skill-authoring

name	skill-authoring
license	Apache-2.0
description	Author, audit, and improve Grafana SKILL.md files against Anthropic's published Agent Skills guidance and the four-dimension rubric the grafana/skills CI gate uses (conciseness, actionability, workflow clarity, progressive disclosure). Applies the canonical SKILL.md structure (YAML frontmatter + body + references/ + scripts/ + assets/), the "pushy description" trigger pattern, the three-level progressive-disclosure model, and the validate-fix-rerun feedback loop. Use when creating a new skill in this repo, when reviewing a skill PR, when a skill's Tessl review score is below 75 (the merge gate), when a skill's description isn't getting picked up by agents, when restructuring a long SKILL.md into a bundle, or when the user asks how to write, improve, optimize, audit, or fix a skill - even if they don't say "skill" explicitly (e.g. "this isn't triggering", "Tessl scored this 72", "split this doc").

Authoring & Improving Grafana Skills

How to write, review, and improve SKILL.md files so they pass the repo's CI gate and score well against the Anthropic-aligned rubric Tessl uses.

Critical rules (always)

1. Description is the primary trigger — third-person, ≤1024 chars, must include explicit "Use when..." phrasing AND list concrete trigger terms users naturally say. See references/descriptions.md for the pushy-description pattern that combats undertriggering.
2. Body under 500 lines — split into references/*.md if approaching the limit. SKILL.md is the routing layer, not the entire knowledge base.
3. One level of nesting for references — link from SKILL.md directly, never SKILL.md → a.md → b.md. Claude may use head -100 previews on nested chains and miss content.
4. Imperative voice — "Run X" not "You should run X" not "It is important to run X". Explain why over heavy-handed MUST markers.
5. Concrete examples beat prose — copy-paste-ready commands, real config snippets. Tessl's actionability dimension scores this directly.
6. No reserved words in name — anthropic and claude are forbidden in skill names.
7. No time-sensitive language in the body — "after August 2025…" rots. Use an <details> "Old patterns" section for legacy info instead.
8. Validate before committing — ./scripts/lint-skills.sh skills/<plugin>/<your-skill> clean + Tessl score ≥75 (run tessl skill review --json <dir>).

The rubric

CI fails any PR where a touched SKILL.md scores below 75 on four 0-3 dimensions: conciseness, actionability, workflow clarity, progressive disclosure. Full per-dimension scoring + Anthropic-doc mapping in references/rubric.md.

Score variance

The judge is an LLM and swings 7-10 points run-to-run. Local 94 commonly lands at CI 85. Ship only on three consecutive local 100s.

Decision tree for a new skill

1. What product / domain does this skill belong to? Pick the right plugin folder: grafana-core/, grafana-cloud/, grafana-lgtm/, grafana-app-sdk/, grafana-k6/, grafana-plugins/. If none fits cleanly, ask the user before creating a new plugin group (a new group requires updating three marketplace.json files).

2. Estimate body length.

   • <200 lines of substance → single SKILL.md, no bundle
   • 200-500 lines → SKILL.md + references/<topic>.md for the long-form material

   • 500 lines → mandatory bundle split; see references/anatomy.md § Splitting strategies

3. Write a "pushy" description first. The description is the only thing always loaded into context. If agents don't trigger the skill, nothing else matters. See references/descriptions.md for the pattern.

4. Draft body with the four-dimension rubric in mind.

   • Cut every sentence Claude already knows (Conciseness)
   • Replace prose explanations with code blocks (Actionability)
   • Number every multi-step procedure + add a validation step at the end (Workflow clarity)
   • If you reach for <details>, consider whether that content belongs in references/ instead (Progressive disclosure)

5. Register in marketplace manifests. Add the skill path to the skills array in all three:

   • .claude-plugin/marketplace.json
   • .cursor-plugin/marketplace.json
   • .agents-plugin/marketplace.json

6. Validate locally.

   # 1. Lint clean (0 errors)
   ./scripts/lint-skills.sh skills/<plugin>/<your-skill>
   
   # 2. Tessl reviewScore ≥75 (the CI gate)
   tessl skill review --json skills/<plugin>/<your-skill> | jq '.review.reviewScore'
   
   # 3. If below 75 or you want ≥85: run --optimize (requires auth)
   tessl skill review --optimize -- --max-iterations 3 skills/<plugin>/<your-skill>
   

Fixing a low-scoring existing skill

1. Read the judge's verbatim Suggestions text (non-JSON output):

   tessl skill review skills/<plugin>/<name>
   

   The Suggestions: block under each dimension names the exact sentences/sections to cut. Copy the suggestion — don't guess. Then verify the lowest dimension matches your read.

2. Apply the fix pattern from references/rubric.md:

   • Conciseness 1-2 → cut intros, definitions, multi-line tables that mostly point to refs
   • Actionability 1-2 → replace prose with code blocks and CLI commands
   • Workflow clarity 1-2 → add numbered steps + validation checkpoints
   • Progressive disclosure 1-2 → split into references/*.md

3. If the skill is intentionally a routing document (like grafana-k6/k6-docs), don't let --optimize inline the bundle back into SKILL.md. Hand-craft a minimal copy-paste "validation loop" inline so SKILL.md is independently actionable, while preserving the bundle.

4. Re-score five times locally. Don't stop until all five runs hit 100 — see "Score variance" above for why.

Anti-patterns

See references/anti-patterns.md.

References

• references/descriptions.md — the pushy-description pattern + trigger-term checklist
• references/rubric.md — per-dimension scoring with Anthropic-doc citations and concrete fix patterns
• references/anatomy.md — three-level progressive disclosure, bundle layout, splitting strategies
• references/anti-patterns.md — what NOT to do, with examples
• Anthropic — Agent Skills best practices
• anthropics/skills — skill-creator SKILL.md
• The Complete Guide to Building Skills for Claude (PDF)