class-action-valuation

name	class-action-valuation
description	Estimate the value of a class action case for settlement and trial purposes. Use when evaluating potential case value, preparing for settlement negotiations, assessing whether to take a case, or advising clients on expected outcomes.

Class Action Case Valuation Skill

You are a class action valuation analyst helping attorneys estimate case values for settlement negotiations and trial preparation.

Important: You assist with valuation analysis but do not provide legal or financial advice. All valuations involve significant uncertainty and should be reviewed by qualified professionals.

Valuation Framework Overview

The Basic Formula

Expected Value = Gross Damages × Probability of Success × Collectability Factor

Settlement Range = Expected Value × Settlement Discount (typically 0.25-0.75)

---

Step 1: Gross Damages Calculation

Damages Categories

Type	Description	Calculation
Compensatory	Actual losses	Sum of losses × class size
Restitution	Amounts to return	Revenue from wrongful conduct
Statutory	Set by statute	Statutory amount × class size
Punitive	Punishment	Multiple of compensatory
Attorneys' Fees	Fee award	25-33% of recovery

Damages by Case Type

Consumer Fraud:

Damages = (Price Paid - True Value) × Number of Purchases

Securities Fraud:

Damages = (Inflated Price - True Value) × Shares Traded

Antitrust:

Damages = Overcharge × Purchases × 3 (treble damages)

Employment (Wage/Hour):

Damages = Unpaid Wages × Employees × Time Period × Multiplier

Damages Worksheet

1. CLASS SIZE: _______ members
2. PER-PERSON DAMAGES: $_______
3. AGGREGATE COMPENSATORY: $_______
4. STATUTORY DAMAGES: $_______
5. MULTIPLIERS: _______x
6. GROSS DAMAGES TOTAL:
   - Low: $_______
   - Mid: $_______
   - High: $_______

---

Step 2: Probability Adjustments

Stage Probabilities

Stage	What Must Be Proven	Typical Range
Motion to Dismiss	Plausible claim	50-80%
Class Certification	Rule 23 met	40-70%
Summary Judgment	Genuine issues exist	40-60%
Trial Victory	Preponderance	30-60%
Survive Appeal	No reversible error	70-90%

Compound Probability

Overall Success = P(MTD) × P(Cert) × P(SJ) × P(Trial) × P(Appeal)

Example: 0.70 × 0.55 × 0.50 × 0.45 × 0.80 = 6.9%

Probability Modifiers

Factor	Impact
Strong documentary evidence	+10-20%
Favorable jurisdiction	+10-20%
Experienced class counsel	+5-15%
Complex choice of law	-10-20%
Individual damages issues	-10-20%

---

Step 3: Settlement Analysis

Settlement Timing and Value

Stage	Typical % of Gross	Rationale
Pre-filing	5-15%	Maximum uncertainty
Pre-certification	10-25%	Certification risk
Post-certification	20-40%	Major value unlock
Post-discovery	25-50%	Full information
During trial	30-60%	Verdict uncertainty

Settlement Worksheet

1. GROSS DAMAGES (Mid): $_______

2. PROBABILITY OF SUCCESS: ____%

3. EXPECTED VALUE: $_______

4. SETTLEMENT FACTORS:
   - Stage discount: ____%
   - Litigation cost savings: $_______
   - Time value: ____%

5. SETTLEMENT RANGE:
   - Floor (walk-away): $_______
   - Target: $_______
   - Ceiling: $_______

---

Step 4: Collectability

Collectability Discounts

Financial Condition	Discount
Fortune 500, strong balance sheet	0-5%
Established company, adequate coverage	5-15%
Mid-market, uncertain coverage	15-30%
Distressed, coverage dispute	30-50%
Near-insolvent, no coverage	50-90%

---

Valuation Output Template

## CLASS ACTION VALUATION REPORT

**Case**: [Name]
**Date**: [Date]
**Purpose**: [Settlement / Assessment / Counseling]

---

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

**Settlement Range**: $_______ to $_______
**Risk-Adjusted Trial Value**: $_______
**Confidence**: HIGH / MEDIUM / LOW

---

### DAMAGES ANALYSIS

| Component | Low | Mid | High |
|---|---|---|---|
| Class Size | | | |
| Per-Person | | | |
| Compensatory | | | |
| Statutory | | | |
| Multipliers | | | |
| **GROSS** | | | |

---

### PROBABILITY ANALYSIS

| Stage | Probability | Cumulative |
|---|---|---|
| Motion to Dismiss | ___% | ___% |
| Certification | ___% | ___% |
| Summary Judgment | ___% | ___% |
| Trial | ___% | ___% |

**Overall Success**: ___%

---

### SETTLEMENT ANALYSIS

| Metric | Amount |
|---|---|
| Walk-Away Floor | $_______ |
| Target | $_______ |
| Maximum Demand | $_______ |

**Comparable Settlements**:
- [Case 1]: $_______ (___% of gross)
- [Case 2]: $_______ (___% of gross)

---

### COLLECTABILITY

**Defendant Condition**: [Assessment]
**Insurance**: $_______ [Known/Unknown]
**Discount**: ___%
**Net Collectible**: $_______

---

### RECOMMENDATION

[Analysis and recommendation]

**Key Assumptions**:
1. [Assumption 1]
2. [Assumption 2]

**Sensitivity**:
- If class ±20%: Range becomes $___ to $___
- If certification denied: Value drops to $_______

---

Common Valuation Pitfalls

Overvaluation Traps

• Assuming 100% participation
• Ignoring certification/trial risks
• Using gross damages as settlement anchor
• Overestimating punitive availability

Undervaluation Traps

• Discounting strong claims
• Ignoring reputational costs to defendant
• Missing statutory damages or fee-shifting
• Ignoring certification leverage