collision-relationships

name

collision-relationships

description

Collision Relationships in FlatRedBall2. Use when working with AddCollisionRelationship, MoveFirstOnCollision, BounceOnCollision, MoveBothOnCollision, CollisionOccurred / CollisionStarted / CollisionEnded events, collision response, collision setup, mass/elasticity, entity-vs-entity collision, screen boundaries, keeping entities in bounds, walls, floors, ceilings, static geometry, sensor shapes, awareness radius, trigger zones, zone-enter/zone-exit detection, or broad-phase partitioning (Factory<T>.PartitionAxis, DeepCollisionCount). Trigger on any collision-related question.

Collision Relationships in FlatRedBall2

Screen.AddCollisionRelationship<A,B> registers a pair of collidable groups. Each frame, after physics runs, every entity in group A is tested against every entity in group B. If they overlap, the configured response fires.

Basic Setup

Call AddCollisionRelationship inside Screen.CustomInitialize after creating your factories:

AddCollisionRelationship<Player, Wall>(_playerFactory, _wallFactory)
    .MoveFirstOnCollision();

Self-Collision (Same List)

To collide entities within the same list (e.g., enemies pushing each other apart):

AddSelfCollisionRelationship<Enemy>(_enemyFactory)
    .MoveBothOnCollision(firstMass: 1f, secondMass: 1f);

Iterates unique unordered pairs only — no duplicate checks, and never an entity against itself. Set AllowDuplicatePairs = true if CollisionOccurred should also fire in the (b, a) ordering (physics still runs once per pair).

Fluent Modifiers

Method	Effect
.MoveFirstOnCollision()	A gets pushed out, B stays fixed. Use for player vs. solid walls.
.MoveSecondOnCollision()	B gets pushed out, A stays fixed.
.MoveBothOnCollision(firstMass, secondMass)	Both objects share the separation weighted by mass.
.BounceFirstOnCollision(elasticity)	A bounces off B; B stays fixed. Use for a ball vs. immovable walls.
.BounceSecondOnCollision(elasticity)	B bounces off A; A stays fixed. Mirror of the above when the static side is A.
.BounceBothOnCollision(firstMass, secondMass, elasticity)	Both sides bounce; separation splits by mass ratio (equal masses share equally).
.BounceOnCollision(firstMass, secondMass, elasticity)	Escape hatch for the asymmetric raw-mass case. Prefer the three above.

Responding to Collision Events

CollisionOccurred fires once per overlapping pair per frame, after position separation and velocity adjustment have been applied.

Entity logic

AddCollisionRelationship<Bullet, Enemy>(_bullets, _enemies)
    .MoveFirstOnCollision()
    .CollisionOccurred += (bullet, enemy) =>
    {
        enemy.TakeDamage(bullet.Damage);
        bullet.Destroy();
    };

Physics customization

Override velocity after the engine's response:

AddCollisionRelationship(_balls, _paddles)
    .BounceFirstOnCollision()
    .CollisionOccurred += (ball, paddle) =>
    {
        ball.VelocityX = /* custom value */;
        ball.VelocityY = /* custom value */;
    };

Triggers (no physics response)

Omit the fluent modifier entirely:

AddCollisionRelationship(_balls, _deathZoneFactory)
    .CollisionOccurred += (ball, _) =>
    {
        _ballFactory.Destroy(ball);
        OnBallLost();
    };

To keep a response configured but decide per collision whether it happens, set ArePhysicsAppliedAutomatically = false and call ApplyPhysics(a, b) from the handler for the pairs that should separate. Different from omitting the modifier: the masses and move/bounce choice still exist, so the response can be applied later rather than never.

Enter/Exit Events — CollisionStarted / CollisionEnded

CollisionStarted fires once on the first frame a pair begins overlapping. CollisionEnded fires once when a previously-overlapping pair stops overlapping. Use these instead of hand-rolling a per-frame _wasOverlapping bool.

var rel = AddCollisionRelationship(_player, _iceZones);
rel.CollisionStarted += (_, zone) => _player.ApplyMovementProfile(zone.Profile);
rel.CollisionEnded   += (_, _)    => _player.ResetMovementProfile();

• Fires on resolving relationships too, not just triggers. Started is useful for footstep sounds, dust puffs, landing-animation triggers.
• Order on entry frame: physics response → CollisionStarted → CollisionOccurred.
• Destroying a side mid-overlap fires Ended synchronously on the same frame (e.g. inside a CollisionOccurred handler). The destroyed entity's shapes have already been cleared by the time the handler runs, so use the argument for identity only — don't query geometry.
• Tunneling: if an entity moves so fast it overlaps for zero frames, neither event fires. Same limitation as CollisionOccurred.
• Zero-overhead when unused — no tracking runs if neither event has a subscriber.

Turning a Relationship Off — IsEnabled

rel.IsEnabled = false stops the automatic per-frame run. rel.RunCollisions() is public and still works while disabled, so game code can drive collision on its own schedule.

Landmine: disabling fires CollisionEnded immediately for every pair overlapping at that moment, and re-enabling refires CollisionStarted for pairs still overlapping — an enter/exit counter sees one extra pair of events per toggle.

Execution Order

Collision runs after physics and before CustomActivity — by the time game logic runs, entities are already separated from any overlapping collision partner. See engine-overview for the full frame loop.

Tile Collision (TileShapes)

TileShapes implements ICollidable and works as static geometry with the entities, staticGeometry overload:

var tiles = new TileShapes { GridSize = 16f };
tiles.AddTileAtCell(col, row);   // or AddTileAtWorld(x, y)
tiles.AddRectangleBorder(0, 0, cols - 1, rows - 1); // perimeter wall ring in one call

// TileShapes has a dedicated overload — no explicit type arguments needed
AddCollisionRelationship(_playerFactory, tiles)
    .MoveFirstOnCollision();

SolidSides on adjacent tiles are maintained automatically — interior shared edges are cleared so entities glide across flat surfaces without snagging on seams.

SlopeMode (per-relationship)

When one side is a TileShapes containing polygon (slope) tiles, relationship.SlopeMode controls how overlap is resolved:

• SlopeCollisionMode.Standard (default) — SAT. Correct for top-down games and for non-player pairs (e.g., a ball bouncing off the same level tiles).
• SlopeCollisionMode.PlatformerFloor — vertical-only heightmap separation on floor slopes, with preferential landing. Use on the platformer player's relationship.

SlopeMode lives on the relationship — not the collection — specifically so the same level geometry can be used with different semantics per relationship (e.g., player = PlatformerFloor, kicked ball = Standard).

PlatformerFloor mode also automatically contributes this collection as a ground-snap target for any entity in the relationship that implements IPlatformerEntity — no separate "SnapTarget" wiring required. See the platformer-movement skill for how to configure CollisionShape / SlopeSnapDistance on the behavior.

var playerVsTiles = AddCollisionRelationship(_playerFactory, solidTiles);
playerVsTiles.SlopeMode = SlopeCollisionMode.PlatformerFloor;
playerVsTiles.BounceFirstOnCollision(elasticity: 0f);

// Same solidTiles, different relationship, Standard SAT — no conflict.
AddCollisionRelationship(_ballFactory, solidTiles)
    .BounceFirstOnCollision(elasticity: 0.7f);

Prefer TileShapes over individual wall entities for static level geometry. Individual entities sharing edges will cause the player to snag on seams between adjacent tiles because each entity maintains its own SolidSides independently. TileShapes solves this by automatically suppressing interior shared edges. Use individual wall entities only when tiles need independent behavior (e.g., destructible blocks, moving platforms) — and for grid-shaped arrangements of those, set Factory<T>.IsSolidGrid = true so the factory applies the same seam suppression across adjacent cells (see entities-and-factories skill).

OneWayDirection (jump-through / cloud platforms)

relationship.OneWayDirection restricts a relationship so separation only fires when the entity is being pushed in the configured direction. All four directions (Up/Down/Left/Right) plus None (default) are supported — Up for jump-through floors, Down for ceiling-only barriers, Left/Right for one-way doors.

var cloudTiles = new TileShapes { GridSize = 16f };
cloudTiles.AddTileAtCell(3, 5);

var playerVsClouds = AddCollisionRelationship(_playerFactory, cloudTiles);
playerVsClouds.OneWayDirection = OneWayDirection.Up;
playerVsClouds.CanDropThrough = true; // opt in to Down+Jump drop-through for clouds
playerVsClouds.BounceFirstOnCollision(elasticity: 0f);

Semantics — three gates, all must pass:

• Separation has the correct sign on the gated axis (e.g. sep.Y > 0 for Up, sep.X < 0 for Left).
• Velocity on the gated axis matches the push direction or is zero (e.g. VelocityY <= 0 for Up — an upward-moving entity passes through even when SAT would push it onto the top).
• LastPosition on the gated axis was at or beyond the post-separation position (entity was cleanly on the correct side last frame, not peaking inside from the wrong side). For Up on sloped tiles this is slope-aware (surface-Y delta between LastPosition.X and current X is folded in so uphill walking passes); other directions use a flat gate.

The off-axis component of the separation is zeroed before applying — an entity clipping a platform's edge is pushed in the gated direction only, never sideways. This matches FRB1 cloud behavior.

Sloped cloud platforms (polygon jump-through tiles)

For sloped one-way tiles (polygon cells in the TileShapes) you must also set SlopeMode = PlatformerFloor. Without it the collection falls back to SAT, the slope-aware LastPosition gate doesn't run, and the player falls through while walking uphill.

var cloudTiles = new TileShapes { GridSize = 16f };
cloudTiles.AddPolygonTileAtCell(3, 5, rightAscendingSlopePrototype);

var playerVsClouds = AddCollisionRelationship(_playerFactory, cloudTiles);
playerVsClouds.OneWayDirection = OneWayDirection.Up;
playerVsClouds.CanDropThrough = true;
playerVsClouds.SlopeMode = SlopeCollisionMode.PlatformerFloor; // required for sloped clouds
playerVsClouds.BounceFirstOnCollision(elasticity: 0f);

Moving-platform velocity transfer (automatic for platformer entities)

When an IPlatformerEntity lands on top of a regular Entity (separation pushes the platformer upward), the engine automatically feeds the other entity's VelocityX into the platformer for that frame — the player rides the platform and inherits its horizontal momentum on jump. No opt-in flag; works on any relationship configured with the standard player setup. Tile collections are excluded (tiles don't have a meaningful velocity). See platformer-movement for the full picture.

CanDropThrough — cloud platforms vs. hard one-way barriers

OneWayDirection and player drop-through are intentionally separate concerns:

• CanDropThrough = true — this relationship honors IPlatformerEntity.Platformer.IsSuppressingOneWayCollision; when the player drop-through flag is active (Down+Jump, or airborne with Down held), the pair is skipped entirely. Use for cloud platforms / jump-through floors.
• CanDropThrough = false (default) — player drop-through input is ignored; the relationship always blocks in the configured direction. Use for hard one-way barriers (e.g. Yoshi's Island ratchet doors) that should never be passable the wrong way.

Both forms are driven by the same OneWayDirection gate — the only difference is whether drop-through can bypass them. See the platformer-movement skill for drop-through wiring on the behavior.

Default vs Non-Default Collision Shapes

Every shape attached with Add(shape) joins the entity's default collision — it participates in every CollisionRelationship the entity is on. That's what you want for the main body, but not for auxiliary shapes like:

• Awareness radius / trigger zone — larger shape that fires events but shouldn't push the entity.
• Weak spot — shape hit by bullets but not by terrain.
• Probe (ledge-detect, wall-slide-detect) — small shape queried manually via CollidesWith.
• Muzzle point / attach anchor — positional reference only, no collision at all.

If any of those join default collision, the entity gets shoved around by its own probes or weak spots. The fix is a single flag:

Body = new AARect { Width = 14, Height = 14 };
Add(Body); // default collision — participates in relationships

Sensor = new Circle { Radius = 64 };
Add(Sensor, isDefaultCollision: false); // attached, moves with entity, but NOT in default collision

_footProbe = new AARect { Width = 2, Height = 2, Y = -1 };
Add(_footProbe, isDefaultCollision: false); // manual-query only

SetDefaultCollision(shape, bool) flips the flag after the fact if needed.

Using a non-default shape in its own relationship

Register the shape's selector on the relationship — default collision stays untouched, the non-default shape participates only in this one:

AddCollisionRelationship<Enemy, Player>(_enemies, _playerFactory)
    .WithFirstShape(e => e.Sensor)
    .CollisionOccurred += (enemy, player) => enemy.Alert(player);

AddCollisionRelationship<Bullet, Enemy>(_bullets, _enemies)
    .WithSecondShape(e => e.WeakSpot)
    .CollisionOccurred += (b, e) => e.TakeCritical(b.Damage);

Using a non-default shape for manual queries

Probes queried each frame don't need a relationship at all — just call CollidesWith directly:

// Ledge detection
if (_patrolInput.X > 0f && !_rightFoot.CollidesWith(SolidCollision))
    _patrolInput.X = -1f;

Footgun: forgetting isDefaultCollision: false on a probe/sensor silently drags the entity into collision responses (e.g., a ground-check probe pushing the entity upward every frame → jitter). If an entity misbehaves near terrain, check every Add call for this flag first.

Common Pitfalls

• Both sides move when only one should — Use .MoveFirstOnCollision() for solid terrain.
• Nothing happens on collision — Confirm both entities have visible, correctly-sized shape children.
• Type argument mismatch on overloads — AddCollisionRelationship<Enemy>(_enemies, _players) is not the 2-list overload. Use two type args for entity-vs-entity (<Enemy, Player>), AddSelfCollisionRelationship<Enemy>(_enemies) for same-list collision, and no explicit type args for TileShapes.
• Player tunnels through thin walls — Discrete collision detection; keep velocities reasonable.
• Don't use a DiedThisFrame flag — The frame order is collision → entity CustomActivity → screen CustomActivity. A flag set during collision is stale by the time the screen reads it. Instead, destroy entities directly in CollisionOccurred and detect cleared groups via _factory.Instances.Count == 0.
• Platformer gotcha: using the raw BounceOnCollision(firstMass, secondMass, elasticity) with swapped masses can make the player phase through the floor. Prefer BounceFirstOnCollision / BounceSecondOnCollision / BounceBothOnCollision — they name the intent and don't require decoding mass numbers at the call site.

Bounce Family — Practical Defaults

Prefer the named methods; they expand into the mass numbers for you:

Scenario	Call
Moving entity bounces off static geometry (wall, floor, ceiling)	.BounceFirstOnCollision(elasticity)
Static side is A, moving side is B (mirror of above)	.BounceSecondOnCollision(elasticity)
Entity vs entity, both sides move (equal or weighted masses)	.BounceBothOnCollision(firstMass, secondMass, elasticity)
Anything weirder	.BounceOnCollision(firstMass, secondMass, elasticity) (escape hatch)

Elasticity: 1.0f = perfectly elastic; 0.9f = 10% energy loss per bounce; 0f = no bounce.

Why name the intent? In the raw BounceOnCollision(firstMass, secondMass, elasticity), "which side moves" is encoded as a pair of numbers — (0, 1, e) means "first is displaced, second is fixed", same shape of call as (1, 1, e) for "both balls move." The named methods make the intent obvious without requiring the reader to decode masses.

On the raw form: lower mass → more displacement. firstMass = 0f means A takes all the separation and B stays fixed (the wall case). Only matters when you need asymmetric non-0/non-1 masses, e.g. a light puck (mass 0.3) vs a heavier paddle (mass 1).

Shape Dispatch

Collision between any two entity types just works — the engine inspects the shape children of each entity at runtime and resolves the overlap automatically. What shapes the entities contain doesn't matter; you don't need to know or specify them at the call site.

Concave Polygon shapes are fully supported: the engine automatically decomposes them into convex parts internally. No manual decomposition is needed and reading CollisionDispatcher.cs is never necessary.

Broad-Phase Partitioning (Performance)

Setting Factory<T>.PartitionAxis to either Axis.X or Axis.Y enables axis-based partitioning, which reduces the deep collision count. Once the PartitionAxis is set, partitioning happens automatically.

Partitioning requires a Factory<T> on both sides of the relationship, and both factories must use the same axis. A relationship built from a plain List<T>, a single entity, or a TileShapes always checks every pair, because none of those is a factory and none has a PartitionAxis to set.

_bulletFactory.PartitionAxis = Axis.X;
_enemyFactory.PartitionAxis = Axis.X;
AddCollisionRelationship<Bullet, Enemy>(_bulletFactory, _enemyFactory);

If the two axes differ, or either one is left null, the relationship silently falls back to checking every pair.

• A self-collision relationship uses a single factory, so only that factory needs a PartitionAxis.
• To confirm partitioning is working, read relationship.DeepCollisionCount. It drops well below n×m once the sweep engages. PerformanceMonitor.GetCollisionReport() (see the performance skill) also reports a PartitionStatus for every relationship, and Unpartitioned is the only value that means something you can fix.
• Choose the axis your entities spread out along most. A wide side-scrolling level partitions best on Axis.X.

Object Size (BroadPhaseRadius)

Each entity's own BroadPhaseRadius (farthest shape edge from center, aggregated across attached shapes) grows and shrinks automatically as shapes are added, removed, resized, moved, or reparented — no manual invalidation needed. ICollidable.BroadPhaseRadius has no default body; Entity supplies the aggregation itself, so every game entity gets it for free.

The sweep itself never reads an individual entity's radius — it uses one shared upper bound per factory (Factory<T>.PartitionMaxRadius, internal), the largest BroadPhaseRadius any entity in that factory has ever reached. A single per-factory bound keeps the sweep's edge order valid even when entities in the same factory have very different sizes; the tradeoff is a slightly wider (but still correct) candidate window when sizes vary a lot.