council-codereview

name	council-codereview
description	Use for code review and quality feedback from both Codex and Gemini. Triggers on "council review code", "council code review", "have council review this", "get council feedback on code".

Council Code Review Skill

Comprehensive code review with both Codex (GPT-5.2) and Gemini for quality, security, and best practices.

When to Use

• Before committing or creating PRs
• Reviewing new code implementations
• Checking for security vulnerabilities
• Getting quality feedback
• When user asks for code review from the council

Reasoning Level

high (default for code review)

Execution

1. Identify the code to review:

   • Specific files mentioned by user
   • Staged git changes (git diff --staged)
   • Recent modifications

2. Gather the code content and context

3. Formulate a review prompt:

   Review this code for quality, security, and best practices:
   
   File: <filename>
   

   ```

   Please analyze:

   1. Potential bugs or logic errors
   2. Security vulnerabilities
   3. Performance issues
   4. Code style and readability
   5. Suggestions for improvement

4. Run BOTH commands in parallel:

   Codex:

   codex exec --sandbox read-only -c model_reasoning_effort="high" "<prompt>"
   

   Gemini:

   gemini -s -y -o json "<prompt>"
   

5. Synthesize review findings

Response Format

## AI Council Code Review

### Codex (GPT-5.2) Review:
**Issues Found:**
- [Severity: High/Medium/Low] [Issue description]

**Security Concerns:**
- [Any security issues]

**Suggestions:**
- [Improvement suggestions]

---

### Gemini Review:
**Issues Found:**
- [Severity: High/Medium/Low] [Issue description]

**Security Concerns:**
- [Any security issues]

**Suggestions:**
- [Improvement suggestions]

---

### Council Synthesis:
**Critical Issues (Both Agree):**
- [Issues identified by both - highest priority]

**Additional Concerns:**
- [Issues only one model caught]

**Agreed Best Practices:**
- [Suggestions both models recommend]

**Final Verdict:** [LGTM / Needs Changes / Blocking Issues]

---
*Session IDs: Codex=[id], Gemini=[id]*