rstudio-create-playwright-tests

name	rstudio-create-playwright-tests
description	Patterns and gotchas for authoring RStudio Playwright tests in TypeScript. Use when writing, reviewing, or migrating tests under e2e/rstudio/.

Creating RStudio Playwright Tests

Most of what you need is in e2e/rstudio/README.md (basic structure, conventions, selector hierarchy, Ace interactions, cross-platform shortcuts, sandbox, tags, package deps) and in the existing tests under e2e/rstudio/tests/. The fixture (@fixtures/rstudio.fixture) handles RStudio launch/shutdown, save-dialog dismissal, and buffer cleanup -- author tests as if the IDE starts clean.

This file covers RStudio-specific gotchas that aren't in the README.

Before writing

• Skim e2e/rstudio/tests/ for an existing similar test.
• Skim e2e/rstudio/pages/, actions/, and utils/ for existing helpers.
• Extend PageObject (panes) or FramePageObject (iframe-hosted UI) from pages/page_object_base_classes.ts when adding a page object.

Universal rules

1. pressSequentially() for GWT text inputs whose handlers fire per keystroke -- console, editor, and most input.gwt-TextBox fields in dialogs/wizards (where typing a character enables OK, triggers autocomplete, etc.). fill() doesn't fire GWT key events in those cases. Inputs driven by a discrete trigger like press('Enter') or a button click (e.g., the console Find bar) work fine with fill(), which has the bonus of replacing text instead of appending. Start with fill(); switch to pressSequentially() only if the handler doesn't fire. For GWT type-ahead widgets (e.g. the Open File dialog's file list) even pressSequentially() can outrace the per-keystroke handler -- use typeSlowly (@utils/constants, 200ms/char).

2. Force-click Ace textareas: await locator.click({ force: true }). An ace_content div overlays the hidden textarea and intercepts normal clicks. focus() is also unreliable -- keystrokes can land in the wrong pane.

3. Derive selectors from source, never use gwt-uid-XXXX (those change every restart):

   • src/gwt/.../commands/Commands.cmd.xml -- command IDs map to menu items at #rstudio_label_<sanitized_id> and toolbar buttons at #rstudio_tb_<sanitized_id> (see ElementIds.java for the sanitizer).
   • src/gwt/.../core/client/theme/DocTabLayoutPanel.java -- tab structure (.gwt-TabLayoutPanelTab, .gwt-TabLayoutPanelTab-selected, etc.).

4. Invoke RStudio commands and prefs via the window.rstudio bridge -- import helpers from @utils/commands (executeCommand, setPref, etc.). Don't use .rs.api.executeCommand(...) (slow console roundtrip) or window.desktopHooks.invokeCommand(...) (Electron-only, crashes on Server). The full bridge surface is documented in e2e/rstudio/CLAUDE.md.

5. Decision order for triggering an action: GUI button/menu/shortcut, then executeCommand(page, id), then page.evaluate() as a last resort. Clicking a button tests the real user path; the helper is for setup/teardown or when the UI path is slow/flaky/tangential to what's being tested.

6. RStudio binds some shortcuts to plain Ctrl on every platform (including macOS) -- e.g., Ctrl+Enter Run Line, Ctrl+L Clear Console, Ctrl+Space Autocomplete. Use Playwright's plain Control for those, not ControlOrMeta. If you're unsure, check what RStudio's keyboard-shortcut UI shows for the binding.

7. Tests must work on Desktop and Server. Prefer stable IDs over wrapper selectors. Tag mode-specific tests @desktop_only or @server_only rather than runtime-branching on testInfo.project.name.

Waits and markers that lie

1. Console markers can false-pass off the command echo. The command you type travels the same output/event stream you're checking, so output.includes(marker) can match the echo of cat("<marker>") even when R never ran it. Split the marker across cat() args (cat("[pw:", "ready]", sep = "")) or build probe strings with paste0().

2. Closing a project on Server reloads the page. waitForLoadState, console-visible, and console-idle can all satisfy against the old page; the late reload then breaks the next test. Use closeProjectIfOpen (@utils/project), which blocks on window.rstudio.project.isActive() === false -- a signal only the post-reload page can produce. Never hand-roll it.

3. Focus needs re-dispatch, not dispatch-once + poll. Other UI (e.g. the Assistant iframe reloading after a project open) can steal focus after your command ran. focusConsole(page) (pages/console_pane.page.ts) re-issues activateConsole inside its poll loop. Retrying helpers are for setup; keep raw one-shot dispatch only where single-dispatch behavior is itself under test.

4. Session restarts: use the helpers, respect the timing. rserver can hold undeliverable console input up to ~30s, and a suspended session's relaunch can exceed 30s. waitForSessionRestart / restartSessionWithSentinel (@utils/project) already encode both -- reuse them. ConsolePaneActions.restartSession() is the third option, for when the test needs .rs.api.restartSession() itself (e.g. its clean: argument).

5. Size timeouts to what gates the UI. The Python-interpreters modal opens only after a machine-wide scan (60s), not a flat 15s. Before tagging a test @desktop_only for "server-specific" behavior, check whether it's just slow.

6. External services: skip on service error, fail on silent nothing. Poll a three-state outcome (matched/error/pending); test.skip on error, but a timeout with neither must still fail so a regression that renders nothing isn't masked. Worked example in visual-editor.md.

7. Document paths come back home-aliased () when the file is under the rsession's home. Reuse / , which handle it -- don't compare to an absolute path yourself.

• Application.java sets ready in initializeAgent(), then calls initializeWorkbench() in the same task, so you cannot observe the gap. Work that startup defers to a later task is still pending: Scheduler.scheduleDeferred work, and timers such as the 200ms timer in PaneManager.ZoomedTabStateValue.onInit.
• initializeWorkbench() returns early with a ReloadEvent when the UI-language cookie, or the web-dialogs cookie on Electron, disagrees with its pref. It returns before it builds the workbench, and the reload it fires is delayed.

On the re-join path of a page.reload() the R session stays up, so sessionInfo.deferred_init_completed is already true and DeferredInitCompletedEvent does not fire again -- which is why ready is set in initializeAgent() at all. Gate on ready, then let the assertion wait for the element and for the timing (see the next entry).

12. expect.poll cannot assert that something never happens. It returns on the first sample that passes. When the starting state is also the passing state -- the pane is not zoomed, no dialog appeared -- the poll succeeds at once, and the test is green before the bad state arrives. Its timeout value does not help in that direction, and a fixed sleep in front of it only races the product timer. For a must-not-happen assertion, sample the predicate over a window that outlasts the deferred work, and fail on the first violation. Start that window after the first sample passes: a slow first sample can otherwise consume the whole window and check the state once. This is entry 9's trap in the other direction. Pick the signal by asking what a broken build does.

13. A stray modal reads as "intercepts pointer events". Any GWT modal renders a gwt-PopupPanelGlass overlay, so an unexpected dialog (e.g. "Error Listing Packages" after resume) surfaces as an opaque gwt-PopupPanelGlass intercepts pointer events timeout at an unrelated click. Call dismissBlockingModals (pages/modals.page.ts) after suspend/resume/restart; stable dialog-button ids are exported there (CONFIRM_BTN = #rstudio_dlg_ok, YES_BTN, NO_BTN, CANCEL_BTN).

Server mode and the sandbox

1. Use the @utils/files helpers for test-file operations, not raw Node fs. writeAndOpenFile / seedSandboxFile / removeSandboxFile / closeAndDeleteSandboxFiles auto-detect whether the workdir is writable by the test process and fall back to R-console writeLines/unlink when it isn't (Server's rsession runs as a different user; remote rsessions have a different filesystem), staying byte-identical to fs.writeFileSync (sep="", useBytes=TRUE). Git operations go through the R console, with inline -c user.name=... -c user.email=... since CI runners have no global git config. When interpolating a test-computed value into an R command, use rStringLiteral / rPathLiteral (@utils/r) -- never hand-build "${path}". @utils/heredoc sends multi-line content cleanly.

2. Components that store secrets via the OS keychain need it disabled in the fixture. Under the sandboxed HOME, macOS has no login keychain, so a keytar-based write throws a blocking "Keychain Not Found" modal; on Windows the write would instead land in the host's real Credential Manager, leaking test state onto the developer's machine.

Techniques

1. Asserting on real RPC/event traffic is a legitimate technique, not just mocking it. page.waitForResponse can pin that a specific RPC fired and inspect its body (e.g. confirm asyncHandle is set, proving it registered as async rather than blocking). page.on('response') filtered to get_events URLs, with expect.poll on the body text, can confirm how the backend delivered something (e.g. one batched event vs. many per-file events) -- detach the listener in finally. When substring-matching event names, include the JSON quotes ('"files_changed"'), since an unquoted match can also hit a similarly-named event.

2. Fixture setup should fail loudly, not as a mysterious timeout. Verify both the subprocess's exit status AND the setup script's own boolean result (a COM Save() or an AppleScript bookmark write can fail with exit code 0), then assert a unique sentinel line in console output. This turns an environment problem into one clear setup-failure message instead of a visibility timeout in every downstream test.

3. Replay a hidden-tab/iframe race deterministically instead of chasing timing. Dispatch synthetic events into the hidden iframe (el.dispatchEvent(new Event('scroll'))) or call the component's lifecycle hook directly from page.evaluate (e.g. iframe.contentWindow.onActivate()) to reproduce the race on demand, with no flaky timing needed.

4. Capturing a satellite (popout) window: register page.context().waitForEvent('page') before issuing the command that opens it, then assert the new page's URL contains the expected view=<name> marker. Works the same way for Desktop (Electron satellite) and Server.

5. Drive Ace through the AceEditor page object (pages/ace_editor.page.ts) rather than ad-hoc page.evaluate. An empty marker (new AceEditor(page, '')) resolves the active editor via the bridge -- prefer it. A non-empty marker does a .ace_editor DOM walk that can land on stale editors left after a tab close; use it only to target a non-active tab. Typed Ace bindings live in @utils/ace -- extend them there instead of casting at the call site.

6. Probe R-side state with (): runs an R expression returning one logical and reads / back from the console -- e.g. .

Feature-specific patterns

When working in these areas, also read the corresponding file:

• Code suggestions / Copilot / NES (tests/panes/editor/code_suggestions.test.ts, edit_suggestions.test.ts): see code-suggestions.md.
• Chat pane / Posit Assistant / RPC interception (tests/panes/posit-assistant-chat/): see chat-pane.md.
• Visual editor / citations (tests/panes/editor/citations.test.ts, and any test that drives the panmirror visual editor): see visual-editor.md.
• Files pane / Open File dialog (tests/panes/files/): see files-pane.md.
• Terminal pane (tests/panes/terminal/): see terminal.md.
• Auth setup / AI credentials (tests/auth.setup.ts, utils/auth.ts, or anything touching credential provisioning): see auth-credentials.md.