cg-paper-writing

name	cg-paper-writing
description	Academic paper writing for 3D vision, computer graphics, CAD, and 3D understanding. Covers NeRF, 3DGS, SLAM, point cloud, 3D shape, CAD modeling. Supports CVPR/ICCV/ECCV/SIGGRAPH venues. Multi-agent adversarial review, citation integrity gates, style calibration. Use when: writing or revising a CG/3D vision paper, drafting abstract/intro/method/experiments, running adversarial review or citation integrity check, calibrating writing style to a venue, 写论文/写paper/论文写作/CG论文/三维视觉论文.
license	Apache-2.0
user-invocable	true
metadata	{"version":"3.0.0","author":"jaccen","tags":["paper-writing","academic","computer-graphics","3dgs","nerf","computer-vision","cvpr","siggraph","adversarial-review","citation-integrity","style-calibration"],"when_to_use":["Write or revise a CG/3D vision academic paper","Draft abstract, introduction, related work, method, or experiments for a 3DGS/NeRF/CAD paper","Run adversarial review or citation integrity check on a draft","Calibrate writing style to a target venue","写论文 / 写paper / 论文写作 / CG论文 / 三维视觉论文"]}

CG Paper Writing Engine (Router)

Architecture: Axis-driven static/dynamic router. Do NOT try to apply the writing logic from memory or from this router alone. Always load fragments from disk as described below.

Step 1 — Detect Request Axes

Analyze the user's request to determine axis values:

Axis: section

User Intent	section value
Writing or revising abstract	abstract
Writing or revising introduction	intro
Writing or revising related work	related-work
Writing or revising methodology	method
Writing or revising experiments	experiments
Writing contribution statements	contribution
Full paper or unspecified section	all

Axis: venue

User Intent	venue value
Targeting CVPR/ICCV/ECCV	cvpr
Targeting SIGGRAPH/EG/PG	siggraph
Targeting NeurIPS/AAAI	neurips
Targeting TVCG/CGF/TOG/TPAMI	tvcg
Writing PhD thesis chapter	thesis
Unspecified or multi-venue	all

If the user does not specify, defaults are: section=all, venue=all.

Step 2 — Load Required Fragments

Always Load (every invocation)

Read these files from static/:

• static/core-stance.md — Role, writing process, de-AI rules, citation fact-check, guardrails
• static/symbols-terminology.md — Mathematical symbols, CG/CAD/3D terminology reference

On-Demand Load (by detected section)

section	Fragment(s) to Load
abstract	static/writing-abstract-intro.md
intro	static/writing-abstract-intro.md
related-work	static/writing-related-method.md
method	static/writing-related-method.md
experiments	static/writing-experiments.md
contribution	static/writing-experiments.md
all	All writing fragments (abstract-intro, related-method, experiments)

On-Demand Load (by detected venue)

venue	Fragment to Load
any non-all value	static/venue-formats.md
all	static/venue-formats.md

Reference Load (for review/integrity work)

• static/review-integrity.md — Multi-agent review, Devil's Advocate Protocol, citation verification, integrity gates, style calibration, writing quality check, persistence

Optimization: For a focused task (e.g., "write abstract"), load only core-stance + symbols-terminology + writing-abstract-intro + venue-formats (if venue specified). For full paper work, load all fragments.

Step 3 — Execute Writing Task

After loading the required fragments:

1. Follow section-specific templates from the loaded writing fragment
2. Apply venue-specific formatting from venue-formats.md
3. Use terminology and symbols from symbols-terminology.md
4. Observe all guardrails from core-stance.md (no fabrication, de-AI rules, citation fact-check)
5. For review/integrity work, follow protocols from review-integrity.md

Rules

1. Write in flowing prose, never bullet points (contribution statements and itemized lists excepted)
2. Every claim needs evidence: Citation or experimental data, and citations must pass three-layer verification
3. Use mathematical notation efficiently: One symbol, one meaning throughout; symbol table persisted
4. Match the venue's tone: CVPR more concise; SIGGRAPH more narrative; if style sample provided, strictly calibrate
5. Chinese academic writing: Follow Chinese academic conventions (本文/我们/由此/表明)
6. Never fabricate data: Mark missing data as <!-- DATA_NEEDED: <description> -->
7. Integrity gates cannot be skipped: Post-Draft Gate and Pre-Submission Gate must both pass
8. Adversarial review must follow concession threshold protocol: Prevent sycophancy and frame-lock
9. Claim-citation alignment: Each claim must be traceable to supporting citation, and citation must actually support the claim
10. Writing context persistence: Maintain symbol, citation, review state consistency across sessions

Red Lines

The following are categorical prohibitions. Violating any of these invalidates the output:

• No invented data: Never fabricate experimental results, method capabilities, or review outcomes. If a value is not found in the loaded files, write "data not available" or "N/A".
• No hallucinated citations: Never invent paper titles, authors, DOIs, arXiv IDs, or venue names. Only reference works explicitly present in the skill's knowledge base or provided by the user.
• No silent speculation: If you are uncertain about a technical detail, explicitly flag it with "[UNCERTAIN]" rather than presenting it as fact.
• No method misattribution: Do not assign features, results, or mechanisms from one method to another. Each method's data is specific to that method.
• No oversimplified comparisons: Do not reduce multi-dimensional trade-offs to a single "better/worse" judgment without context.

Cross-Skill Routing

This skill focuses on paper writing. For related workflows:

• Method comparison → 3dgs-method-compare (for positioning and related work tables)
• Paper reading/analysis → 3dgs-paper-reader (for understanding related work in depth)
• Experiment design → 3dgs-experiment-planner (for experiment sections)
• Visualization/figures → 3dgs-visualizer (for paper-quality figures)
• Code review → 3dgs-code-reviewer (for implementation verification)

Related Skills

• 3dgs-paper-reader — Deep reading and analysis of 3DGS papers (use for understanding related work)
• 3dgs-method-compare — Method comparison (use for positioning and related work tables)
• 3dgs-experiment-planner — Experiment design (use for experiment sections)
• 3dgs-visualizer — Visualization (use for paper-quality figures)
• 3dgs-code-reviewer — Code review (use for implementation verification)

Guardrail: Do Not Apply From Memory

Do NOT try to apply the logic, method data, bug patterns, or technical details described in this skill from memory. Always read the SKILL.md and referenced files from disk before producing any output. The knowledge base is updated frequently; stale memory may produce outdated, inaccurate, or fabricated results.

If you cannot find a method, pattern, or data point in the loaded files, say so explicitly. Never invent metrics, venue acceptances, bug patterns, or technical features not present in the source data.

If you like it, please star this repo https://github.com/jaccen/Awesome-Gaussian-Skills