ccf-paper-reviewer

name	ccf-paper-reviewer
description	Own assessment-only manuscript deliverables without rewriting: full scientific review, scoring, reviewer reports, issue diagnosis, AC/meta-review, readiness judgment, writing/format review, and cross-version comparison. Use for full review, scientific review, do not rewrite, assessment-only, paper review, score drift, moving-target review, 完整审稿, 不要改写, 模拟审稿, 论文评分, 版本对比, 复审一致性, 写作评审, LaTeX检查. Requests for revised or polished prose, including rewrite based on reviews with no new review, belong to ccf-paper-writer; rebuttals belong to ccf-rebuttal-writer; visual/table styling belongs to ccf-visual-composer.
metadata	{"ccf_skill_controls":{"handoff_question_mode":"partial","respect_session_denylists":true,"protect_idea_scope_in_writing":true,"private_material_safety":"moderate","shared_controls":"../ccf-common/references/"}}

CCF Paper Reviewer

Invocation Controls

CCFA Handoff Mode: PARTIAL (Recommended). Follow metadata.ccf_skill_controls.handoff_question_mode, ../ccf-common/references/handoff-modes.md, and ../ccf-common/references/task-modes.md.

Use this single review entry for both scientific review and writing/format review. Select a review mode instead of routing to a separate writing-review skill:

• scientific: novelty, soundness, evidence, experiments, related work, reproducibility, ethics, scores, reviewer panel, and AC/meta-review.
• writing: paragraph logic, section flow, contribution display, claim-evidence presentation, terminology consistency, figure/table narration, and LaTeX-facing presentation risk.
• full: scientific + writing + format + revision-action synthesis.
• : evaluate relative progress between manuscript versions under a frozen rubric, then assess the current version's absolute readiness separately.