error-handling-gate

name	error-handling-gate
description	Verifies error handling including empty catch detection, user-friendly messages, and logging. WARNING gate triggered during /own:done flow.

Gate 3: Error Handling Review

"Happy path code is easy. Error handling is where senior engineers shine."

Purpose

This gate ensures the code handles failures gracefully, provides meaningful feedback to users, and doesn't silently swallow errors.

Gate Status

• PASS — Error handling is appropriate
• WARNING — Issues found that should be addressed

---

Gate Questions

Question 1: Failure Scenario

"What happens if [main operation] fails? Walk me through the user experience."

Looking for:

• Awareness of failure modes
• User-friendly error messages
• Recovery options (retry, fallback)
• No silent failures

Example scenarios:

• Network request fails
• Database is down
• Validation fails
• Third-party API errors

Question 2: User Feedback

"What does the user see when an error occurs? Would they understand what to do next?"

Looking for:

• Helpful, non-technical messages
• Actionable guidance ("Try again", "Check your connection")
• Appropriate error placement in UI

Question 3: Error Visibility

"How would you debug this in production if something went wrong?"

Looking for:

• Errors are logged
• Sufficient context in logs
• No sensitive data in logs
• Error tracking awareness (Sentry, etc.)

---

Error Handling Checklist

Async Operations

• All async calls wrapped in try/catch or .catch()
• No empty catch blocks
• Errors include context (what operation, what data)
• finally blocks for cleanup (loading states, etc.)

User Experience

• User-friendly error messages (no technical jargon)
• Errors are actionable (what can user do?)
• Loading states cleared on error
• Retry options where appropriate

Logging & Debugging

• Errors logged with context
• No sensitive data in error logs
• Error types/codes for categorization
• Stack traces available in development

Edge Cases

• Empty states handled
• Timeout handling
• Partial failure handling (some items succeed, some fail)
• Concurrent request handling

---

Response Templates

If PASS

✅ ERROR HANDLING GATE: PASSED

Error handling looks solid:
- Async operations properly wrapped
- User-friendly error messages
- Errors logged for debugging

Moving to the next gate...

If WARNING

⚠️ ERROR HANDLING GATE: WARNING

Found [X] error handling concerns:

**Issue 1: [Empty catch block / Missing error handling]**
Location: `file.ts:42`
Question: "What happens when this fails silently?"

**Issue 2: [Technical error shown to user]**
Location: `file.ts:88`
Question: "Will users understand 'TypeError: Cannot read property...'?"

**Issue 3: [No loading state cleanup]**
Location: `file.ts:100`
Question: "What happens to the loading spinner if this fails?"

These should be addressed to ensure a good user experience.

---

Common Issues to Check

1. Empty Catch Blocks

❌ try {
     await submitForm();
   } catch (error) {
     // Silent failure - user has no idea
   }

✅ try {
     await submitForm();
   } catch (error) {
     console.error('Form submission failed:', error);
     setError('Could not submit. Please try again.');
   }

2. Missing Finally for Cleanup

❌ try {
     setLoading(true);
     await fetchData();
     setLoading(false);
   } catch (error) {
     handleError(error);
     // Loading stays true forever!
   }

✅ try {
     setLoading(true);
     await fetchData();
   } catch (error) {
     handleError(error);
   } finally {
     setLoading(false);
   }

3. Technical Errors Exposed

❌ catch (error) {
     setError(error.message);
     // User sees: "TypeError: Cannot read property 'map' of undefined"
   }

✅ catch (error) {
     console.error('Load failed:', error);
     setError('Something went wrong. Please try again.');
   }

4. No Error Differentiation

❌ catch (error) {
     setError('Error');
   }

✅ catch (error) {
     if (error.status === 401) {
       setError('Please log in to continue.');
       redirectToLogin();
     } else if (error.status === 404) {
       setError('Item not found.');
     } else if (error.name === 'NetworkError') {
       setError('Check your internet connection.');
     } else {
       setError('Something went wrong. Please try again.');
     }
   }

---

Socratic Error Questions

Instead of pointing out the fix, ask:

1. "What happens if the network is down when the user clicks this?"
2. "If this catch block runs, what will the user see?"
3. "How will you know this failed in production?"
4. "What if only some of the items fail to save?"
5. "Is the loading spinner stuck if an error happens?"

---

Error Message Quality Check

Bad Message	Better Message
"Error"	"Could not save. Please try again."
"An error occurred"	"Unable to load your profile. Check your connection."
"TypeError: undefined"	"Something went wrong. Please refresh and try again."
"500 Internal Server Error"	"Our servers are having trouble. Please try again in a moment."
"Failed"	"Could not complete your request. Need help? Contact support."

---

Severity Guide

Issue	Severity	Impact
Empty catch block	HIGH	Silent failures, hard to debug
No loading state cleanup	MEDIUM	Stuck UI, poor UX
Technical error shown	MEDIUM	Confusing UX, potential info leak
No retry option	LOW	Minor UX friction
Generic error message	LOW	Less helpful but not broken