tsp-type-override

name	tsp-type-override
description	Override TypeSpec types with Java-native types (e.g. OffsetDateTime, DayOfWeek) using @@alternateType in a client.java.tsp file. Use when a TypeSpec model field has an incorrect or too-generic type that should map to a specific Java type.

TypeSpec Type Override for Java

Override types in generated Java code by adding @@alternateType decorators to the client.java.tsp file.

Preconditions

• You must be in the directory that contains tsp-location.yaml.
• The TypeSpec must already be synced locally into TempTypeSpecFiles/. If not, run tsp-client sync first.
• Identify the client.java.tsp file inside TempTypeSpecFiles/. This is the only file you should edit.

Important: TempTypeSpecFiles is volatile

TempTypeSpecFiles/ is a transient working directory managed by tsp-client. It is regenerated on every tsp-client sync or tsp-client update and is typically gitignored. Any changes made only in TempTypeSpecFiles/ will be lost on the next sync/update cycle.

If the user provides a local checkout of Azure/azure-rest-api-specs, always apply the same client.java.tsp edits there so the changes are preserved and can be committed to a PR. The path to the spec file inside that repo can be derived from tsp-location.yaml:

• directory field gives the relative path (e.g. specification/ai-foundry/data-plane/Foundry)
• The file to edit is client.java.tsp inside that directory

Workflow

1. Locate the TypeSpec model and field

Search the .tsp files under TempTypeSpecFiles/ for the model and field the user wants to override:

grep -rn "<ModelName>\|<fieldName>" TempTypeSpecFiles/ --include="*.tsp"

Read the model definition to confirm the current type of the target field (e.g. string, int32, a union, etc.).

2. Determine the correct decorator form

There are two forms of @@alternateType. Choose based on the target type:

Form A — TypeSpec built-in type (preferred when possible)

Use when there is a TypeSpec scalar that the Java emitter already maps to the desired Java type.

Desired Java type	TypeSpec alternate
OffsetDateTime	utcDateTime
Duration	duration
byte[]	bytes
long / Long	int64
double / Double	float64

Syntax (applied to a model property, scoped to Java):

@@alternateType(ModelName.fieldName, utcDateTime, "java");

This form is fully supported on model properties.

Form B — External Java type via identity (on a type definition)

Use when no TypeSpec scalar maps to the desired Java type (e.g. java.time.DayOfWeek), or when you want to prevent emission of a model entirely by mapping it to an existing external class (e.g. an openai-java type).

Syntax (applied to the type definition itself, not a property):

@@alternateType(TypeName, { identity: "fully.qualified.ClassName" }, "java");

Important constraints for external types:

• External types ({ identity: ... }) cannot be applied to model properties — they must target the type definition (Model, Enum, Union, Scalar).
• A scope parameter (e.g. "java") is required for external types.
• Known limitation (as of typespec-java 0.39.x): The Java emitter does not fully support external types on Enum/Union definitions. It will still generate the class instead of referencing the JDK type. This is tracked as a bug. Only use Form B for Model types until the emitter is fixed.

De-duplication use case: Form B can suppress emission of generated models that duplicate an external dependency. For example, @@alternateType(OpenAI.Reasoning, { identity: "com.openai.models.Reasoning" }, "java") prevents the codegen from emitting its own Reasoning class — any property typed as OpenAI.Reasoning will use com.openai.models.Reasoning directly. This works for Model types that are members of unions too (e.g. ComparisonFilter inside a Filters union). See the dedup-openai skill for the full workflow including serialization fixes.

Form C — External Java type on a single property (model indirection)

Use when you need to override a single property to an external Java type, but Form B cannot be used because it would change the type globally, and { identity: ... } cannot be applied directly to properties.

The workaround is a two-step indirection: define a dummy model annotated with the external identity, then use @@alternateType on the property pointing to that model.

// Step 1: Define a dummy model with the external Java type identity
@alternateType({ identity: "java.util.TimeZone" }, "java")
model TimeZoneType {}

// Step 2: Override the property type to use the dummy model
@@alternateType(OpenAI.ApproximateLocation.timezone, TimeZoneType, "java");

Why this works: @alternateType({identity: ...}) is supported on Model definitions (Form B). The @@alternateType on a property accepts any TypeSpec type as the alternate (Form A). By combining both, the property override resolves through the model to the external Java class.

What does NOT work (and why this form exists):

• { identity: ... } directly on a property → compiler error / silently ignored.
• @alternateType({identity: ...}) on a scalar → the Java emitter ignores the identity and falls back to BinaryData (as of typespec-java 0.40.x).
• @alternateType({identity: ...}) on a scalar extends string → the emitter ignores the identity entirely and uses String.

Important: The Java emitter generates writeJsonField / TypeName.fromJson(reader) calls for the overridden property, which will not compile because the external Java type (e.g. java.util.TimeZone) does not implement JsonSerializable. You must fix toJson/fromJson manually — see step 5 below.

3. Apply the override

Edit the client.java.tsp file inside TempTypeSpecFiles/. Add the decorator(s) under the type-replacement section (usually at the bottom of the file):

// EvaluatorVersion datetime fields are typed as string in the spec
@@alternateType(EvaluatorVersion.created_at, utcDateTime, "java");

4. Generate and verify

Always generate with --save-inputs so the edited TypeSpec files are preserved:

tsp-client generate --save-inputs

After generation, verify the Java source uses the expected type:

grep -n "OffsetDateTime\|DayOfWeek\|<ExpectedType>" src/main/java/com/azure/ai/projects/models/<ModelName>.java

Check that:

• The field type changed (e.g. private OffsetDateTime createdAt;)
• The getter return type changed (e.g. public OffsetDateTime getCreatedAt())
• The JSON deserialization uses the correct parser (e.g. CoreUtils.parseBestOffsetDateTime)
• No spurious files were generated (e.g. under src/main/java/java/)

5. Write unit tests for serialization/deserialization

After generation, always write a unit test that verifies the generated model serializes and deserializes the overridden type to the same wire-format values defined in the original TypeSpec. This is critical because the emitter may generate serialization code that does not match the API wire format (e.g. java.time.DayOfWeek.name() produces "MONDAY" but the TypeSpec union defined "Monday").

Place the test class under src/test/java/ in the model's package (e.g. com.azure.ai.projects.models).

The test must cover three scenarios:

1. Serialization — Construct the model with the Java type, serialize to JSON, and assert the JSON string values match the TSP-defined wire format (e.g. PascalCase "Monday", not UPPER_CASE "MONDAY").
2. Deserialization — Parse a JSON string using the TSP-defined wire-format values and assert the Java type is correctly populated.
3. Round-trip — Serialize → deserialize and assert the original values are preserved.

Example test skeleton:

@Test
void serializationProducesWireFormatValues() throws IOException {
    // Build model with the Java type
    var schedule = new WeeklyRecurrenceSchedule(Arrays.asList(DayOfWeek.MONDAY, DayOfWeek.FRIDAY));
    String json = toJsonString(schedule);
    // Assert the wire values match the TSP union/enum values, NOT the Java enum constant names
    String expected = "{\"daysOfWeek\":[\"Monday\",\"Friday\"],\"type\":\"Weekly\"}";
    assertEquals(expected, json);
}

@Test
void deserializationParsesWireFormatValues() throws IOException {
    // Use TSP-defined wire-format values
    String json = "{\"daysOfWeek\":[\"Monday\",\"Wednesday\"],\"type\":\"Weekly\"}";
    WeeklyRecurrenceSchedule schedule;
    try (JsonReader reader = JsonProviders.createReader(json)) {
        schedule = WeeklyRecurrenceSchedule.fromJson(reader);
    }
    assertEquals(Arrays.asList(DayOfWeek.MONDAY, DayOfWeek.WEDNESDAY), schedule.getDaysOfWeek());
}

@Test
void roundTripPreservesValues() throws IOException {
    var original = new WeeklyRecurrenceSchedule(Arrays.asList(DayOfWeek.SUNDAY, DayOfWeek.SATURDAY));
       toJsonString(original);
    WeeklyRecurrenceSchedule deserialized;
     (   JsonProviders.createReader(json)) {
        deserialized = WeeklyRecurrenceSchedule.fromJson(reader);
    }
    assertEquals(original.getDaysOfWeek(), deserialized.getDaysOfWeek());
}

If the tests fail: customize toJson/fromJson

When the emitter generates incorrect serialization (e.g. element.name() instead of PascalCase), you must manually fix the toJson and fromJson methods in the generated model class:

1. Remove the @Generated annotation from toJson and fromJson. This ensures your customizations survive future tsp-client generate / tsp-client update runs — the codegen will not overwrite methods that lack @Generated.
2. Place any marker comments inside the method body, not above the signature. The codegen rewrites everything above the method signature (including javadoc and comments) even for non-@Generated methods. Javadoc you write above a non-@Generated method will survive, but standalone comments above the signature will be wiped. Place markers like // AI Tooling: ... on the first line inside the method body. For fields, place marker comments on the same line (trailing), not on the line above.
3. Fix the serialization logic to convert between the Java type and the TSP wire format. For example, for java.time.DayOfWeek:
   • toJson: convert DayOfWeek.MONDAY → "Monday" (PascalCase) using a helper like:

     private static String toPascalCase(DayOfWeek day) {
         String name = day.name();
         return name.charAt(0) + name.substring(1).toLowerCase(Locale.ROOT);
     }
     

   • fromJson: convert "Monday" → DayOfWeek.MONDAY by uppercasing before valueOf():

     DayOfWeek.valueOf(reader.getString().toUpperCase(Locale.ROOT))
     

4. Re-run the unit tests and confirm all three scenarios pass.

Form C serialization fixes: When using the model indirection (Form C), the emitter generates writeJsonField("field", this.field) and ExternalType.fromJson(reader) — both will fail to compile because the external Java type does not implement JsonSerializable. Fix by:

• toJson: replace writeJsonField with the correct writer method (e.g. writeStringField("timezone", this.timezone != null ? this.timezone.getID() : null))
• fromJson: replace ExternalType.fromJson(reader) with the correct factory (e.g. TimeZone.getTimeZone(reader.getString()))

6. Apply changes to the local spec repo (if provided)

If the user supplied a local checkout path for Azure/azure-rest-api-specs, apply the same edits to the client.java.tsp there. Derive the file path from tsp-location.yaml:

<local_spec_repo>/<directory>/client.java.tsp

For example, if directory: specification/ai-foundry/data-plane/Foundry and the local repo is at ~/code/azure-rest-api-specs:

~/code/azure-rest-api-specs/specification/ai-foundry/data-plane/Foundry/client.java.tsp

Verify the file exists before editing. If it doesn't, warn the user and print the expected path.

7. Remind the user about the spec PR

After confirming the generated code is correct, remind the user:

The @@alternateType changes in client.java.tsp are local overrides in TempTypeSpecFiles/. For these to persist across future code generations, the same changes must be contributed to the Azure/azure-rest-api-specs repository via a pull request targeting the corresponding client.java.tsp file under the specification/ directory.

Build the PR URL from tsp-location.yaml:

• Repo: repo field (e.g. Azure/azure-rest-api-specs)
• Directory: directory field (e.g. specification/ai-foundry/data-plane/Foundry)
• File: client.java.tsp in that directory

Troubleshooting

Symptom	Cause	Fix
Generated class still uses String	Decorator not picked up	Verify the model/field names match exactly (case-sensitive, use the TypeSpec name, not the Java name)
File generated under src/main/java/java/time/...	External type identity used on an Enum/Union	Remove the decorator — this is the known emitter bug for Enum/Union external types
Compiler error on @@alternateType	Wrong target kind	External types must target type definitions, not properties. TypeSpec built-ins can target properties.
Warning: external-type-on-model-property	External type { identity: ... } applied to a property	Move the decorator to the type definition instead
Property becomes BinaryData instead of external type	@alternateType({identity: ...}) used on a scalar	Scalars don't support external identity resolution. Use Form C (model indirection) instead.
writeJsonField / fromJson compile errors after Form C	Emitter treats external type as JsonSerializable	Remove @Generated from toJson/fromJson and fix serialization manually (see step 5).