play-learn-lift

name	play-learn-lift
description	Start Playing. Keep Learning. Lift Others.
license	MIT
tier	1
allowed-tools	["read_file","write_file"]
related	["moollm","bootstrap","sister-script","sniffable-python","constructionism","adventure","debugging","scratchpad","research-notebook","skill","plain-text"]
tags	["moollm","methodology","pedagogy","workflow","learning"]

Play Learn Lift

Start Playing. Keep Learning. Lift Others.

The three-stage journey from curiosity to mastery to teaching. The core MOOLLM methodology.

This is programming by demonstration (Cypher, Watch What I Do, MIT Press 1993) — except the demonstrator is you and the recording is your own session transcript. Do the thing once (PLAY), inspect how you actually did it with cursor-mirror (LEARN), and lift the procedure into a reusable skill (LIFT). Worked example, end to end: the Prestoration — one performed PDF correction, introspected from its transcript, lifted into change-name.

[!TIP] This IS the methodology. Every other skill is an expression of PLAY-LEARN-LIFT. Start here.

---

The Cycle

flowchart LR
    P["🎮 PLAY"] --> L["📚 LEARN"]
    L --> LI["🚀 LIFT"]
    LI -->|inspire| P

Stage	Motto	What Happens
🎮 PLAY	Jump in!	No prerequisites, can't break anything, curiosity drives discovery
📚 LEARN	Patterns emerge	Connections make sense, confidence builds naturally, "I noticed..."
🚀 LIFT	Help others play	Teaching solidifies learning, sharing multiplies impact

---

Why This Matters

Most learning is backwards:

• ❌ Study first, then do
• ❌ Master before sharing
• ❌ Fear mistakes

PLAY-LEARN-LIFT inverts it:

• ✅ Do first, understand emerges
• ✅ Share while learning, teaching accelerates mastery
• ✅ Mistakes are features, not bugs

---

Philosophy

"Low floor, high ceiling, wide walls" — Seymour Papert / Mitch Resnick

Principle	Meaning
Low floor	Easy to start. No prerequisites.
High ceiling	No limit to growth. Experts stay engaged.
Wide walls	Many paths to explore. Your way is valid.

Papert's constructionism anchors PLAY: build first, learn by making, then share what you built. Drescher's schema learning maps the loop: PLAY surfaces patterns, LEARN revises and stabilizes schemas, and LIFT publishes them as reusable artifacts.

Failure-Friendly

MOOLLM is unbreakable by design. Files remain transparent and inspectable. State can always be recovered. Experimentation is not just allowed but encouraged. Git acts as your safety net, catching every fall.

---

Each Stage in Detail

🎮 PLAY

"What if I just..."

• No prerequisites required
• Curiosity drives discovery
• Fun comes first
• "Oops" is learning data
• Everything is reversible (git, append-only logs)

Capture everything: Even dead ends teach something.

📚 LEARN

"I noticed you do this often..."

• Patterns become visible through repetition
• Connections make sense
• Confidence builds naturally
• Knowledge deepens organically
• The "aha!" moments

Document patterns: Future-you will thank present-you.

LEARN Sub-Phases (Platform-Legible Self-Eval)

When LEARN involves potential rule changes or skill upgrades, use explicit sub-phases:

Phase	Action	Gate
OBSERVE	Collect traces, note patterns, analyze behavior	None — always safe
PROPOSE	Draft changes, describe rationale, show diff	Review checkpoint
COMMIT	Apply changes after human approval	Human commit required

This separation makes self-evaluation "platform-legible" — automated systems can see that observation is separate from action, and rule changes require explicit human approval. The agent never modifies its own rules unilaterally.

🚀 LIFT

"Here's what I learned..."

• Teaching solidifies understanding
• Sharing multiplies impact
• Create tutorials from your journey
• Community grows stronger
• Everyone rises together

Share the journey: The path matters, not just the destination.

LIFT Provenance (Audit-Friendly Upgrades)

When LIFT produces reusable artifacts (skills, templates, procedures), include provenance:

provenance:
  source_logs: ["session-2026-01-23.md", "research-notebook/pll-analysis.yml"]
  extracted_by: "claude-opus-4"  # or human author
  reviewed_by: "don-hopkins"     # human reviewer required for skill upgrades
  lifted_at: "2026-01-23T12:00:00Z"
  rationale: "Pattern appeared 5+ times across sessions; now crystallized."

This makes upgrades audit-friendly: anyone can trace back to the original observations, see who approved the lift, and understand why the pattern was worth crystallizing.

LIFT is earned — dogfood the concrete before you abstract the generic

The most common way LIFT goes wrong is lifting too early: extracting a clean, generic skill from a shape you have only imagined, not used. You end up with a beautiful abstraction that fits nothing, because you abstracted before the concrete instance told you what it was actually for.

The gate: use the specific thing first; let it teach you the general thing.

• Build and run the concrete instance in a real playground (e.g. a repo-show) before you try to extract the generic (a reusable show skill). The generic is a reward you earn by using the specific, not a starting assumption.
• Intentional scheduling. Schedule the dogfooding as a deliberate PLAY/LEARN step — don't lift reactively the moment something looks reusable. Give it enough real use to reveal its seams, defaults, and failure modes. Then lift.
• Where lifted things go. Fundamental, reusable core and designs belong in the public, shared library (MOOLLM skills) so others can build on them. Instance-specific glue stays in the playground. LIFT is precisely the act of moving proven core down into the shared layer.

LIFT readiness checklist (all should be true before extracting a generic skill):

• The concrete instance has been used in anger more than once (not just written).
• Use surfaced at least one surprise — a default, seam, or failure the design didn't predict.
• You can name what it's good for (and what it isn't) from experience, not intention.
• The generic would serve a second, real caller — not a hypothetical one.
• Provenance (above) can point at actual logs, not plans.

Premature LIFT is Lift-Learn-Play in disguise. If you can't yet say what the thing is from having used it, you're still in PLAY. Stay there a little longer.

Lineage — Oliver Steele's Instance-First Development (2004). This gate is the methodology twin of Steele's essay Classes and Prototypes:

"one implements functionality for a single instance, and then refactors the instance into a class that supports multiple instances… This avoids premature abstraction… It's easier to generalize from two examples than from one." OpenLaszlo made the transition seamless via the Instance Substitution Principle — an instance can be replaced by its own definition without changing semantics, because class-member and instance-member definitions are syntactically parallel (prototype-based, à la Self). LIFT is exactly that refactor: you earn the class by using the instance. Steele notes it's orthogonal to test-driven development — both implement the specific first, then generalize.

---

The Cycle Continues

"Start with jazz, end with standards."

After LIFT, you discover new areas to PLAY in:

PLAY → LEARN → LIFT → (inspire) → PLAY → ...

The pun is deliberate: jazz is free exploration (PLAY), and standards are both jazz classics everyone knows AND the reusable patterns you crystallize (LIFT). The learning happens in between!

• Teaching reveals gaps in your own understanding
• Helping others sparks new questions
• The cycle accelerates with practice

---

In Practice

Solo

1. PLAY: Try something new, log what happens
2. LEARN: Review logs, find patterns, update notes
3. LIFT: Write a README, create a template, share with future-self

With Others

1. PLAY: Pair explore, capture together
2. LEARN: Compare notes, synthesize insights
3. LIFT: Write shared docs, teach newcomers

Edgebox's probe -> analyze -> call flow is an operational PLL precedent: PLAY probes, LEARN analyzes, LIFT calls.

---

The Three Sister Directories

Every skill embodies PLL through three implementation directories:

Sister	Role	PLL Phase	What Lives Here
templates/	Empathic seeds	PLAY	{{~expression}} with YAML Jazz meta-comments
examples/	Concrete instances	LEARN	Working code, real data, copyable patterns
scripts/	Lifted automation	LIFT	Doc-first tools born from repeated work

PLAY with templates → LEARN from examples → LIFT into scripts
     ↓                      ↓                     ↓
 templates/              examples/            scripts/
 (seeds)                 (patterns)           (automation)

Together: templates + examples + scripts = the complete PLL cycle

What was once "watch me do this" becomes "run this instead."

Why This Matters

• Templates are prompts for exploration — they invite the LLM to instantiate
• Examples capture what works — they're templates that have been played with
• Scripts automate what repeats — they're the ultimate LIFT product

This is why MOOLLM skills have this structure. It's not arbitrary — it's PLL crystallized into filesystem layout.

See also:

• MOOPMAP.md — The semantic pyramid, with three sisters at the base
• sister-script/ — Automation born from documentation
• cursor-mirror/ — Python structured for LLM comprehension (sniffable-python exemplar)
• no-ai-slop/examples/ — Anti-patterns documented as learning material

---

Related Skills

Skill	Connection
sister-script/	LIFT stage: automate proven patterns
research-notebook/	LEARN stage: structured capture
session-log/	PLAY stage: append-only exploration
summarize/	LEARN → LIFT: distill insights

---

Contents

File	Purpose
SKILL.md	Full methodology documentation
CYCLE.yml.tmpl	Cycle template
PLAY_LOG.md.tmpl	Play log template

---

Protocol Symbol

PLAY-LEARN-LIFT (alias: PLL)

# PROTOCOLS.yml
PLAY-LEARN-LIFT:
  meaning: "Explore freely → find patterns → share wisdom"
  invoke_when: "Starting any new exploration, learning, or teaching"
  motto: "Start Playing. Keep Learning. Lift Others."

See: PROTOCOLS.yml#PLAY-LEARN-LIFT

---

The Intertwingularity

PLL is the methodology. Other skills are its expressions.

graph TD
    PLL[🎮📚🚀 play-learn-lift] -->|PLAY captures| SL[📜 session-log]
    PLL -->|LEARN structures| RN[📓 research-notebook]
    PLL -->|LIFT automates| SS[👯 sister-script]
    PLL -->|LIFT shares| SUM[📝 summarize]
    
    AP[⚔️ adventure] -->|IS| PLAY
    DB[🔧 debugging] -->|IS| PLAY
    TC[🎴 card] -->|created via| LIFT

---

Navigation

Direction	Destination
⬆️ Up	skills/
⬆️⬆️ Root	Project Root
👯 Sister	sister-script/
📓 Sister	research-notebook/
📜 Sister	session-log/
📋 Symbols	PROTOCOLS.yml

---

Start playing. The rest follows.