econ-paper-review-skill

Review economics papers, working papers, theses, and submissions with referee-grade rigor and exhaustive verified comments. Use when the user asks to evaluate, referee, audit, stress-test, pre-review, find all problems, or comprehensively review empirical, experimental, descriptive, forecasting, prediction/ML, historical, archival, qualitative, meta-analytic, structural, quantitative, macro, theoretical, or mixed economics work; assess identification, inference, logic, equations, evidence, novelty, clarity, or journal readiness; or produce a grounded referee report, separate editing comments, optional requested journal-fit analysis, findings ledger, and prioritized fix plan. Use econ-review to judge papers; use econ-write to draft or rewrite paper text after the judgment is settled.

Prepare, verify, repair, or refresh the user-owned Python runtime and local Review Desk used by an installed econ-review plugin. Use when the user installs econ-review from a marketplace, asks to finish setup, reports missing Python packages or Poppler, needs the Review Desk launcher, or wants to check installation readiness without creating duplicate Claude Code or Codex skill copies.

Review economics papers, working papers, theses, and submissions with referee-grade rigor and exhaustive verified comments. Use when the user asks to evaluate, referee, audit, stress-test, pre-review, find all problems, or comprehensively review empirical, experimental, descriptive, forecasting, prediction/ML, historical, archival, qualitative, meta-analytic, structural, quantitative, macro, theoretical, or mixed economics work; assess identification, inference, logic, equations, evidence, novelty, clarity, or journal readiness; or produce a grounded referee report, separate editing comments, optional requested journal-fit analysis, findings ledger, and prioritized fix plan. Use econ-review to judge papers; use econ-write to draft or rewrite paper text after the judgment is settled.