tracking completely.

Solution: ALWAYS use Passthrough nodes to mutate existing loaded objects. Passthrough nodes preserve the original applicationId from the source application. NEVER create new objects from scratch in Grasshopper if you need change tracking.

Proxy Reference Integrity

Proxies (RenderMaterial, Level, Group, Definition, Color) reference objects by applicationId:

RenderMaterial Proxy:
  applicationId: "mat-brick-red"
  objects: ["12345", "12346", "12347"]   ← these are applicationIds of objects

If an object's applicationId changes (e.g., Grasshopper regenerates it), the proxy reference breaks silently. The object loses its material/level/group association with NO error message.

---

Geometry Baking Strategy

The displayValue Contract

Every DataObject MUST include displayValue — an array of interoperable geometry primitives:

Primitive	Used By	Description
Mesh	ALL connectors	Universal fallback — triangulated geometry with optional vertex colors
Line	Most connectors	Straight line segment between two points
Point	Most connectors	Single coordinate in 3D space
Polyline	Most connectors	Connected sequence of line segments
Arc	Some connectors	Circular arc defined by plane, radius, angles
Brep	Rhino, Grasshopper	NURBS boundary representation — ONLY useful for Rhino-ecosystem receivers

Baking Rules

1. Mesh is king: ANY receiver can display a Mesh. ALWAYS include Mesh geometry in displayValue for maximum interoperability.
2. Brep is bonus: Include Brep data ONLY when the source application natively works with NURBS. Rhino and Grasshopper can use it; all other connectors ignore it and fall back to Mesh.
3. Solids vanish: AutoCAD and Civil 3D solids are ALWAYS converted to Mesh during publishing. This conversion is irreversible. NEVER plan a workflow that requires solid geometry to survive the Speckle pipeline.
4. Units travel with objects: Every geometry object carries a units field. Unit conversion happens automatically during the conversion pipeline. NEVER assume all objects share the same unit system in a federated model.

What Survives Cross-Tool Exchange

Data Type	Survives?	Notes
Mesh geometry	ALWAYS	Universal primitive
Brep geometry	Rhino ecosystem only	Other tools get Mesh fallback
Material properties	ALWAYS (via proxy)	Color, opacity, metallic, roughness
Textures	NEVER	Not supported in any connector
Custom properties	Varies by target	Revit, Blender, Archicad DROP on load
Level associations	BIM connectors only	Via Level proxy
Block/Instance definitions	Most connectors	Via Definition proxy
Named views	Perspective only	No orthographic/plan/section views
Element categories	Source-specific	Lost on cross-tool transfer
Native type information	NEVER on load	Direct Shapes / GDL Objects only

---

Conflict Resolution

Version Conflicts

When multiple users publish to the same model from different tools:

1. No automatic merge: Speckle does NOT merge versions. Each publish creates a new version. The latest version replaces the previous one for that model.
2. Branch strategy: Use separate models (branches) per discipline. Federate at the project level, not the model level.
3. Version history: All previous versions are preserved and accessible. NEVER rely on overwriting — Speckle is append-only for versions.

Coordinate System Alignment

Connector	Reference Point Options	Default
Revit	Internal Origin, Project Base, Survey Point	Internal Origin
Archicad	Project Origin	Project Origin
Rhino	World Origin	World Origin
AutoCAD	World Origin	World Origin
Civil 3D	World Origin (NO reference point option)	World Origin
Blender	World Origin	World Origin

Critical rule: ALWAYS align reference points BEFORE publishing to a federated project. Misaligned reference points cause models to appear in wrong positions. The most common mistake is mixing Revit's Internal Origin with Survey Point across different Revit files in the same project.

Duplicate Object Resolution

When the same physical element exists in multiple source models (e.g., a shared wall between architect and structural engineer):

1. No deduplication: Speckle does NOT deduplicate across models. Both versions exist in the federated view.
2. applicationId collision: Different tools assign different applicationId values to the same physical element. There is NO automatic cross-tool identity matching.
3. Manual coordination: Teams MUST agree on ownership boundaries. One discipline owns each element category.

---

Versioning Strategies for Federation

Strategy 1: Model-Per-Discipline

Project/
├── architecture/    ← Revit (architect)
├── structure/       ← Tekla (structural engineer)
├── mep/             ← Revit (MEP engineer)
├── landscape/       ← Rhino (landscape architect)
└── coordination/    ← Federated analysis results

Each discipline publishes to its own model. Federation happens at the project level. This is the RECOMMENDED approach for multi-discipline projects.

Strategy 2: Model-Per-Zone

Project/
├── building-a/      ← Multiple disciplines for Building A
├── building-b/      ← Multiple disciplines for Building B
└── site/            ← Site-wide elements

Useful for large campus projects where zone-based coordination matters more than discipline-based.

Strategy 3: Version Tagging Convention

ALWAYS establish a version naming convention before starting federated workflows:

[DISCIPLINE]-[PHASE]-[DATE]-[DESCRIPTION]
Examples:
  ARCH-SD-20260320-initial-layout
  STRUCT-DD-20260320-column-grid-update
  MEP-CD-20260320-duct-routing-v2

---

Collection Hierarchy Preservation

Each connector writes a specific hierarchy pattern into Speckle Collections. Understanding this is essential for navigating federated data:

Connector	Hierarchy Pattern	Example Path
Revit	File > Level > Category > Type	Building.rvt / Level 1 / Walls / Basic Wall - 200mm
Rhino	File > Layer > Sublayer	Model.3dm / Architecture / Facades / Glass Panels
AutoCAD	File > Layer	Site.dwg / Boundaries
Civil 3D	File > Layer	Roads.dwg / Alignment-Centerlines
Archicad	File > Floor > Type	Building.pln / Ground Floor / Wall
Tekla	File > Type	Structure.db1 / Beam
Grasshopper	User-defined Collections	analysis / load-paths / primary

Key insight: Consumers of federated data can navigate using the source application's familiar hierarchy. A structural engineer browsing the architect's model sees Revit's Level > Category > Type structure intact.

---

Power BI Federation

Power BI is the primary tool for federated model analysis. It provides unique federation capabilities:

Manual Federation Function

Speckle.Models.Federate(model1, model2, ..., modelN)

This function combines multiple loaded models into a single federated dataset for unified querying and 3D visualization.

Federation Analysis Workflow

1. Load each discipline model using the Power BI Connector
2. Use Speckle.Models.Federate() to combine datasets
3. Cross-reference properties across disciplines using shared spatial coordinates
4. Visualize federated model in the 3D Viewer Visual
5. Build dashboards comparing metrics across disciplines

Power BI Limitations in Federation

• Read-only: CANNOT modify or publish data back
• Tabular data model: Complex nested properties require Speckle.Utils.ExpandRecord()
• No clash detection: Spatial analysis must be done manually or via Automate

---

Reference Links

• references/methods.md — Federation API methods, proxy structures, collection operations
• references/examples.md — Complete federation workflow examples with code
• references/anti-patterns.md — What NOT to do in federated workflows

Official Sources

• https://docs.speckle.systems/developers/data-schema/overview.md
• https://docs.speckle.systems/developers/data-schema/proxy-schema.md
• https://docs.speckle.systems/developers/data-schema/connector-index.md
• https://docs.speckle.systems/connectors/revit/revit.md
• https://docs.speckle.systems/connectors/grasshopper/grasshopper.md
• https://docs.speckle.systems/connectors/power-bi/power-bi.md