respond-pr-feedback

name	respond-pr-feedback
description	Respond to review comments on a PR after evaluation and fixes
disable-model-invocation	true

Respond to PR Feedback

Post replies to review comments after you've evaluated the feedback and made fixes. Resolves conversation threads by default.

Usage

/beagle-core:respond-pr-feedback [--pr <number>] [--no-resolve]

Flags:

• --pr <number> - PR number to target (default: current branch's PR)
• --no-resolve - Skip thread resolution after posting replies (default: resolve all)

Prerequisites

Run /beagle-core:fetch-pr-feedback first to evaluate the feedback and make any necessary fixes.

Hard gates (sequenced)

Advance only after each pass condition is met (objective checks—not assumed completion).

1. Prerequisite satisfied: You have already run /beagle-core:fetch-pr-feedback, evaluated each thread, and applied fixes or chosen an explicit response strategy per thread (no posting blind).
2. Context loaded: Step 2 commands exit 0; values parsed from gh pr view, gh repo view, and gh api user are non-empty and assigned to $PR_NUMBER, $PR_AUTHOR, $OWNER, $REPO, $CURRENT_USER—never invent owner, repo, or PR number.
3. Queue decided: Step 3a jq exits 0. If the filtered list is empty, output exactly All review comments have been addressed. and stop (do not call reply or GraphQL resolve APIs).
4. Reply before resolve: For each target comment, Step 4 gh api .../replies exits 0 before Step 5 attempts resolution for that item (unless --no-resolve).
5. Resolve with mapping: Step 5 calls resolveReviewThread only when Step 3b provides a threadId for that comment’s id; if there is no mapping, skip resolution for that item without treating it as failure.

Instructions

1. Parse Arguments

Extract flags from $ARGUMENTS:

• --pr <number> or detect from current branch
• --no-resolve flag (boolean, default false)

2. Get PR Context

# Get PR info (if --pr not specified, uses current branch)
gh pr view --json number,author --jq '{number, author: .author.login}'

# Get repo owner/name
gh repo view --json owner,name --jq '{owner: .owner.login, name: .name}'

# Get current authenticated user
gh api user --jq '.login'

Store as $PR_NUMBER, $PR_AUTHOR, $OWNER, $REPO, $CURRENT_USER.

Note: $OWNER, $REPO, etc. are placeholders. Substitute actual values from previous steps.

3. Fetch Unreplied Comments and Thread Data

3a. Unreplied Review Comments

Fetch review comments, excluding PR author and current user, filtering to root comments that haven't been replied to.

Write the jq filter to a temp file using a heredoc with single-quoted delimiter (prevents shell escaping issues with !=, regex patterns, and angle brackets):

cat > /tmp/unreplied_comments.jq << 'JQEOF'
add // [] |
# Root comments from reviewers (not replies, not PR author, not current user)
[.[] | select(
  .in_reply_to_id == null and
  .user.login != $pr_author and
  .user.login != $current_user
)] as $roots |
# IDs that current user has already replied to
[.[] | select(.user.login == $current_user) | .in_reply_to_id] as $replied |
# Filter to unreplied only
$roots | map(select(. as $c | $replied | index($c.id) == null)) |
# Dedup: group by path + line + reviewer, pick newest per group
group_by({
  p: .path,
  l: (.line // .original_line),
  u: .user.login
}) |
map(sort_by(.created_at) | last) |
# Output needed fields
map({
  id,
  user: .user.login,
  path,
  line_display: (
    .line as $end | .start_line as $start |
    if $start and $start != $end then "\($start)-\($end)"
    else "\($end // .original_line)" end
  ),
  body
})
JQEOF

gh api --paginate "repos/$OWNER/$REPO/pulls/$PR_NUMBER/comments" | \
  jq -s --arg pr_author "$PR_AUTHOR" --arg current_user "$CURRENT_USER" \
  -f /tmp/unreplied_comments.jq

If no unreplied comments found, output: "All review comments have been addressed." and stop.

3b. Pre-fetch Thread Data

Fetch review thread IDs to enable resolution after posting replies:

gh api graphql -f query="
  query {
    repository(owner: \"$OWNER\", name: \"$REPO\") {
      pullRequest(number: $PR_NUMBER) {
        reviewThreads(first: 100) {
          nodes {
            id
            isResolved
            comments(first: 1) {
              nodes { databaseId }
            }
          }
        }
      }
    }
  }
"

Build a lookup map: comment databaseId → thread id (unresolved threads only). This enables immediate resolution after posting each reply.

4. Generate and Post Replies

For each unreplied comment, determine the appropriate response based on your evaluation:

Evaluation Outcome	Response
Feedback was incorrect/unfounded	Explain why the current code is correct
Feedback lacked context	Explain the design decision
Feedback was valid and fixed	"Fixed in $COMMIT_SHA" or brief description of change
Feedback was valid but won't fix	Explain the tradeoff/decision

Tagging guideline: @-tag bot reviewers (e.g., @coderabbitai) to trigger their processing. Do not @-tag human reviewers.

Post reply to each comment:

gh api "repos/$OWNER/$REPO/pulls/$PR_NUMBER/comments/$COMMENT_ID/replies" \
  -X POST --raw-field body="$RESPONSE"

5. Resolve Threads

This step runs by default. Skip only if --no-resolve was passed.

After posting each reply, look up the $THREAD_ID from the step 3b mapping using the comment's $COMMENT_ID:

gh api graphql -f query="
  mutation {
    resolveReviewThread(input: {threadId: \"$THREAD_ID\"}) {
      thread { isResolved }
    }
  }
"

• If a comment's $COMMENT_ID has a matching thread ID in the lookup, resolve it
• If no thread ID found (e.g., issue comment rather than review thread), skip resolution for that comment

6. Output Summary

Group by reviewer:

### Reviewer: coderabbitai[bot]

| File:Line | Response Type | Thread |
|-----------|---------------|--------|
| `src/foo.ts:42` | Fixed in `abc1234` | Resolved |
| `src/bar.ts:15` | Explained design | Resolved |

### Reviewer: octocat

| File:Line | Response Type | Thread |
|-----------|---------------|--------|
| `src/baz.ts:7` | Won't fix | Resolved |

Footer:

**Threads resolved: 3/3**

Response Guidelines

• @-tag bot reviewers to trigger re-processing; do not tag human reviewers
• Keep responses concise and technical
• No performative agreement ("Great point!", "You're right!")
• Reference specific code/design when explaining decisions
• If fixed: state what changed, no gratitude

Example

# Respond to all reviewers on current PR (resolves threads)
/beagle-core:respond-pr-feedback

# Respond on a specific PR
/beagle-core:respond-pr-feedback --pr 123

# Respond without resolving threads
/beagle-core:respond-pr-feedback --no-resolve