菜单
Orchestrate comprehensive quality assessment by executing 5 specialized quality skills in sequence and synthesizing results into a unified quality gate decision. This skill should be used when performing final review of completed implementation.
默认使用会先检查来源的 Prompt；你也可以切换为直接命令，或下载本地副本。
决定是否安装前，请先阅读 SKILL.md，以及 SkillsMP 当前展示的配套文件。
用 Codex 或 Claude 帮你安装 复制这段 Prompt，粘贴到 Codex、Claude 或其他助手里，让它检查 Skill 页面并帮你完成安装。
直接命令不会经过审查 Prompt；运行前请先检查来源。
npx skills add https://github.com/adolfoaranaes12/BMAD-ENHANCED --skill review-task命令会保持在同一行。复制前请横向滚动并检查完整内容。
想先保存到本地？可下载 SkillsMP 当前能够提供的文件。
Comprehensive brownfield architecture analysis for existing codebases. Discovers structure, identifies patterns, assesses quality, calculates production readiness, and provides actionable recommendations. Use when analyzing existing codebases to understand architecture, assess quality, or prepare for modernization.
Systematically consume QA quality gate outputs and apply prioritized fixes for high-severity issues, NFR failures, and test coverage gaps. Use when quality review identifies issues requiring remediation.
Peer review architecture for quality, risks, and optimization opportunities. Analyzes scalability bottlenecks, security vulnerabilities, performance optimization, technology fit, and provides prioritized recommendations. Use when reviewing proposed architecture documents for quality assurance, risk identification, or architectural decision validation.
基于 SOC 职业分类
正在显示 SKILL.md
| name | review-task |
| description | Orchestrate comprehensive quality assessment by executing 5 specialized quality skills in sequence and synthesizing results into a unified quality gate decision. This skill should be used when performing final review of completed implementation. |
| acceptance | [{"all_assessments_completed":"All 5 quality skills executed successfully (risk-profile, test-design, trace-requirements, nfr-assess, quality-gate)"},{"gate_decision_made":"Quality gate decision generated (PASS/CONCERNS/FAIL/WAIVED) with overall quality score"},{"reports_generated":"Assessment reports created in .claude/quality/ (assessments/*.md, gates/*.yaml, gates/*.md)"},{"task_updated":"Task file Quality Review section updated with summary and report links"}] |
| inputs | {"task_file":{"type":"string","required":true,"description":"Path to task file in .claude/tasks/{task-id}.md format"},"execution_mode":{"type":"enum","values":["full","individual","resume"],"default":"full","description":"Execution mode: full (all 5 skills), individual (selected skills), resume (continue partial review)"},"selected_skills":{"type":"array","required":false,"description":"For individual mode: which skills to execute (risk-profile, test-design, trace-requirements, nfr-assess, quality-gate)"}} |
| outputs | {"gate_decision":{"type":"object","description":"Quality gate decision with status, score, blockers, action items"},"assessment_reports":{"type":"object","description":"File paths to all generated assessment reports"},"review_summary":{"type":"string","description":"Human-readable summary of quality review results"}} |
| telemetry | {"emit":"skill.review-task.completed","track":["task_id","execution_mode","duration_ms","skills_executed","gate_decision","overall_score"]} |
Orchestrate comprehensive quality assessment by executing 5 specialized quality skills in sequence and synthesizing results into a unified quality gate decision.
This skill coordinates execution of 5 specialized quality skills to provide comprehensive quality assessment:
This skill should be used when: Comprehensive quality review of completed task (status "Review"), preparing for merge/deploy decision
Individual assessments: Invoke specific skills directly (risk-profile, test-design, trace-requirements, nfr-assess, quality-gate)
This skill should NOT be used when: Task in progress, reviewing drafts, quick spot checks
Quality Review Orchestration Flow:
Step 0: Configuration & Verification
↓
Step 1: risk-profile → .claude/quality/assessments/{task-id}-risk-{date}.md
↓
Step 2: test-design → .claude/quality/assessments/{task-id}-test-design-{date}.md
↓
Step 3: trace-requirements → .claude/quality/assessments/{task-id}-trace-{date}.md
↓
Step 4: nfr-assess → .claude/quality/assessments/{task-id}-nfr-{date}.md
↓
Step 5: quality-gate → .claude/quality/gates/{task-id}-gate-{date}.{yaml,md}
↓
Step 6: Update Task File
↓
Step 7: Present Summary
Each skill builds on previous results. Execution order is critical.
AUTHORIZED: Read task/implementation files, execute quality skills, generate reports, update task "Quality Review" section only
NOT AUTHORIZED: Modify task Objective/AC/Context/Tasks/Implementation, modify code, change status to "Done", bypass skills
Purpose: Load configuration, verify task readiness, determine execution mode.
Actions:
.claude/config.yamlHalt if: Config missing, task not ready, status not "Review"
See: references/execution-modes-guide.md for detailed flow and references/templates.md for configuration format
Purpose: Assess implementation risks using P×I (Probability × Impact) methodology.
Actions:
Invoke risk-profile.md skill:
Executing: .claude/skills/quality/risk-profile.md
Task: {task-id}
Skill executes 7-step risk assessment process:
Capture results: risk count, critical/high risks, mitigation coverage, report path
Error Handling: If skill fails, ask user to fix and re-run, or skip and continue (impacts gate confidence).
See: references/templates.md for output format and captured data structure
Purpose: Design comprehensive test strategy with P0/P1/P2 priorities and mock strategies.
Actions:
Invoke test-design.md skill:
Executing: .claude/skills/quality/test-design.md
Task: {task-id}
Risk Profile: {risk-file} (for risk-informed test prioritization)
Skill executes 7-step test design process:
Capture results: total tests, P0/P1/P2 counts, test levels, report path
See: references/templates.md for output format
Purpose: Map acceptance criteria → implementation → tests with gap analysis.
Actions:
Invoke trace-requirements.md skill:
Executing: .claude/skills/quality/trace-requirements.md
Task: {task-id}
Risk Profile: {risk-file}
Test Design: {test-file}
Skill executes 7-step traceability process:
Capture results: traceability score, implementation/test coverage, gaps, report path
Error Handling: Traceability is CRITICAL for quality gate. Must fix and re-run if fails.
See: references/templates.md for output format
Purpose: Assess non-functional requirements across 6 categories.
Actions:
Invoke nfr-assess.md skill:
Executing: .claude/skills/quality/nfr-assess.md
Task: {task-id}
Risk Profile: {risk-file}
Traceability: {trace-file}
Test Design: {test-file}
Skill executes 8-step NFR assessment:
Capture results: overall NFR score, category scores (security/performance/reliability/maintainability/scalability/usability), critical gaps, report path
See: references/templates.md for output format
Purpose: Synthesize all assessments and make final PASS/CONCERNS/FAIL/WAIVED decision.
Actions:
Invoke quality-gate.md skill:
Executing: .claude/skills/quality/quality-gate.md
Task: {task-id}
Risk Profile: {risk-file}
Test Design: {test-file}
Traceability: {trace-file}
NFR Assessment: {nfr-file}
Skill executes 8-step gate synthesis:
Capture results: gate decision (PASS/CONCERNS/FAIL/WAIVED), overall score, can proceed status, blockers, action items, report paths (YAML + MD)
Error Handling: Gate decision is CRITICAL. Must fix and re-run if fails.
See: references/templates.md for output format
Purpose: Update task file Quality Review section with synthesized summary.
Actions:
See: references/templates.md for task file update template
Purpose: Present comprehensive summary synthesizing all 5 skill results with gate decision, dimension scores, findings, action items, and next steps.
Actions:
See: references/templates.md for complete summary template and user decision handling
Quality review orchestration complete when:
references/execution-modes-guide.md - Execution flow for full/individual/resume modesreferences/error-handling-guide.md - Error scenarios, graceful degradation, fallback strategiesreferences/orchestration-guide.md - Skill coordination and sequencing detailsreferences/synthesis-summary-guide.md - Summary generation and presentationreferences/templates.md - Output templates, task file updates, user decision handling