| name | paper-audit |
| version | 1.0.0 |
| category | academic-writing |
| tags | ["audit","review","paper","pdf","latex","typst","chinese","english","scoring","checklist"] |
| description | Unified paper audit skill supporting Chinese & English academic papers.
Supports LaTeX (.tex), Typst (.typ), and PDF (.pdf) input formats.
Three modes: self-check (pre-submission), review (peer review simulation),
gate (quality gate pass/fail).
Use when user mentions: audit, review, check paper, paper quality,
pre-submission check, score paper, or any paper auditing task.
|
| argument-hint | [paper.tex|paper.typ|paper.pdf] [--mode self-check|review|gate] [--pdf-mode basic|enhanced] |
| allowed-tools | Read, Glob, Grep, Bash(python *) |
| references | ["resources/references/REVIEW_CRITERIA.md","resources/references/CHECKLIST.md","resources/references/AUDIT_GUIDE.md"] |
| scripts | ["scripts/audit.py","scripts/pdf_parser.py","scripts/detect_language.py","scripts/report_generator.py","scripts/parsers.py"] |
Paper Audit Skill (论文审核)
Unified academic paper auditing across formats and languages.
Critical Rules
- NEVER modify
\cite{}, \ref{}, \label{}, math environments in LaTeX
- NEVER modify
@cite, #cite(), #ref(), <label> in Typst
- NEVER fabricate bibliography entries — only verify existing
.bib/.yml files
- NEVER change domain terminology without user confirmation
- Check
FORBIDDEN_TERMS lists before suggesting any terminology changes
- For PDF input, clearly flag sections where extraction quality is uncertain
- Always distinguish between automated findings and LLM-judgment scores
Audit Modes
Mode: self-check (Pre-submission Self-Check)
Trigger keywords: audit, check, self-check, pre-submission, score, review my paper
What it does: Runs all automated checks and generates a structured report with:
- Per-dimension scores (Quality, Clarity, Significance, Originality) on 1-6 scale
- Issue list sorted by severity (Critical > Major > Minor)
- Improvement suggestions per section
- Pre-submission checklist results
CLI: python scripts/audit.py paper.tex --mode self-check
Mode: review (Peer Review Simulation)
Trigger keywords: simulate review, peer review, reviewer perspective, what would reviewers say
What it does: Everything in self-check PLUS:
- Paper summary from reviewer perspective
- Strengths analysis
- Weaknesses analysis with severity
- Questions a reviewer would ask
- Accept/reject recommendation with confidence
CLI: python scripts/audit.py paper.tex --mode review
Mode: gate (Quality Gate)
Trigger keywords: quality gate, pass/fail, can I submit, ready to submit, advisor check
What it does: Fast mandatory checks only:
- Format validation
- Bibliography integrity
- Figure/table references
- Pre-submission checklist
