qrx-questionroute-extract

name	qrx - QuestionRoute Extract
description	Extract structured QuestionRoute data (questions, routes, chains, regresses) from unstructured prose, skills, or markdown files. Prototype for structured skill output.
output	{"format":"json","writes_files":true,"schema":{"questions":"QuestionRoute Question[]","routes":"QuestionRoute RouteFile[]","chains":"QuestionRoute QuestionChain[]","regresses":"QuestionRoute Regress[]"}}

QuestionRoute Extract

Input: $ARGUMENTS

The input should be a file path, a block of text, or a skill name to extract from.

---

Output Schema

This skill produces structured JSON files, not prose. Every output must conform to these types exactly.

Question

{
  "id": "string (kebab-case, unique)",
  "text": "string (the question ending in ?)",
  "definition": "string (one sentence: what this question searches for)",
  "semanticType": "string (causation | location | temporal | identity | method | evaluation | quantity | relation | condition | existence | obligation | preference | possibility | comparison)",
  "abstractionLevel": "number (1=very specific, 2=specific, 3=moderate, 4=general, 5=universal)",
  "slots": "string[] (what this question accepts as input)",
  "tags": "string[] (topical labels)"
}

Route

{
  "sourceId": "string (question ID this routes FROM)",
  "routes": [
    {
      "targetId": "string (question ID this routes TO)",
      "type": "prerequisite | implication | clarification | expansion | opposition | composition | analogy | causal",
      "reason": "string (one sentence: why this route exists)",
      "weight": "high | medium | low"
    }
  ]
}

Chain

{
  "id": "string (kebab-case)",
  "links": ["string (question IDs or 'chain:chainId' references)"],
  "composedText": "string (the compound question formed by composing the links)",
  "compositionType": "conjunction | embedding | conditional | sequential | telescoping",
  "depth": "number (0=all atomic, 1+=contains chains)",
  "tags": "string[]"
}

Regress

{
  "id": "string (kebab-case)",
  "questionRef": "string (question ID or 'chain:chainId')",
  "predictions": [
    {
      "id": "string",
      "text": "string (the predicted answer)",
      "truthStatus": "guess",
      "testedBy": [],
      "followUps": ["string (question IDs spawned by this answer)"],
      "reasoning": ""
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [],
  "depth": "number",
  "tags": "string[]"
}

---

Process

Step 1: Read the source

If the input is a file path, read the file. If it's a skill name (like /rca), read claude-code-plugin/skills/{name}/SKILL.md. If it's raw text, use it directly.

Step 2: Extract raw questions

Find every sentence or phrase that functions as a question — ending in ? or structured as an interrogative.

Filter OUT:

• Rhetorical questions that are really statements ("Isn't that obvious?")
• Meta-questions about the skill itself ("What depth should I use?")
• Example questions used as illustrations (unless they're genuinely useful as search directions)

Filter IN:

• Questions that define a search direction ("What is X?", "Why does Y?")
• Questions that could be asked of any subject ("Is it true?", "What stops you?")
• Questions embedded in procedures that guide thinking

Step 3: Reduce to atomic form

For each extracted question, determine if it's atomic or compound.

Atomic: A single search direction. One question word, one focus.

• "Why?" → atomic
• "What stops you?" → atomic (What + constraint)
• "Is it true?" → atomic

Compound: Multiple search directions fused together.

• "What would you do if you weren't trying to improve?" → What + Do + If + Improve (chain candidate)
• "Is the seeking optimizing for feeling or for results?" → compound with comparison

For compound questions:

1. Decompose into atomic questions
2. Create the atomic questions as individual entries
3. Create a chain that composes them back into the compound form

Step 4: Deduplicate and normalize

• Merge questions that are the same search direction with different wording
• Prefer the shorter, more general form
• Check against existing QuestionRoute data to avoid duplicating questions that already exist
• Use existing question IDs where a match exists

Step 5: Assign structure

For each surviving atomic question:

• id: kebab-case, descriptive, unique. Check existing IDs in the target data directory.
• text: The question in its cleanest form, ending in ?
• definition: One sentence describing what this question searches for. Do NOT use flowery language like "The fundamental question of..." — just say what it does.
• semanticType: Classify based on what kind of answer the question seeks
• abstractionLevel: 1-5 based on how general vs specific
• slots: What the question accepts (e.g., "Why?" has slot for "subject")
• tags: Topical labels relevant to the question's domain

Step 6: Infer routes

Look at how questions relate to each other in the source material:

• Questions that appear in sequence → potential route (check if the connection is logical)
• Questions where one is a prerequisite for another → prerequisite route
• Questions where one challenges another → opposition route
• Questions where one expands another → expansion route
• Questions where one causes another to be asked → causal or implication route

Each route needs a reason — one sentence explaining WHY this connection exists. Not a label, a reason.

Step 7: Build chains

For compound questions identified in Step 3:

• Create a chain linking the atomic components
• Determine composition type:
  • conjunction: A AND B ("Why and how?")
  • embedding: A contains B ("Why do you want?")
  • conditional: IF A THEN B ("If you want, should you?")
  • sequential: A THEN B ("First why, then how")
  • telescoping: A narrows into B ("Where specifically here?")

Step 8: Build regresses (if applicable)

If the source contains predicted answers or answer→follow-up patterns:

• Create regress entries
• All predictions start as truthStatus: "guess" with empty testedBy
• Follow-ups should reference question IDs (create new questions if needed)
• outputs always starts empty — outputs are discovered, not pre-filled

Step 9: Write files

Write each question, route file, chain, and regress to the target QuestionRoute data directory.

Default target: The QuestionRoute project data directory. If $ARGUMENTS includes a target path, use that.

File naming:

• Questions: data/questions/{id}.json
• Routes: data/routes/{sourceId}.json (append to existing if file exists)
• Chains: data/chains/{id}.json
• Regresses: data/regress/{id}.json

Step 10: Report

After writing files, output a summary:

EXTRACTED FROM: [source file/text]

QUESTIONS: [count] new, [count] matched existing
  [list of new question IDs with text]

ROUTES: [count] new connections
  [list of sourceId → targetId with type]

CHAINS: [count] new
  [list of chain IDs with composedText]

REGRESSES: [count] new
  [list of regress IDs with questionRef]

FILES WRITTEN:
  [list of file paths]

---

Judgment Guidelines

These are the hard calls. When in doubt:

Judgment	Default
Is this really a question or just rhetoric?	If it defines a search direction, it's a question
Atomic or compound?	If it has one question word and one focus, atomic
What abstraction level?	Compare to existing questions: Why?=4, Where should I eat?=1
Does this route exist?	Only if you can state WHY in one sentence
What composition type?	Read the compound question aloud — how do the parts fuse?
Should this be a regress?	Only if the source explicitly predicts answers
Does this duplicate an existing question?	Check text AND semantic type, not just text

---

Depth Scaling

Depth	Min Questions	Min Routes	Min Chains	Min Regresses
1x	5	3	0	0
2x	10	8	1	0
4x	20	15	3	1
8x	40	30	6	2

Default: 2x. Parse depth from $ARGUMENTS if specified.

---

Pre-Completion Checklist

• Every extracted question has all 7 fields populated
• No question uses flowery/explainer definitions
• All IDs are kebab-case and unique
• Routes have one-sentence reasons (not labels)
• Chains correctly decompose compound questions
• All regress predictions have truthStatus "guess" and empty testedBy
• No duplicate questions (checked against existing data)
• Files written to correct paths
• Summary report produced

---

Integration

• This is the first skill with output.format: json and output.writes_files: true
• Future skills can adopt the same frontmatter pattern to declare structured output
• Use from: any project that needs to extract QuestionRoute data from text
• Pairs with: /extract (finds skills), /sf (saves prose output)