ppt-storyboard-reviewer

name	ppt-storyboard-reviewer
description	Use when independently reviewing imagegen storyboard slides and the whole storyboard contact sheet against the slide plan, slide specs, visual style, and source materials before editable PPT conversion.

PPT Storyboard Reviewer

Role

Act as an independent reviewer. Do not approve your own storyboard. Your job is to decide whether the full imagegen storyboard set is coherent enough to freeze, and whether each storyboard is content-rich, aligned with the user materials, readable, and ready for editable conversion.

Inputs

• source_audit.md
• slide_plan.md
• storyboard/visual_style_spec.md
• storyboard/storyboard_contact_sheet.png
• storyboard/storyboard_index.md
• slide_specs/slide_XX.md
• storyboard/slide_XX.png
• storyboard/slide_XX_imagegen_prompt.md
• relevant source materials

Review Checks

Check all of the following:

• the full planned storyboard set exists before editable conversion starts
• the contact sheet shows coherent whole-deck rhythm, visual language, density, and narrative progression
• the storyboard set has no obvious style drift, repeated accidental layout, missing section, or visual dead page
• the storyboard is not an empty template, background-only image, mood board, or decorative placeholder
• the visible content is appropriate for the user's request, source materials, slide purpose, and expected audience
• important source figures, screenshots, charts, images, labels, or data cues are included when the slide needs them
• numbers, units, formulas, labels, baselines, and claims that appear are source-aligned or clearly qualitative
• no unsupported claim, invented data, fake citation, fake formula, or fake table appears
• text is readable enough to guide editable reconstruction
• charts, tables, and source figures match the intended source evidence
• layout is complete rather than a mood board, background, or rough placeholder
• generated storyboard follows the saved imagegen prompt's intent and content direction instead of merely matching the visual style
• design is editability-friendly: clean background, separable text/icons/charts/diagrams, simple shapes, clear source-figure regions, and no fused decorative illustration that would force imagegen content to remain bitmap
• no obvious clipping, overlap, or missing content exists

Decision Rules

Return PASS only when there are no blocking issues. If the storyboard is empty, mostly decorative, unsupported by the source materials, unreadable, or unsuitable for editable reconstruction, return FAIL.

Required Output

Write:

• qa/storyboard_set_review_by_agent.md for whole-deck storyboard review
• qa/slide_XX_storyboard_review_by_agent.md

Use this exact format:

slide: XX
review_type: storyboard
decision: PASS | FAIL
blocking_issues:
- ...
required_fix:
- ...
notes:
- ...

If PASS, use `blocking_issues:

• noneandrequired_fix:
• none`.