vivado-impl

name

vivado-impl

description

Use this skill when the user needs help with Vivado implementation strategy selection and optimization. This includes opt_design (logic optimization directives and options), place_design (placement directives, congestion analysis, PSIP physical synthesis), phys_opt_design (physical optimization - fanout/placement/routing/SLR crossing/register optimization, hold fixing), route_design (routing directives, congestion resolution, pre-routing critical nets), power_opt_design (clock gating, BRAM power optimization), incremental implementation (read_checkpoint -incremental, auto_incremental, reuse analysis), ECO flow, implementation run strategies (Performance/Congestion/Area strategies), or any question about choosing between implementation directives or resolving timing/congestion issues during implementation. This skill provides decision-making knowledge for the implementation phase — for TCL command execution use vivado-tcl, for synthesis use vivado-synth, for constraints use vivado-constraints, for timing report interpretation and analysis use vivado-analysis.

Vivado Implementation Decision Guide

Based on UG904 (v2025.2). For command syntax and property tables see REFERENCE.md; for report_qor_suggestions RTL optimization examples (UG906 before/after) see examples/ug906/ directory.

Implementation Flow Overview

opt_design          ← Logic optimization (REQUIRED)
  ↓
power_opt_design    ← Clock gating power opt (OPTIONAL, not Versal)
  ↓
place_design        ← Placement (REQUIRED)
  ↓
power_opt_design    ← Post-place power opt (OPTIONAL)
  ↓
phys_opt_design     ← Post-place physical opt (OPTIONAL, recommended)
  ↓
route_design        ← Routing (REQUIRED)
  ↓
phys_opt_design     ← Post-route physical opt (OPTIONAL)
  ↓
write_bitstream     ← Bitstream (all except Versal)
write_device_image  ← Device image (Versal only)

Key rule: All implementation commands are re-entrant — they can be run repeatedly on the same design. Each run optimizes the results of the previous run.

---

opt_design — Logic Optimization

Directive Decision Table

Scenario	Directive	Effect
Default / first try	Default	Default optimization phases
Deep exploration	Explore	Multiple passes of optimization
Area reduction (comb)	ExploreArea	Multiple passes, emphasis on reducing combinational logic
Area reduction (comb+seq)	ExploreSequentialArea	Reduces both combinational and sequential logic
Explore + LUT remap	ExploreWithRemap	Explore + Remap optimization
Fast iteration	RuntimeOptimized	Minimal optimization passes
QoR-suggested	RQS	Uses report_qor_suggestion strategy

Available Optimizations (18 phases)

Phase	Option	Default	Description
1	-retarget	ON	Retarget primitives across device families
2	-propconst	ON	Constant propagation
3	-sweep	ON	Remove loadless cells, tie-off, retarget dual-port→single-port RAM
4	-muxf_remap	off	Remap MUXF7/F8/F9 to LUT3 for routability
5	-carry_remap	off	Remap short CARRY chains to LUTs
6	-control_set_merge	off	Merge equivalent control set drivers
7	-merge_equivalent_drivers	off	Merge all equivalent drivers (not just control)
8	-bufg_opt	ON	Insert BUFG on high-fanout clock/non-clock nets
9	-shift_register_opt	ON	SRL fanout opt + SRL↔register transforms
10	-mbufg_opt	off	Replace parallel BUFGCEs with MBUFG (Versal)
11	-dsp_register_opt	off	Optimize DSP pipeline registers
12	(auto)	ON	Control Set Reduction (CONTROL_SET_REMAP property)
13	-hier_fanout_limit <N>	off	Module-based fanout replication
13	-control_set_opt	off	Control Set Optimization (auto-selected candidates)
14	-remap	off	Combine cascaded LUTs to reduce logic levels
15	-resynth_remap	off	Timing-driven re-synthesis + remap
16	-resynth_area

IMPORTANT: Specifying individual options disables ALL default options. To run defaults + extras: opt_design -retarget -propconst -sweep -bufg_opt -shift_register_opt -bram_power_opt -remap

---

place_design — Placement

Directive Decision Table

Scenario	Directive	Designs Benefited
Default	Default	All
Deep exploration	Explore	All (higher effort detail placement)
Aggressive exploration	AggressiveExplore	Timing-critical designs
RAM/DSP dense	WLDrivenBlockPlacement	Many BRAM/DSP blocks
RAM/DSP dense	EarlyBlockPlacement	RAM/DSP as placement anchors
Timing meets post-place but fails post-route	ExtraNetDelay_high	Long-distance nets, high fanout
Timing meets post-place but fails post-route	ExtraNetDelay_low	Same, lower pessimism
Congestion	AltSpreadLogic_high	High connectivity → congestion
Congestion (moderate)	AltSpreadLogic_medium/low	Moderate congestion
SSI congestion	SSI_SpreadLogic_high/low	SSI devices
SSI SLR balancing	SSI_SpreadSLLs	Balance SLL connections across SLRs
SSI SLR balancing	SSI_BalanceSLLs	Balance SLLs between SLRs
SSI SLR balancing	SSI_BalanceSLRs	Balance cell count between SLRs
SSI high utilization	SSI_HighUtilSLRs	Pack logic closer in each SLR
Extra post-place opt	ExtraPostPlacementOpt	All
Alternate timing	ExtraTimingOpt	Alternative timing-driven algorithms
ML-predicted best	Auto_1	Highest confidence ML prediction
ML-predicted 2nd	Auto_2	Second best ML prediction

Key Options

Option	Effect
-post_place_opt	Extra timing optimization after placement
-timing_summary	Force STA-based timing summary (more accurate, slower)
-no_timing_driven	Wirelength-only placement (fastest)
-no_psip	Disable Physical Synthesis in Placer
-no_bufg_opt	Disable BUFG insertion during placement
-sll_align_opt	Align SLL registers for SSI multi-die parts
-ultrathreads	Parallel placement across SLRs (UltraScale+ SSI)
-unplace	Remove all non-fixed placements

---

phys_opt_design — Physical Optimization

Two Modes

• Post-place: More aggressive, based on placement timing estimates
• Post-route: More conservative, uses actual routed delays, auto-updates routing

TIP: Post-route phys_opt is most effective on designs with few failing paths (WNS > -0.200 ns). Designs with > 200 failing endpoints see little improvement.

Directive Decision Table

Scenario	Directive	Effect
Default	Default	Default optimizations
Deep exploration	Explore	Multi-pass + SLR crossing + critical path final phase
Explore + hold fix	ExploreWithHoldFix	Explore + hold violation fixing
Explore + aggressive hold	ExploreWithAggressiveHoldFix	Explore + aggressive hold fixing
Most aggressive	AggressiveExplore	Allows WNS degradation in SLR crossing opt
Alternative replication	AlternateReplication	Different critical cell replication algorithm
Fanout-focused	AggressiveFanoutOpt	Aggressive fanout optimization
Add retiming	AddRetime	Default flow + register retiming
Aggressive + retiming	AlternateFlowWithRetiming	Aggressive replication + DSP/BRAM opt + retiming
Fast	RuntimeOptimized	Fewest iterations

Key Individual Options

Setup optimization (post-place defaults):

Option	Description
-fanout_opt	Replicate high-fanout net drivers (default post-place)
-critical_cell_opt	Replicate cells in failing paths (default post-place)
-placement_opt	Re-place critical path cells (default both modes)
-dsp_register_opt	Move registers in/out of DSP cells
-bram_register_opt	Move registers in/out of BRAM cells
-uram_register_opt	Move registers in/out of UltraRAM cells
-shift_register_opt	Extract SRL end stages to improve timing
-restruct_opt	Swap LUT connections to reduce logic levels
-lut_opt	Single LUT movement/replication
-clock_opt	Useful clock skew optimization

Routing optimization (post-route defaults):

Option	Description
-routing_opt	Re-route critical nets/pins (default post-route)
-slr_crossing_opt	Optimize inter-SLR paths (default both modes)
-critical_pin_opt	Remap LUT pins to faster physical pins

Hold fixing:

Option	Description
-hold_fix	Fix hold violations above threshold
-aggressive_hold_fix	Fix more hold violations
-sll_reg_hold_fix	SLL register hold fix (UltraScale+)
-insert_negative_edge_ffs	Insert neg-edge FFs to split hold paths

Other:

Option	Description
-retime	Register retiming (Versal)
-interconnect_retime	Interconnect retiming by FF movement (Versal)
-force_replication_on_nets <nets>	Force driver replication on specific nets
-equ_drivers_opt	Rewire loads to equivalent drivers
-casc_opt	LUT cascade optimization (Versal)
-cell_group_opt	Critical fanin cone group opt (Versal)
-bram_enable_opt	Reverse BRAM power opt on timing-critical enable paths
-path_groups <args>	Limit optimization to specific path groups
-tns_cleanup	Allow slack degradation if WNS maintained (with -slr_crossing_opt)

---

route_design — Routing

Directive Decision Table

Scenario	Directive	Effect
Default	Default	Default routing
Explore alternatives	Explore	Explore different critical path routes (signoff timing)
Aggressive exploration	AggressiveExplore	More aggressive thresholds
No timing relaxation	NoTimingRelaxation	Never relax timing goals
More iterations	MoreGlobalIterations	Detailed timing analysis all stages
Emphasize delay	HigherDelayCost	Trade compile time for delay optimization
Fast	RuntimeOptimized	Fewest iterations
Congestion	AlternateCLBRouting	Alternate CLB routing algorithms
Fastest	Quick	Non-timing-driven, minimum legal routing
QoR-suggested	RQS	Uses report_qor_suggestion

Key Options

Option	Effect
-tns_cleanup	Focus on WNS, fix non-critical failing paths. Use before post-route phys_opt
-preserve	Preserve existing routes, route remaining. For pre-routing critical nets
-nets <net_objects>	Route only specified nets
-pins <pin_objects>	Route only specified pins
-delay	Route individual nets with smallest delay
-auto_delay	Route with timing-constraint-driven budgets (use with -nets/-pins)
-max_delay <ps> / -min_delay <ps>	Target delay for pin routing (use with -pins)
-unroute	Remove routing (entire design or specific nets/pins)
-timing_summary	Force STA timing summary (more accurate)
-finalize	Complete partially routed connections (ECO flow)
-eco	Incremental ECO routing (faster after small changes)
-ultrathreads	Parallel routing (faster, slight variation between runs)
-no_timing_driven	Disable timing-driven routing (feasibility test only)

Pre-routing Critical Nets Pattern

# Route top 10 critical nets first with minimum delay
set preRoutes [get_nets -of [get_timing_paths -max_paths 10]]
route_design -nets [get_nets $preRoutes] -delay
# Then route rest preserving critical routes
route_design -preserve

---

power_opt_design — Power Optimization

# Basic usage (optimize entire design)
power_opt_design

# Control scope
set_power_opt -include_cells [get_cells inst_A]
set_power_opt -exclude_cells [get_cells inst_B]
set_power_opt -cell_types {BRAM}
set_power_opt -clocks {clk1}

Note: Not supported for Versal. BRAM power opt is skipped if already done by opt_design.

---

Incremental Implementation

Setup

# Non-Project Mode
read_checkpoint -incremental <reference_routed.dcp>
# Automatic incremental (recommended)
read_checkpoint -incremental -auto_incremental <reference.dcp>
# Force incremental even if criteria not met
read_checkpoint -incremental -force_incr <reference.dcp>
# Fix specific objects
read_checkpoint -incremental <ref.dcp> -fix_objects [all_rams]

Incremental Directives

read_checkpoint -incremental -directive <directive> <ref.dcp>

Directive	Effect
RuntimeOptimized	Reuse max, target same WNS as reference (default)
TimingClosure	Rip up failing paths, try harder to close timing
Quick	No timer, fastest, needs WNS > 1.0 ns

Auto Incremental Criteria

• Cell matching ≥ 94%
• Net matching ≥ 90%
• Reference WNS ≥ -0.250 ns

Analysis

report_incremental_reuse -file incr_reuse.rpt

Note: Not supported for Versal.

---

Congestion Analysis & Resolution

Congestion Levels

• Level 5 (32x32 tiles) — warning threshold, expect timing impact
• Level 8+ — router early exit, design likely unroutable

Diagnosis

report_design_analysis -congestion -file congestion.rpt
report_route_status -file route_status.rpt

Resolution Decision Tree

1. Synthesis: Use AlternateRoutability directive, reduce MUXF/CARRY usage
2. opt_design: Use -muxf_remap, -carry_remap, LUT_DECOMPOSE property
3. place_design: Use AltSpreadLogic_high or SSI_SpreadLogic_high
4. route_design: Use AlternateCLBRouting
5. RTL changes: Reduce fanout, pipeline long paths, reduce resource utilization

---

Predefined Implementation Strategies (Project Mode)

Performance-focused

Performance_Auto_1/2/3, Performance_Explore, Performance_ExplorePostRoutePhysOpt, Performance_ExploreWithRemap, Performance_WLBlockPlacement, Performance_WLBlockPlacementFanoutOpt, Performance_EarlyBlockPlacement, Performance_NetDelay_high/low, Performance_Retiming, Performance_ExtraTimingOpt, Performance_RefinePlacement, Performance_SpreadSLLs, Performance_BalanceSLLs, Performance_BalanceSLRs, Performance_HighUtilSLRs

Congestion-focused

Congestion_SpreadLogic_high/medium/low, Congestion_SSI_SpreadLogic_high/low

Area-focused

Area_Explore, Area_ExploreSequential, Area_ExploreWithRemap