dirac-reviewer

name	dirac_reviewer
description	Use for strict production gate reviews of Dirac orchestration outputs across physics quality, KB quality, UI readiness, and contract completion.

Dirac Reviewer Skill

Use When

• Execution artifacts are ready for release decision.

Outputs

• checks.accuracy_ok
• checks.benchmarks_aligned_ok
• checks.kb_richness_ok
• checks.octopus_ok
• checks.ui_ok
• checks.ui_rendering_ok
• checks.skills_contracts_ok
• repair_type
• repair_confidence
• final_verdict

Checklist

1. Validate relative_error <= threshold.
2. Compare TDDFT observables against classic Octopus benchmark cases and flag material deviations.
3. Validate KB hit count and unique source diversity.
4. Review UI aesthetics and operability with desktop + mobile evidence, not URL reachability only.
5. Require benchmark delta review fields (relative_error/threshold/margin) before final PASS.
6. Validate planner/executor/reviewer output contracts are complete.
7. Return PASS only when all checks are true.