| name | value-proposition-canvas |
| description | Maps value propositions using the Value Proposition Canvas framework with customer jobs, pains, and gains. Use when refining your product-market fit messaging. |
| allowed-tools | Read Write Glob |
| metadata | {"author":"matthewhitcham","version":"1.0"} |
Value Proposition Canvas
When to Use This Skill
Use this skill when you need to:
- Map your value proposition against specific customer segments
- Identify customer jobs, pains, and gains to inform product and messaging decisions
- Align your product features with what customers actually care about
- Articulate why your offer is the best solution for a specific audience
DO NOT use this skill for competitive analysis, pricing strategy, or brand identity work. This is for structured value proposition mapping using the canvas framework.
Core Principle
YOUR VALUE PROPOSITION IS NOT WHAT YOU THINK YOUR PRODUCT DOES — IT IS THE OVERLAP BETWEEN WHAT YOUR CUSTOMER NEEDS AND WHAT YOU UNIQUELY DELIVER. THE CANVAS REVEALS THAT OVERLAP.
Phase 1: Brief
Required Inputs
| Input | What to Ask | Default |
|---|
| Product/service | "What do you offer?" | No default — must be provided |
| Target customer | "Who is this for? Be specific." | No default — must be provided |
| Current messaging | "How do you currently describe your product?" | Whatever they share |
| Customer research | "Have you talked to customers? What do they say?" | Limited or anecdotal |
| Competitors | "Who else solves this problem?" | General awareness |
GATE: Confirm inputs before building the canvas.
Phase 2: Customer Profile (Right Side of Canvas)
Customer Jobs
Identify what the customer is trying to accomplish:
## Customer Jobs
**Functional Jobs (tasks they need to complete):**
1. [Job 1 — e.g., "Send professional invoices to clients"]
2. [Job 2 — e.g., "Track which invoices are paid and overdue"]
3. [Job 3 — e.g., "Manage cash flow across multiple clients"]
**Social Jobs (how they want to be perceived):**
1. [Job — e.g., "Look professional and established to clients"]
2. [Job — e.g., "Be seen as organized and on top of finances"]
**Emotional Jobs (how they want to feel):**
1. [Job — e.g., "Feel confident about business finances"]
2. [Job — e.g., "Reduce stress around getting paid"]
Customer Pains
## Customer Pains
**Frustrations:**
1. [Pain — e.g., "Creating invoices from scratch takes too long"]
2. [Pain — e.g., "Chasing late payments is awkward and time-consuming"]
**Risks/Fears:**
1. [Pain — e.g., "Worried about looking unprofessional"]
2. [Pain — e.g., "Fear of cash flow gaps sinking the business"]
**Obstacles:**
1. [Pain — e.g., "Don't know what to include on an invoice"]
2. [Pain — e.g., "No system for tracking who owes what"]
Customer Gains
## Customer Gains
**Required Gains (must-haves):**
1. [Gain — e.g., "Invoices sent and paid reliably"]
**Expected Gains (standard expectations):**
1. [Gain — e.g., "Professional-looking invoices"]
2. [Gain — e.g., "Easy tracking of payment status"]
**Desired Gains (would love to have):**
1. [Gain — e.g., "Automated payment reminders"]
2. [Gain — e.g., "One-click invoice creation"]
**Unexpected Gains (wow factors):**
1. [Gain — e.g., "Cash flow forecasting based on invoice data"]
GATE: Review the customer profile before mapping the value side.
Phase 3: Value Map (Left Side of Canvas)
Products and Services
List what you offer that addresses the customer jobs.
Pain Relievers
For each customer pain, show which feature or aspect of your product relieves it.
Gain Creators
For each customer gain, show how your product creates or amplifies it.
Fit Analysis
## Value Proposition Fit
| Customer Pain/Gain | Your Solution | Fit Strength |
|--------------------|---------------|-------------|
| [Pain 1] | [Feature/benefit] | Strong / Moderate / Weak |
| [Pain 2] | [Feature/benefit] | Strong / Moderate / Weak |
| [Gain 1] | [Feature/benefit] | Strong / Moderate / Weak |
Highlight:
- Strong fits — these are your core selling points
- Weak fits — gaps to address in product development or acknowledge in messaging
- Unaddressed jobs/pains — opportunities or boundaries to communicate
Phase 4: Polish
1. Value Proposition Statement
Distill the canvas into a single statement:
For [target customer] who [job to be done],
[Product name] is the [category] that [key benefit].
Unlike [alternative], we [key differentiator].
2. Messaging Hierarchy
Rank the value proposition elements by importance:
- Primary message (the #1 pain you relieve)
- Secondary messages (2-3 supporting gains)
- Proof points for each message
3. Application Guide
Show how to use the canvas output for:
- Sales page headlines and copy
- Ad messaging and targeting
- Product development priorities
- Customer support scripts
Anti-Patterns
- Listing features instead of jobs — "We have a dashboard" is a feature. "Track all invoices in one place" is a job.
- Guessing customer pains — if you have not talked to real customers, the canvas is fiction. Base it on research.
- Trying to fit everything — you cannot relieve every pain and create every gain. Focus on the strongest fits.
- One canvas for multiple segments — different customer segments have different jobs, pains, and gains. Create a separate canvas per segment.
- Never updating the canvas — customer needs evolve. Revisit quarterly.
Recovery
- No customer research: Recommend 5 short interviews with existing or potential customers. Provide interview questions to use.
- Too many customer segments: Start with the highest-value or largest segment. Complete one canvas fully before starting another.
- Weak fit across the board: This is valuable insight — it may mean the product needs repositioning or the target customer needs to change.
- User cannot articulate their differentiator: Use the canvas to find it. The overlap between customer needs and what competitors miss is the differentiator.
