compiler-and-fourslash-tests

name	compiler-and-fourslash-tests
description	How to write, run, and debug compiler tests and fourslash (LSP) tests in the typescript-go repository. Covers test file formats, directives, markers, baseline management, and the fourslash verification API.

Writing, Running, and Debugging Compiler Tests and Fourslash Tests

This guide covers the complete testing workflow for the typescript-go repository, including compiler tests (type-checking, emit, diagnostics) and fourslash tests (language server features like completions, hover, go-to-definition).

1. Compiler Tests

Compiler tests validate the TypeScript compiler's behavior: diagnostics, JavaScript emit, source maps, type/symbol baselines, and more. Each test is a .ts or .tsx file that the test runner compiles, then compares output against stored baselines.

1.1 Where Test Files Live

Path	Purpose
testdata/tests/cases/compiler/	Regression tests (local to this repo)
testdata/tests/cases/conformance/	Conformance tests (local to this repo)
_submodules/TypeScript/tests/cases/compiler/	Submodule tests from upstream TypeScript
_submodules/TypeScript/tests/cases/conformance/	Submodule conformance tests from upstream

1.2 Writing a New Compiler Test

A compiler test is just a .ts or .tsx file — no Go code needed. Place it in testdata/tests/cases/compiler/ for regression tests or testdata/tests/cases/conformance/<subdir>/ for conformance tests.

Simple single-file test

// testdata/tests/cases/compiler/myNewTest.ts
const x: number = "hello"; // expect type error

Using compiler option directives

Set compiler options with // @option: value comment directives at the top of the file:

// @target: es2020
// @strict: true
// @declaration: true
// @jsx: react
// @noEmit: true
const x: number = 42;

Multi-file test

Use // @filename: directives to define multiple files in one test:

// @target: es2015
// @module: commonjs

// @filename: /src/utils.ts
export function greet(name: string): string {
    return `Hello, ${name}`;
}

// @filename: /src/main.ts
import { greet } from "./utils";
const msg: number = greet("world"); // type error

Generating test variations

Options can specify multiple comma-separated values to generate separate sub-test configurations:

// @target: es2015, esnext
// @module: commonjs, esnext
// @strict: true, false
export const x = 1;

This generates a sub-test for each combination, with names like myTest.ts (target=es2015,module=commonjs,strict=true).

Note: // @lib: is not variant — commas add additional lib files rather than creating separate test configurations:

// @lib: es2020,dom

Symlink tests

Use // @symlink: to create symlinks in the virtual filesystem:

// @symlink: /src -> /node_modules/mylib

Other directives

• // @currentDirectory: /custom/path — Set the working directory
• // @noImplicitReferences — Don't auto-include referenced files

1.3 Running Compiler Tests

Via hereby (recommended)

Always use npx hereby test to run tests. It ensures a clean state by clearing stale baselines before running, so results are always trustworthy. Trust the results — if hereby test passes, the tests pass.

It's generally best to run all tests — the full suite is very quick and will find issues you didn't realize you were introducing:

npx hereby test    # Run ALL tests — recommended, fast, and catches unexpected breakage

If a test fails, the output will include the full test name and package, which you can use to re-run it directly with go test for debugging (see below).

Via Go directly (for print-debugging a single test)

Use go test directly only when you need verbose output for a specific test to debug with print statements. The test output from hereby test will tell you the exact package and test name to use:

go test ./internal/testrunner/ -run 'TestLocal/myNewTest' -v

The test entry points are:

• TestLocal — runs tests from testdata/tests/cases/ (both compiler/ and conformance/)
• TestSubmodule — runs tests from _submodules/TypeScript/tests/cases/ and generates diff baselines

What happens during a test run

For each test file, the runner:

1. Parses directives (// @option:, // @filename:, etc.)
2. Generates configurations for each option variation
3. For each configuration, runs these parallel sub-tests:
   • error — Verifies diagnostics against .errors.txt baseline
   • output — Verifies JavaScript emit against .js baseline
   • sourcemap — Verifies source map output
   • sourcemap record — Verifies source map record
   • union ordering — Validates AST union type ordering
   • source file parent pointers — Validates AST structure integrity

1.4 Baseline System

Baselines are the expected output files that test results are compared against.

Directory	Purpose
testdata/baselines/reference/	Golden/expected baselines (committed to repo)
testdata/baselines/local/	Generated during test runs (not committed)

Baseline file types

Extension	Content
.errors.txt	Diagnostic error messages
.js	Emitted JavaScript
.d.ts	Declaration output
.symbols	Symbol information
.types	Type information
.sourcemap.txt	Source map output
.trace.json	Trace output

Viewing baseline diffs

git diff --diff-filter=AM --no-index ./testdata/baselines/reference ./testdata/baselines/local

Accepting baselines

Important: Only accept baselines immediately after a successful npx hereby test run. The hereby test command clears stale baselines before running, so accepting after it guarantees you're only accepting baselines from the current test run. If you accept without running hereby test first, you risk accepting old/stale baselines from previous runs.

npx hereby test              # MUST run this first — clears stale state
npx hereby baseline-accept   # Then accept the baselines

The baseline-accept task:

1. Copies all files from local/ to reference/ (excluding .delete files)
2. Deletes reference files that have corresponding .delete markers in local/

---

2. Fourslash Tests

Fourslash tests validate language server (LSP) features: completions, hover/quick info, go-to-definition, find references, rename, code fixes, formatting, and more. They're Go test files that set up TypeScript source with position markers, then verify LSP responses.

2.1 Where Test Files Live

Path	Purpose
internal/fourslash/tests/*.go	Hand-written fourslash tests
internal/fourslash/tests/gen/*.go	Auto-generated from upstream TypeScript fourslash tests
internal/fourslash/tests/manual/*.go	gen tests migrated to manual with npm run makemanual
internal/fourslash/	Test harness and utilities
internal/fourslash/tests/util/	Shared test constants (DefaultCommitCharacters, etc.)

Key difference: Generated tests in gen/ use fourslash.SkipIfFailing(t) for tests that are known to not yet work. Hand-written tests should always pass. Tests in manual/ are generated tests that have been migrated and possibly modified — they should not be created from scratch.

2.2 Writing a New Fourslash Test

Create a Go test file in internal/fourslash/tests/. The file uses the fourslash_test package.

Minimal template

package fourslash_test

import (
    "testing"

    "github.com/microsoft/typescript-go/internal/fourslash"
    "github.com/microsoft/typescript-go/internal/testutil"
)

func TestMyFeature(t *testing.T) {
    t.Parallel()
    defer testutil.RecoverAndFail(t, "Panic on fourslash test")
    const content = `
var x/*marker1*/ = 42;
`
    f, done := fourslash.NewFourslash(t, nil /*capabilities*/, content)
    defer done()
    f.VerifyQuickInfoAt(t, "marker1", "var x: number", "")
}

Real-world example: Quick Info

func TestBasicQuickInfo(t *testing.T) {
    t.Parallel()
    defer testutil.RecoverAndFail(t, "Panic on fourslash test")
    const content = `
/**
 * Some var
 */
var someVar/*1*/ = 123;

/**
 * Other var
 * See {@link someVar}
 */
var otherVar/*2*/ = someVar;
`
    f, done := fourslash.NewFourslash(t, nil /*capabilities*/, content)
    defer done()
    f.VerifyQuickInfoAt(t, "1", "var someVar: number", "Some var")
    f.VerifyQuickInfoAt(t, "2", "var otherVar: number",
        "Other var\nSee [someVar](file:///basicQuickInfo.ts#4,5-4,12)")
}

Real-world example: Editing and Completions

func TestBasicEdit(t *testing.T) {
    t.Parallel()
    defer testutil.RecoverAndFail(t, "Panic on fourslash test")
    const content = `export {};
interface Point {
    x: number;
    y: number;
}
declare const p: Point;
p/*a*/`
    f, done := fourslash.NewFourslash(t, nil /*capabilities*/, content)
    defer done()
    f.GoToMarker(t, "a")
    f.Insert(t, ".")
    f.GoToEOF(t)
    f.VerifyCompletions(t, nil, &fourslash.CompletionsExpectedList{
        IsIncomplete: false,
        ItemDefaults: &fourslash.CompletionsExpectedItemDefaults{
            CommitCharacters: &DefaultCommitCharacters,
        },
        Items: &fourslash.CompletionsExpectedItems{
            Exact: []fourslash.CompletionsExpectedItem{
                &lsproto.CompletionItem{
                    Label:    "x",
                    Kind:     new(lsproto.CompletionItemKindField),
                    SortText: new(string(ls.SortTextLocationPriority)),
                },
                "y",
            },
        },
    })
}

Marker syntax

Markers define cursor positions and text ranges in the test content:

Syntax	Description	Example
/*name*/	Named position marker	var x/*pos*/ = 1;
/*1*/, /*2*/	Numbered markers	foo(/*1*/, /*2*/)
`[	text	]`

Multi-file tests

Use // @Filename: (capital F) to define multiple files:

const content = `
// @Filename: /src/utils.ts
export function greet(name: string) { return name; }

// @Filename: /src/main.ts
import { greet } from "./utils";
greet(/*marker*/"world");
`

Setting compiler options

Embed a tsconfig.json file or use directive comments:

const content = `
// @Filename: /tsconfig.json
{ "compilerOptions": { "strict": true, "target": "es2020" } }

// @Filename: /src/test.ts
const x/*1*/ = 42;
`

2.3 Verification Methods (Common API)

The fourslash.FourslashTest type (variable f) provides these verification methods:

Quick Info / Hover

f.VerifyQuickInfoAt(t, "marker", "var x: number", "documentation text")
f.VerifyBaselineHover(t)  // generates baseline file

Completions

f.VerifyCompletions(t, "marker", &fourslash.CompletionsExpectedList{
    IsIncomplete: false,
    ItemDefaults: &fourslash.CompletionsExpectedItemDefaults{
        CommitCharacters: &DefaultCommitCharacters,
        EditRange:        Ignored,
    },
    Items: &fourslash.CompletionsExpectedItems{
        Includes: []fourslash.CompletionsExpectedItem{
            &lsproto.CompletionItem{Label: "myVar"},
        },
        // Or use Exact for exact match:
        // Exact: []fourslash.CompletionsExpectedItem{"x", "y"},
    },
})

Import the test utilities for shared constants:

import . "github.com/microsoft/typescript-go/internal/fourslash/tests/util"
// Provides: DefaultCommitCharacters, Ignored, CompletionGlobalThisItem, etc.

Navigation

f.VerifyBaselineGoToDefinition(t)           // baseline-based
f.VerifyBaselineGoToTypeDefinition(t)
f.VerifyBaselineGoToImplementation(t)

References and Rename

f.VerifyBaselineFindAllReferences(t)
f.VerifyBaselineRename(t)

Diagnostics

f.VerifyNoErrors(t)
f.VerifyErrorExistsBetweenMarkers(t, "start", "end")
f.VerifyBaselineNonSuggestionDiagnostics(t)

Signature Help

f.VerifyBaselineSignatureHelp(t)
f.VerifyNoSignatureHelp(t)

Editing (simulating user actions)

f.GoToMarker(t, "marker")    // move cursor to marker position
f.Insert(t, ".")             // type text at cursor
f.Backspace(t, 3)            // delete 3 characters before cursor
f.DeleteAtCaret(t, 5)        // delete 5 characters after cursor
f.Paste(t, "new text")       // paste text
f.Replace(t, start, len, "replacement")
f.GoToEOF(t)                 // move to end of file
f.GoToFile(t, "/src/main.ts") // switch to another file

Other LSP Features

f.VerifyBaselineDocumentHighlights(t)
f.VerifyBaselineDocumentSymbol(t)
f.VerifyBaselineCallHierarchy(t)
f.VerifyBaselineInlayHints(t)
f.VerifyBaselineSelectionRanges(t)
f.VerifyBaselineClosingTags(t)
f.FormatDocument(t, "/test.ts")
f.VerifyOrganizeImports(t, expectedContent, actionKind, prefs)

2.4 Running Fourslash Tests

# Run ALL tests (recommended — fast, ensures clean state, catches unexpected breakage)
npx hereby test

# For print-debugging a specific test with verbose output
go test ./internal/fourslash/tests -run TestBasicQuickInfo -v

2.5 Fourslash Baselines

Fourslash tests that use VerifyBaseline* methods generate baselines under:

testdata/baselines/reference/fourslash/<command>/

Where <command> is one of: quickInfo, signatureHelp, goToDefinition, goToType, goToImplementation, findAllReferences, documentHighlights, findRenameLocations, callHierarchy, Code Lenses, Document Symbols, Inlay Hints, etc.

File extensions vary by command:

• .baseline — quickInfo, signatureHelp, diagnostics, etc.
• .baseline.jsonc — most other features
• .baseline.md — auto imports
• .callHierarchy.txt — call hierarchy

Accept baselines the same way as compiler tests — but only after running npx hereby test:

npx hereby test              # MUST run first to clear stale baselines
npx hereby baseline-accept

2.6 Generated vs. Hand-Written Tests

Generated tests (in gen/) are auto-converted from the upstream TypeScript fourslash test suite using the script at internal/fourslash/_scripts/convertFourslash.mts. They:

• Use fourslash.SkipIfFailing(t) for tests that don't pass yet
• Should not be manually edited (they'll be overwritten on regeneration)
• Provide coverage for ported TypeScript behavior

Tests in manual/ are gen tests that have been migrated with npm run makemanual. They should not be created from scratch — only use makemanual to move a generated test that needs modification.

Hand-written tests (directly in internal/fourslash/tests/):

• Must always pass (no SkipIfFailing)
• Test specific behaviors, edge cases, or new features
• Are the right place for custom regression tests

---

3. General Testing Practices

3.1 Key hereby Commands

Command	Description
npx hereby test	Run all tests (recommended — fast, clears stale state)
npx hereby baseline-accept	Accept local baselines as new reference
npx hereby format	Format code (uses dprint)
npx hereby lint	Run linters (uses golangci-lint)

3.2 Typical Workflow

Adding a new compiler test

1. Create testdata/tests/cases/compiler/myTest.ts with test code and directives
2. Run all tests: npx hereby test
3. Review generated baselines: git diff --diff-filter=AM --no-index ./testdata/baselines/reference ./testdata/baselines/local
4. Accept (only after hereby test): npx hereby baseline-accept

Adding a new fourslash test

1. Create internal/fourslash/tests/myTest_test.go with the test function
2. Run all tests: npx hereby test
3. Review any generated baselines: git diff --diff-filter=AM --no-index ./testdata/baselines/reference ./testdata/baselines/local
4. Accept (only after hereby test): npx hereby baseline-accept

Investigating a test failure

1. Run all tests: npx hereby test
2. If a test fails, use the package and test name from the output to re-run with verbose output: go test ./internal/testrunner/ -run 'TestLocal/failingTest' -v
3. Check baseline diffs: git diff --diff-filter=AM --no-index ./testdata/baselines/reference ./testdata/baselines/local
4. If the new output is correct, run npx hereby test again, then accept: npx hereby baseline-accept
5. If not, fix the code and re-run

Debugging an unrecovered panic

If a test panics without a clear stack trace, run all tests in the package sequentially with verbose mode to identify which test caused the panic:

go test ./internal/testrunner/ -parallel=1 -v

The last test that shows as running before the panic output is the one that caused it.